Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Settler colonialism is at the core of the heteropatriarchy, and critiques of such heteronormativity that fail to first comprehend that role recreate settler colonialism – only a prior breakdown of the politics of the settler can resolve either impact

Morgensen 11 (Scott Lauria, assistant professor of gender studies at Queen’s University, “Spaces between Us: Queer Settler Colonialism and Indigenous Decolonization”, University of Minnesota Press, 11/17/11, pp. 1-28)//JSL

This book examines how settler colonial power relations among native and non-native people define the status "queer." It argues that modern queer subjects, cultures, and politics have developed among natives and non-natives in linked, yet distinct, ways. The imposition of colonial heteropatriarchy relegates native people and all non-native people of color to queered statuses as racialized populations amid colonial efforts to eliminate native nationality and settle native lands. Modern sexuality comes into existence when the heteropatriarchal advancement of white settlers appears to vanquish sexual primitivity, which white settlers nevertheless adopt as their own history. When modern sexuality queers white settlers, their effort to reclaim a place within settler society produces white and non-native queer politics for recognition by the state. Yet memories and practices of discrepant sexual cultures among Indigenous peoples and peoples of color persistently trouble the white settler logics of sexual modernity. For instance, native modes of kinship, embodiment, and desire such as those today called "Two-Spirit" produce Native queer modernities that denaturalize settler colonialism. the comparative studies in this book show settler colonialism as the context in which non-native and native people produce modern queer subjects, cultures, and politics. A methodological shift in native studies heralded by such scholars as Linda Tuhiwai Smith and Robert warrior theorizes settler colonialism by tracing the "intellectual histories" (Warrior) and methods of Native peoples practicing survival, resistance, and decolonization.2 Scholarship in settler colonial studies must support this turn, as when Patrick Wolfe theorizes settler colonialism as "a structure, not an event" that calls for a sustained denaturalizing critique.3 Andrea Smith calls on Native studies to refuse its "ethnographic entrapment" in the description of Native cultures and instead become an interdisciplinary site for explaining and transforming a world defined by settler colonialism.4 She promotes this shift by invoking queer theory, which displaced the description of sexual minorities in gay/lesbian studies by theorizing heteronormativity as a power relation that conditions all subjects and social life.5 Scholars at the intersections of Native and queer studies have responded to these calls by demonstrating that each field is intrinsic to the other.6 Smith explains that "the heteronormativity of settler colonialism" has subjected Native and non-Native people to settler colonial rule and regimes of modern sexuality. In this context, "queer" statuses accrue to nonheteronormative identities—such as gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender, or queer—after colonial heteropatriarchy first redefines embodiment, desire, and kinship to eliminate Native culture, control racialized populations, and secure, in Sherene Razack's term, a "white settler society." In this book, queer will refer to statuses produced by the heteropatriarchal power of white supremacist settler colonialism. My analysis joins critics of homo-normativity in arguing that all "queer" statuses are not equivalent.7 Jasbir Puar critiques "homonationalism" as the process whereby whiteness and imperialism create U.S. queer subjects as "regulatory" over peoples queered by U.S. rule.8 I resituate Puar's account to argue that in a white settler society, queer politics produces a settler homonationalism that will persist unless settler colonialism is challenged directly as a condition of queer modernities.9 Native and queer studies must regard settler colonialism as a key condition of modern sexuality on stolen land, and use this analysis to explain the power of settler colonialism among Native and non-Native people. This book investigates how settler colonialism produces what I call "non-Native queer modernities," in which modern queers appear definitively not Native—separated from, yet in perpetual (negative) relationship to, the original peoples of the lands where they live. The phrase suggests a settler colonial logic that disappears indigeneity so it can be recalled by modern non-natives as a relationship to native culture and land that might reconcile them to inheriting conquest.10 Thus, "non-native" signifies not a racial or ethnic identity but a location within settler colonialism. non-native queer modernities naturalize settler colonialism when they confront queer differences as racial or diasporic in a manner that sustains native disappearance. If queer subjects align with whiteness or homonationalism, their settler colonial roots may seem clear. But even multiracial and transnational queer critiques of racism and imperialism can erase native people and naturalize settler colonialism in ways that indirectly or directly define queer modernity as not native. This book examines "native queer modernities" as projects that formed historically precisely to displace the settler colonial logics that sustain "non-native queer modernities."

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.