Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The gender binary is a settler colonial invention, only by starting our analysis at the subjugation of the Two-Spirit can we have an effective queering of discourse

Singer No Date [Phoenix A., former Transgender Justice Policy Fellow at Basic Rights Oregon and Indigenous and transgender activist. Colonialism, Two-Spirit Identity, and the Logics of White Supremacy. Portland State University.]

Before the colonization of this land, there were as many as six traditional gender orientation roles among numerous tribes (Cameron, 124). However, due to boarding schools erasing these traditions through the Christianization of those who would later become the Elders within our community, the Christianized related the existence of the Two-Spirit as sin (Cameron,124) and this is because we have internalized the dominant culture’s concepts of gender and sexuality (Driskill, 55). The Western Gender Binary is thus superimposed upon all cultures and their histories seen through the gaze of not only male dominance but a male/female paradigm that does not account for the existence of third, fourth, fifth and even more varieties of non-male/female expressions and identities. Colonization, as previously elaborated upon, brought to Indigenous societies the patriarchy and beliefs of natural male dominance. But an overlooked aspect of the patriarchy - this Western gender binary, also found its way impacting Indigenous thought through the process of colonization. The Western Gender Binary does not see the Two-Spirit, the Western Gender Binary only sees a Man acting in “Unmanly” ways or a Woman acting in “Unwomanly” ways. What has resulted from this has been our very own communities becoming hostile to Gay, Lesbian, Bi/Pan, Trans* and Two-Spirit Indigenous peoples due to the influence of violent and assimilative colonialism. Many of these people not being accepted by their own families, by their own tribes, even those with traditions normalizing their existences. A further demonizing of Native bodies occurs when the Native refuses to conform to the invading culture’s normative behaviors of gender expression. The influence of Western culture on the erasure of Indigenous “Queer” and Two -Spirit peoples has created a system of sexual assault, homophobia and transphobia used against our peoples, entangled with the history of colonialism (Driskill, 51). As part of the settler mentality, we can see these actions as colonial violence against the Two-Spirit (ibid) and are also the results of genocide (Driskill, 52). To reiterate previous statements, the Western gender binary is a form of superimposed and universalized colonialism upon Indigenous bodies and minds. Often, the fight for decolonization fails to include or may even openly alienate and exclude Indigenous “Queers,” Two -Spirits, non-cisnormative and non-heteronormative individuals. Even amongst those attempting post colonialism, the adverse effects of gendered colonialism finds itself difficult to erase from the consciousness. Be that as it may one not achieve decolonization without also including an eradication of the Western gender binary. Healing our identities is part of the ongoing process of decolonization (Driskill, 51) because besides our land, our identities are colonized as well (Driskill, 52) and expressing our identities as Two-Spirit peoples is to resist colonialist definitions defining who we are while also proclaiming ourselves sovereign from the identities of the white dominated LGBTQ rights movement (ibid). Two-Spirit is a term used to describe our experiences of intersecting oppressions (race, colonialism, queerness, sexuality transgenderism, two-spirit identity) and is therefore a culturally specific term which cannot be transferred into other cultures (Cameron, 126). Colonization operates as a mechanism of white supremacy which as previously defined is built around paranoia, white solidarity and consensus, white exclusiveness (“otherizing”), defensiveness, colonial aggression and violence. As has been described, white supremacy and settler-colonialism not only colonizes the bodies of Indigenous peoples, but their minds as well. This has effectively been done through the erasure of traditions and introduction of patriarchy imposed upon Indigenous peoples in the boarding schools. Settlers want the Indigenous person to “disappear” and history has shown they’ve attempted this not only through physical genocide but cultural genocide as well. This disappearance of Native peoples includes those often most threatening to patriarchy and Western culture, the Two-Spirit. White supremacy through violence has sought the destruction of the Two-Spirit. White supremacy through paranoia, considering the Two-Spirit to be sin have sought the destruction of the Two-Spirit. White supremacy through white solidarity and consensus has imposed its Western concept of sexuality and gender upon Indigenous peoples, seeking the destruction of the Two-Spirit. Assimilation and annihilation have been tools at the hands of the settler-colonialists to erase Indigenous peoples as people and as a unique set of cultures residing in the United States. Existing is therefore resistance.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.