Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Queer Subject formation depends upon indigeneity as a transitive site for the manifestation of desire as a subject.

Jodi A. Byrd 18 (citizen of the Chickasaw Nation of Oklahoma and associate professor of English and Gender and Women's Studies at the University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign where she is also a faculty affiliate at the National Center for Supercomputing Applications, “LOVING UNBECOMING: The Queer Politics of the Transitive Native,” CRITICALLY SOVEREIGN: Indigenous Gender, Sexuality, and Feminist Studies, joanne barker,-editor, /ejb)

As an emergent field in its own right, then, queer Indigenous studies has begun to stage difficult and important questions about the nature of identity and its discontents, posing quandaries about the possibilities and limits of the transformative politics of gender and sexuality especially where they intersect with race, transnationalism, and colonialism. As queer Indigenous studies begins to articulate some of the stakes for culturally and tribally inflected counter-practices of gender and sexuality, kinship, governance, and relationally, one of the remaining challenges for the field is to interrogate whether the queer in Indigenous studies is the same as the queer in queer studies. At first blush, it might be tempting to assume that the answer is self-evident, the question slightly coy. The question, however, might trouble some of the methodological, theoretical, and quotidian horizons that intersectionality and interdisciplinarity seek to make visible within the fields of Indigenous, gender, and sexuality studies. The queer within Indigenous studies has already come to signify a range of prescribed practices attached to decolonizing desire, gender performance, kinship socialities, and relationities to land and community. Faced with the quandaries that the colonial, racial, gendered, and historical disjunctions of encounter, contact, and orientation have left us, what can desire and grief mean to the colonized if they signal, at their core, modes of dispossession, undoing, firsting, and lasting? What might the subjectlessness that Andrea Smith suggests as intervention to ethnographic entrapment offer queer Indigenous critique if it disallows anything fixed, grounded, located, or, most important, accountable to community, relationality, and connection? As a concept, indigeneity admittedly has had and has required a political referent that is tied to land, relation, and community, even if such referents are fluid and mutable. But at the same time, and as an ideological referent that is always up for grabs, indigeneity remains elusive, ontologically ephemeral, temporally challenged, and captured within the discourses of discovery, enlightennment, and sovereignty. Caught within modes of possession and its lack, Indigenous subjectlessness at the site of the queer simultaneously straddles the threshold between the colonialist practices of replacing the Indigenous, on the one hand, and emptying the Indigenous of any prior signification, on the other. In the grammars of empire where subject formation occurs through the Hegelian dialectics of freedom and enslavement, ownership and property, civilized and savage, sovereign and beast, the Indigenous might be understood as the domain or register in which the tensions between and among these antagonisms become sensible. Indigeneity’s challenge to settler colonial subjectivity and its loss, then, requires us to shift the frame slightly askew to apprehend how the processes of subjectivity—be they queer or normative—cohere, entangle, and unravel in relation to what Elizabeth Povinelli has identified as the governance of the prior. That governance, defined as “the priority of the prior person (or people) as a natural right of all persons and the people as such emerged as an impediment to the previous logics of kingly seizure and to the emergent logic of colonial governance,” hinges on an unresolvable temporal paradox that produces the conditions of indigeneity as prior to and a priority of the law at the same time that the law abjects indigeneity from having any priority at all.24 Returning to a distinction within the conceptualization of subjectless critique may help parse some of these tensions that exist within and between the queer and the Indigenous that have made questions of subjectivity and its temporality so fraught. In Imagine Otherwise, Kandice Chuh advocates for the creation of subjectlessness as a way to “prioritize difference by foregrounding the discursive constructedness of subjectivity,” where the subject “only becomes recognizable and can act as such by conforming to certain regulatory matrices.”25 I want to pry open this space of subjectivity, its regulatory matrices, and its queer refusals to posit that a prior presence, whether we name it Indigenous or something else, retains key transitive properties that enable and, in fact, are required to adhere relationality within the intimacies and violence of empire. According to Karen Elizabeth Gordon, transitive verbs “are those that cannot complete their meaning without the help of a direct object.”26 Like vampires, such verbs feed off an object to sustain, fulfill, and extend themselves in embodied orientations that require the object in order to exist. Such orientations, after Sara Ahmed, “are about the intimacy of bodies and their dwelling places”; they “allow us then to rethink the phenomenality of space—that is, how space is dependent on bodily inhabitance.” 27 Caught in a transitive relationality with indigeneity, settlers cannot achieve their sovereign subjectivities and embodiments without the help of the Native as object to orient them. In other words, the discursive frameworks and “regulatory matrices” of the subject have already been formulated in response to the colonization of American Indians. Within the structuring elements of settler colonialism, subjectivity, claiming to be, and speaking for have gone hand in hand with the theft of lands, the politics of replacement, and the forced normativities of compulsory heterosexuality and lineal descent. The fraught and contradictory desires for and against subjectivities embedded within the ontological orientations of empire are located within the diversity of experiences that have shaped such positionalities as settler, arrivant, and Native. These colonial contexts inform modern claims to Indigenous identity within the racial regimes of U.S. neoliberal multiculturalism and intersect with those queer politics that disrupt static, essential, and normalized privileges of race, class, and gender, on the one hand, and Indigenous identities that are tied to community recognition, sovereignty, and land, on the other. How might desire—which, as Holland has argued, is imbricated within quotidian racist practices—function to reproduce the logics of dispossession at the site of reinvention and becoming for the other? The U.S. Supreme Court, building on an interlocking foundation of precedence for its juridical authority, issued four rulings in June 2013 that hinged on equal protection to arbitrate the triad of sexuality, race, and indigeneity. In the process of maintaining white normativity within heterosexual—and now, by extension, same-sex— family units, the court inveighed on Indigenous identity, fearing the possibility of a remote Indian ancestor to be a disability hampering a child’s full incorporation into the rights due her as a transracial Indian-into- white subject. That fear not only demonstrates the degree to which the legal normativities of embodied ability depend on racializing and colonizing logics to produce the righted subject, but also highlights the transitive form through which the law interpellates indigeneity as difference and recourse. But how did indigeneity become transitive within the regulative fictions of rights and liberties? That answer might be found within the racial integrity acts of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries that the Loving v. Virginia landmark ruling in 1967 purportedly overturned. By framing these concerns at a slight slant, it is my hope that we might be able to begin to apprehend how desire and identity function within the context of an ongoing colonialism that adjudicates inclusion and exclusion through a transitive relationality that requires the Native other to make visible the biopolitical structures of race, sexuality, gender, and sovereignty

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.