Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Queer theory fails

Saffin 8 BODIES THAT (DON'T) MATTER: SYSTEMS OF GENDER REGULATION AND INSTITUTIONS OF VIOLENCE AGAINST TRANSGENDER PERSONS: A QUEER/CRITICAL RACE FEMINIST CRITIQUE By LORI A. SAFFIN DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY WASHINGTON STATE UNIVERSITY Program of American Studies AUGUST 2008

Despite the productive and effective strategies offered by Queer Theorizing, I am hesitant to firmly adhere only to this body of knowledge. Many academics and activists alike have challenged the political efficacy of queer theory, pointing out that the pluralizing of identity, though important, continues to denigrate the importance of race, class, and gender, as sexuality becomes the signifying element of identification. Likewise, I have concerns about the open ended politics proclaimed under Queer Theory. As John D'Emilio illustrates in 12 his account of American gay and lesbian politics, "identity" and "difference" have simultaneously served as the crux as well as the crisis for most gay and lesbian organizing.13 So, if "queer" is fluid, boundariless, oppositional, and multiplicitous, how do "we" organize around "difference" or ground in politics? What are these politics, and who sets the agenda? Queer Theory seeks ^definition in order to combat the inherent divisiveness created within identity politics and disrupt rigidly constructed binaries. However, materiality, material reality, and the lived experiences of individuals/communities residing in the margins and overlaps of structural racism, classism, sexism, and heterosexism seem overlooked. Therefore, Queer Theory, perhaps, purports alternative and liberatory strategies in theory, but encounters many difficulties when attempting coalitional politics and everyday activism

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.