Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Analyzing colonialism is a pre-req to addressing the patriarchy – they ignore the sovereignty of native nations

Smith 10 (Andrea, Smith is an American academic, feminist, and activist against violence. Smith's work focuses on issues of violence against women of color and their communities, specifically Native American women. A co-founder of INCITE! Women of Color Against Violence, the Boarding School Healing Project, and the Chicago chapter of Women of All Red Nations, Smith has based her activism and her scholarship on the lives of women of color and long claimed to be Cherokee. Formerly an assistant professor of American Culture and Women's Studies at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor, Michigan, Smith currently serves as an associate professor in the Department of Media and Cultural Studies at University of California, Riverside, “Queer Theory and Native Studies” pg 58-60 accessed 7/10 //um-tw)

The question arises, then, why is settler colonialism so seriously undertheorized in queer studies, even within queer of color critique? One possibility may be that∂ queer studies has not considered the possibility of alternative forms of national-ism that are not structured by nation-states. To be fair, queer theory does offer strong critiques of the heteronormativity of the nation-state as well as the heter-onormativity of the citizen, particularly the U.S. citizen. Puar’s and Gopinath’swork demonstrates how the noncitizen, particularly in the figure of the refugee or the immigrant, queers the state’s heteronormativity. Berlant also looks at how queer activist groups within the United States attempt to reconfigure citizenship within the current nation-state and even to question the “censoring imaginary of the state.”∂ 66∂ Muñoz similarly gestures to “beyond” the current political system when he says, “Our charge as spectators and actors is to continue disidentifying with this world until we achieve new ones.”∂ 67∂ Thus, queer theorists seem to exhibit some desire to think beyond the nation-state .At the same time, queer theory seems to lapse back into presuming the givenness of the nation-state in general, and the United States in particular. Forinstance, Berlant contends: “It must be emphasized . . . that disidentification with U.S. nationality is not, at this moment, even a theoretical option for queer citizens. . . .We are compelled, then, to read America’s lips. What can we do to force the offi-cially constituted nation to speak a new political tongue?”∂ 68∂ This statement curi-ously occludes the struggles of many indigenous peoples who have articulated themselves as belonging to sovereign nations rather than as being U.S. citizens.The reason for this occlusion can be found in another statement: Berlant contendsthat Native peoples “have long experienced simultaneously the wish to be fullcitizens and the violence of their partial citizenship.”∂ 69∂ She collapses Native peo-ples into the category of racial minority rather than recognize them as colonized peoples struggling against a settler state. So the settler state is presumed within queer theory, while (as mentionedpreviously) indigenous nationhood is imagined as simply a primitive mirror image of a heteronormative state. However, many Native scholars and activists are offering internal critiques of contemporary Native politics to imagine potentially nonheter-onormative forms of indigenous nationhood. As Taiaiake Alfred, Glen Coulthard,Denetdale, and others note, Native sovereignty struggles are themselves often articulated within, rather than in resistance to, the logics of settler colonialism.∂ 70∂ That is, articulations of Native governance and sovereignty often mimic the logics of the settler state rather than draw on forms of indigenous governance that call into question many of the logics of nation-state forms of governance. As they argue, Native sovereignty struggles often focus on gaining recognition from the surround-ing settler state. To gain this recognition, Native nations model themselves after∂ colonial states, mirroring their similar colonial logics. Coulthard explains that this politics of recognition also entraps colonized peoples in a death dance with their colonizers. The “key problem with the politics of recognition when applied to thecolonial context . . . [is that it] rests on the problematic assumption that the flour-ishing of Indigenous Peoples as distinct and self-determining agents is somehow dependent on their being granted recognition and institutional accommodation from the surrounding settler-state and society. . . . Not only will the terms of rec-ognition tend to remain the property of those in power to grant to their inferiorsin ways that they deem appropriate, but also under these conditions, the Indig-enous population will often come to see their limited and structurally constrained terms of recognition granted to them as∂ their own∂ . In effect, the colonized come to∂ identify∂ with ‘white liberty and white justice.’ ”∂ 71∂ He calls on indigenous activiststo shift their focus from seeking recognition from the settler state to seeking rec-ognition from each other as well as other oppressed communities. Native peoples’ethnographic entrapment within the academy presumes the politics of recognitionthat Coulthard critiques. That is, Native peoples are compelled to represent them-selves properly in order to gain recognition within the academy — they are notsupposed to define the terms of discourse itself. ∂ As I have discussed elsewhere, these alternative models of sovereignty are not based on a narrow definition of nation that entails a closely bounded com-munity and ethnic cleansing. Native activists often articulate indigenous forms of nationhood organized around a logic of citizenship based less on rights withina nation and more on a system of interrelatedness and mutual responsibility.∂ 72∂ Because these visions of national liberation do not necessarily entail a nation-state form of governance as their end goal, they do not imagine a social struc-ture based on social domination. As such, they can∂ potentially∂ challenge logics of heteronormativity because heteropatriarchy is a logic that naturalizes socialhierarchy. That is, if under the logic of heteropatriarchy, men are supposed torule women on the basis of biology, this social hierarchy becomes naturalized. As Karen Warren notes, social domination is effective primarily because it seemsnatural — otherwise, there is no reason why people would want to live under con-ditions of domination.∂ 73∂ Once we challenge the idea that domination is somehow “human nature,” we have the potential to question the naturalization of all its manifestations, including heteropatriarchy

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.