Gender and settlerism are intrinsically tied together- Heteropatriarchal colonialism has sexualized indigenous lands while transforming native people into violable subjugated kin to be assimilated into white settler societies- colonial heteropatriarchy structures the lives of all indigenous persons, and that divesting from it will be necessary to collective work for decolonisation.
Scott Lauria Morgensen (2012) Theorising Gender, Sexualityand Settler Colonialism: An Introduction, Settler Colonial Studies, 2:2, 2-22, DOI:10.1080/2201473X.2012.10648839, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/2201473X.2012.10648839
Indigenous feminist and LGBTQ/Two-Spirit criticisms have established the ineluctably gendered and sexual quality of settlers’ attempted conquest of indigenous peoples. This literature teaches that heteropatriarchal colonialism has sexualised indigenous lands and peoples as violable, subjugated indigenous kin ties as perverse, attacked familial ties and traditional gender roles, and all to transform indigenous peoples for assimilation within or excision from the political and economic structures of white settler societies.1 Although these lessons are recorded in scholarly texts, the violences they name have been challenged by indigenous women and LGBTQ/Two-Spirit people who organise for their own and their people’s liberations. Among many examples, the Aboriginal women’s movement in Canada, Two-Spirit organising across North America, and takatapui organising in Aotearoa New Zealand offer grounded theories of gendered and sexual colonisation and of indigenous resistance.2 Crucially, such movements do not restrict their address to persons so-identified, for they argue that colonial heteropatriarchy structures the lives of all indigenous persons, and that divesting from it will be necessary to collective work for decolonisation. Activist and intellectual legacies such as these make possible this collection and its investigations of gender, sexuality, and settler colonialism, and recur continually in our accounts. ‘Calling’, Karangatia, invokes the opening of an exchange of words in which Morgensen, ‘Theorising Gender, Sexuality, and Settler Colonialism’ 5 many will listen and may eventually speak, but within a context first defined by indigenous women who call a diversity of gendered and sexual subjects into conversation. This title, by Michelle Erai’s suggestion, positions both the issue’s contents and our collaboration as co-editors. Whereas I write this introduction as sole author, I do so to present my response as a white settler critic to a context of speaking, listening, learning, and acting that has been defined by the calls of indigenous feminist and LGBTQ/Two-Spirit scholars and activists. With these histories in mind, this introduction and our collection theorise gender, sexuality, and settler colonialism by advancing beyond similar scholarship in colonial studies. For some time now, the very ubiquity of feminist and queer accounts in colonial studies has appeared to explain gender and sexuality in settler-colonial situations. Yet as recent scholarship indicates, the specificity of settler colonialism is obscured if it is presumed to have been explained by general theories of ‘colonialism’.3 All such theories must be revisited to ask if they erroneously generalise specific colonial situations, and to provincialise all such situations by positioning them comparatively. Scholars in colonial and postcolonial studies long have observed that colonial rule comes into being by mobilising gendered and sexual power. Yet this observation in itself does not denaturalise gender or sexuality, as is apparent when even major texts in these fields leave the impression that a natural gendered or sexual order underlies what colonial violence produced.4 Anticolonial feminist and queer accounts show that colonisation’s sexual and gendered methods are inventive, not foreordained; and that liberation will follow disturbing all that colonisation taught, so that distinctive ways of life might be recalled or imagined. Such accounts position ‘gender’ and ‘sexuality’ alongside ‘race’ and ‘nation’ as analytical categories that are freed from any universal referent, in that they designate power-laden arenas of contested knowledge and embodied practice that call for critical and creative engagement. While such insights appear diversely without cohering in any single body of work, they were made possible by the signal contributions of critics within feminist antiracist and anticolonial movements. Indigenous, Black, US/Third World, and women of Morgensen, ‘Theorising Gender, Sexuality, and Settler Colonialism’ 6 colour feminisms synergised with feminists engaged in anticolonial and postcolonial nationalism to displace white settler and Western feminist thought: a history that at the end of the 20th century produced postcolonial and transnational feminisms as arenas where scholars across the global north and south could form alliances in critiquing colonial, racial, gendered, and sexual power.5 The scholarly projects of queer of colour and queer diasporic critique formed in relation to these lineages, as have transnational queer studies that trouble racial or diasporic identity to address the global and imperial scales of sexual power.6 Denaturalising gender, sexuality, race, and nation is a hallmark of such work, as when Chandra Mohanty’s review of writings from the 1980s argued for ‘the inherently political definition of the term women of color’ as designating ‘a political constituency, not a biological or even sociological one’ that coheres around ‘a common context of struggle’. 7 Jacqui Alexander joined Chandra Mohanty in emphasising their commitments to decolonisation, arguing that if ‘decolonization involves thinking oneself out of the spaces of domination’, then this will transpire only ‘through praxis’, which they sought by holding their work responsible to ‘the concrete analyses of collective and organizational practice within feminist communities that offer provisional strategies for dismantling the psychic and social constellations put in place by colonization’. 8