Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The 1ACs approach to queerness as intrinsically subversive, counterhegemonic, and individuated cleaves the ontological from the political generating a settler neutrality that colludes with settler homo-nationalism and turns the case. The desire to dismantle the notion of identity is a settler desire for the elimination of native people.

Rosenburg 14 (Jordana Rosenberg, Literature Professor at UMass Amherst “The Molecularization of Sexuality: On Some Primitivisms of the Present,” Theory & Event Volume 17 Issue 2 GC)

To the extent that queer studies has shifted focus from queer objects to objects more generally, this shift has a double resonance. On the one hand, it represents the critical force of diasporic and queer of color critique to broaden the understanding of sexuality to a set of conjunctural questions that contextualizes the ontological illusion of subjectivity within what Roderick Ferguson describes as the ineluctably political field of subject formation and the production of desire: “If the intersections of race, gender, sexuality and class constitute social formations within liberal capitalism, then queer of color analysis obtains its genealogy within a variety of locations. We may say that women of color feminism names a crucial component of that genealogy as woman of color theorists have historically theorized intersections as the basis of social formations. Queer of color analysis extends women of color feminism by investigating how intersecting racial, gender, and sexual practices antagonize and/or conspire with the normative investments of nation-state and capital.”20

Queer of color critique insists that queerness cannot be understood in isolation from a range of social formations. In doing so, Ferguson notes that this composite of forces (“racial, gender, and sexual practices”) operates with a double valence: an “and/or” logic. It’s this “and/or” that has marked queer theory for the past decade or more. Even as queerness remains a site of resistance to what Elizabeth Freeman has indispensably termed “chrononormativity” – or, what we might understand as the demands of racial capitalism for certain forms of productivity and submission to the status quo – as Jasbir Puar has made clear, queerness has also, in crucial ways, become folded into chrononormativity. For Puar, the conspiring between queer subjects and the nation-state is marked by the “incorporation of queers into the domains of consumer markets and social recognition in the post-civil rights late twentieth century … [as] queers [enter into] the biopolitical optimization of life,” and become “tied to ideas of life and productivity.”21 In both accounts, however, we notice the ways that queer studies has expanded its focus from explicitly “queer” objects to an intersectional or conjunctural account of the social world.

In a special issue of Social Text, “What’s Queer About Queer Studies Now?,” David Eng, J. Jack Halberstam, and Jose Munoz describe this expansion as queer theory’s “subjectless turn”: “What might be called the ‘subjectless’ critique of queer studies disallows any positing of a proper subject of or object for the field by insisting that queer has no fixed political referent … A subjectless critique establishes … a focus on a ‘wide field of normalization’ as the site of social violence.”22 It should be said that this subjectless critique is, itself, marked by a kind of and/or logic. As Andrea Smith has argued, while the subjectless turn opens up queer work beyond the kind of “ethnographic multiculturalism” that attends the neoliberal Humanities more generally, there is also a tendency for this turn to ontologize queerness itself such that the fundamental plays of power that constitute that social world become normalized and de-specified. Drawing on Puar, Smith argues that the “subjectless” subject of queer critique often unwittingly puts into place a racialized subject that bears the burden of subjectivity: “Puar’s analysis of biopower suggests that modern white queer subjects can live only if racialized subjects trapped in primitive and unenlightened cultures pass away” (49).

Smith’s focus here has to do with explicating the relationship between settler colonialism and queerness – tracing how this relation comes to be encoded at the level of the body, of desire, and in the habitus of the everyday. More than this – and more to the point for our work here – Smith elucidates how origin narratives embed themselves at the heart of not only queer subject formation, but queer theory as well. Building on her claims regarding the subjectless turn, and citing Elizabeth Povinelli, Smith argues that: “queer politics and consciousness often rely on a primitivist notion of the indigenous as the space of free and unfettered sexuality that allows the white queer citizen to remake his or her [their] sexuality. However, once this sexual praxis is engaged, it does not translate into solidarity with indigenous peoples’ land struggles. The subjectless critique thus calls attention to both the importance of Native peoples within scholarly work and their disappearance within this work. At the same time, it may be the case that it is in fact a subjectless critique that disguises the fact that the queer, postcolonial, or environmentally conscious subject is simultaneously a settler subject” (52).

To reiterate: the despecification of the queer object, for Smith, runs the risk of despecifying, as well, the historical forces that make “queerness” appear legible as an ontologically abstract force in the first place: “what seems to disappear within queer theory’s subjectless critique are settler colonialism and the ongoing genocide of Native peoples” (49).23 When queerness comes to indicate an ontological or essential form of resistance, we can lose sight of the conditions that make queerness as such legible in the first place. Scott Morgensen describes this in terms of a “settler rationality” at the heart of Western queer subject-formation; “settler rationality” might thus be understood as a way for queer whiteness to appropriate fantasized forms of primitive indigeneity, so to naturalize the displacement and extermination of indigenous people from the settler colony.24

Although this is a necessarily hasty summary of recent developments in queer theory, we might say that the broadening of the ambit of queer study beyond the queer subject follows an “and/or” logic: it both reaches toward historical materialist and (pace Ferguson) intersectional analyses, and it has the potential to “conspire” with the erasure of the specificities of racial capitalism and the underlying settler-colonial logic of modern Western culture. Let us simply say, then, that the subjectless turn has been at once a turn toward the historical specification of queerness in the context of racial capitalism, and, at times, a flight into an ontological queerness that at times attenuates such specification.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.