Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Pessimism inhibits social change and fails to address the material changes in the status quo – not being able to recognize the necessity for change impedes anti-capitalist movements.

Sam Gindin, 2009, a Canadian intellectual and activist known for his expertise on the labour movement and the economics of the automobile industry. Gindin is a graduate of the University of Manitoba. (Transcending Pessimism: Rekindling Socialist Imagination). Mar 18, 2009 https://socialistregister.com/index.php/srv/article/view/5731/2626

At the same time, however, we still live in an era of foreclosed hope in the possibility of a better world. What makes the tragedy of Willie Loman so universal now is that even people who wonder whether the capitalist dream isn’t the wrong dream see no way of realizing a life beyond capitalism, or fear that any attempt to do so can only result in another nightmare. Overcoming this debilitating political pessimism is the most important question anyone seriously interested in social change must confront. Socialists search for what direction to take under these conditions, it helps to know that others before have faced the same problem. How to make ‘the defeated man ... try the outside world again’ was precisely the question that impelled Ernst Bloch in the 1930s to write his magnum opus, The Principle ofHope.2Pessimism – ‘paralysis per se’ – was the first obstacle to be confronted:...people who do not believe at all in a happy end impede changing the world almost as much as the sweet swindlers, the marriage-swindlers, the charlatans of apotheosis. Unconditional pessimism therefore promotes the business of reaction not much less than artificially conditioned optimism; the latter is nevertheless not so stupid that it does not believe in anything at all. It does not immortalize the trudging of the little life, does not give humanity the face of a chloroformed gravestone. It does not give the world the deathly sad background in front of which it is not worth doing anything at all. In contrast to a pessimism which itself belongs to rotten-ness and may serve it, a tested optimism, when the scales fall from the eyes, does not deny the goal-belief in general; on the contrary, what matters now is to find the right one and to prove it… In recent years we have seen all too many disillusioned people on the left ‘coming to their senses’ by abandoning the goal of socialism. Some have succumbed to a post-modernist pessimism, which has indeed proved to be ‘paralysis per se’. Even more seem to have jumped from what Bloch called the ‘evils of putschist activism’ all the way to social democracy’s ‘third way’, whose presumption that neo-liberal prescriptions of efficiency are compatible with social justice is the contemporary expression of what Bloch designated as one of the key hallmarks of ideology – ‘the premature harmonization of social contradictions’ within the confines of existing social relations. Frustrated by their inability to change the world overnight through sheer activism, they have not so much abandoned the idea of change but, like the Greek God Procrustes who adjusted the size of his guests to fit the size of his bed, they have shrunk the meaning of change to fit what capital and the state will accommodate. Yet it is increasingly apparent from the extreme limitations of the ‘third way’ in practice that reviving the goal of socialism is necessary even to make small improvements in the current state of the world. As Bloch put it: ‘If the will-content of the goal is missing, then even the good probable is left undone; if the goal remains, however, then even the improbable can be done, or at least made more probable for later.’

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.