Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

AT: INB—Econ Turn—Kills Growth

Military spending decks economic growth.

Muhammad Azam 20, Department of Economics, Faculty of Business & Economics, Abdul Wali Khan University Mardan, 12/28/2020, “Does military spending stifle economic growth? The empirical evidence from non-OECD countries,” Heliyon, 6(12), , RH

Undeniably, peace and long-term sustainable economic development are the prime agenda of all countries. This study aims to empirically evaluate the impact of military spending on economic growth for a panel of 35 non-OECD countries over 1988–2019. A multivariate regression model based on the augmented production function is used to achieve the objective of the study. The panel autoregressive distributed lag (ARDL)/pooled mean group (PMG) technique is employed, while, in addition the robust least squares and fixed-effect estimators are implemented for the robustness of the results. This study found a clear negative effect of military spending on economic growth. The pairwise Dumitrescu Hurlin panel causality test results exhibit bi-directional causality between military expenses and economic growth. Overall, these estimates provide strong support that military expenditure is not beneficial rather detrimental to economic growth. The empirical findings of this study suggest that policymakers need to redesign the military budget to stimulate economic growth and improve social welfare.

The assessment of the economic and social effects of military expenditure remains an interesting desirable area of research. The ultimate objectives of underdeveloped and developed countries are to achieve sustainable economic growth and prosperity in the long-run. There is a substantial volume of literature about the economic consequences of military expenditure; however, no consensus has been developed, whether military spending is beneficial or detrimental to economic growth. Military spending according to the Keynesian approach is a component of government consumption, which stimulates economic growth by expanding demand for goods and services. Military spending affects economic growth through many channels. When aggregate demand is lower relative to prospective supply, rises in military spending tend to enlarge capacity utilization, raise profits, and consequently, enhance investment and aggregate output (). Several prior studies have drawn findings that support the Keynesian military view of the positive influence of military expenditure on national output (; ; ). In a study conducted by , it is ascertained that military spending has several positive effects on capital, labor, growth, and the effectual use of available resources in the economy as a whole.

The focus of academicians, researchers, and developmental economists for peace economics are useable as military spending is one of the main concerns of countries, regardless of their development status. According to conventional logic, the military formulation is an economic encumbrance. While comparatively more resources are devoted to military formulations, and lesser proportion is left for investment in the education and technology sectors, which play a vital role in the economic growth process and provide a broader base for socio-economic development. Generally, it is believed that in the insecure region, each country deliberately allocates an uneven share of its meager economic resources to “unproductive” military expenditure. In the absenteeism of international collaboration to minimize political pressure, military expenditures can be driven more and more across a region as each country goes beyond its neighbors to safeguard its security, raise the level of regional military expenditure and bring little rise or even a decline in the security of all. However, there are two direct and interconnected ways by which higher military expenditure may unfavorably affect long-run economic growth. First, military spending upsurge may diminish the total accumulation of existing resources available for other domestic usages such as investment in prolific capital, education, and market-oriented technological enhancement. Second, high military expenditure can intensify misrepresentations that condense the efficiency of resource distribution, thereby diminishing the total yield factor2.

Military expenditure tends to attenuate productivity because more funds diversion to military expenditure causes the government to either increase taxes or get loans from the foreign capital market to balance its budget. The second alternative is therefore primarily harmful to economic prosperity, since it escalates the rate of interest, decreases investment and consumer demand, and drives economic growth sluggish (Russett, 1969; Borch and Wallace, 2010). In a similar vein, some other studies including Lim (1983) noted that military expenses are harmful to the growth of any economy. Even, a study by Dunne (2000) focusing on the Keynesian framework reveals that military spending has no influence on growth at best, but most probably has an inverse effect; obviously, there is no indication of a positive influence of military burden on economic growth. This implies that disarmament certainly offers a prospect for augmented economic performance.

Despite the voluminous empirical studies on the military-growth connection, the empirical findings are still inconclusive6. The discussion in the present literature on the influence of military spending opened with the seminal work of Benoit (1978) which opined that military spending and growth have a positive correlation. Afterward, many studies are continuously performed to empirically verify the relationship between these variables by using different models, estimation techniques, set of countries, and data period. Several other studies support the positive effect of defense spending including Atesoglu (2002), who observed that there exists a significantly positive association in military outlays and aggregate output in the case of the United States from 1947:2–2000:2. The empirical analysis of the study by Yildirim et al. (2005) found that military spending boosts national income in the Middle Eastern countries and Turkey over 1989–99. Narayan and Singh (2007) empirically verified that defense expenses Granger causes exports, and exports Granger causes national income (GDP), indicating that defense spending indirectly Granger causes national income in the short-run for Fiji over 1970–01. According to Borch and Wallace (2010), higher levels of military expenditure are better prepared to stave off the harmful influences of an economic slump than states with lower levels of military spending in the 49 U.S. states during 1977–04. Malizard (2010) observed two-way causality between military spending and growth in France during 1960–08. Findings of Farzanegan (2014) study supported the positive impact of the military outlay on growth in Iran during 1959–07. Khalid and Noor (2018) concluded that military spending has a positive relationship with growth in sixty-seven developing economies during 2002–10.

On the other hand, some prior studies, for example,  detected that a greater military burden is related to sluggish growth for 69 countries during 1952–70, whereas a rise of 10% military spending leads to a decrease of annual economic growth by 0.13%.  revealed that overall the direct and indirect effects of military expenditure will dampen growth rate and impede development in a panel of 50 developing economies during 1965–73. The author suggested that empirical indication goes against the conclusions of Benoit and others about the positive impact of military outlay on growth in less-developed economies.  found that military expenditure hampers economic growth, but civilian expenses have a positive impact on growth for Egypt, Israel, and Syria (1975–98), (1967–98), and (1973–98) respectively. The empirical findings of  reveal that overall the military outlay has a negative influence on the growth rate of Peru over 1970–96.  found that military expenditure leads to deleterious growth for low-income countries in the whole sample of 90 countries during 1992–06.  observed a significantly negative effect of military spending on growth in 83 countries from OECD over 1970–14.  examined the causal link between military spending and economic growth for 35 African countries over 1990–15. The authors found that (i) no causal link in seven countries; (ii) one-way causality from military spending to growth in two countries; (iii) one-way link from growth one-way in 14 countries; and (iv) two-ways link in 12 countries. Overall, the GMM estimates reveal that military spending has a significant negative effect on economic growth in Africa.

Similarly, other studies provide evidence of mixed results on the economic effects of military expenses on growth, for example, the study of  divided the economies into financial resource restrained and unrestrained groups over 1960–78. The findings revealed that enhanced military expenditures promoted growth in the unrestrained group, but a small visible impact was found in resource-constrained countries. In a study on three North American countries namely Canada, Mexico, and the U.S. during 1963–05,  found that enhanced military expenditure promotes nominal GDP in Canada and Mexico, while it declines the growth in nominal GDP in the U.S.  observed no Granger causal association between military outlay and growth for South Africa during 1951–10. However, by using the bootstrap rolling window estimation approach, the study finds two ways Granger causality in different subsamples. The results of  supported the neutrality hypothesis for France, Germany, and Italy, while, the military expenditure–growth hampering hypothesis for Canada and the UK, and unidirectional Granger causality running from national income to military outlay for China. Moreover, the results supported the feedback between military spending and national income in the case of Japan and the U.S. over 1988–10. Using the “Hendry General-to-Specific modeling” methodology, the study of  fails to find any causal linkages between military spending and economic growth in India over 1980–16. Some more related empirical studies are given in .

Several empirical studies are available on the relationship between military spending and economic growth, but their empirical findings are yet inconclusive. Undeniably, the economic effect of military expenditure is an essential issue for the developing world. Therefore, this research work aims to determine empirically the impact of military expenditure along with some other control variables on the growth, for a set of thirty-five countries from non-OECD over 1988–19. According to the nature of the data, the widely used panel unit tests are employed to check the order of integration of each variable. The results are found mixed (i.e., I(0), and I(1)) based on stationarity, and thus, the panel ARDL/PMG approach is applied. Afterward, the panel robust least squares and fixed-effect estimators are also employed as analytical techniques for parameters’ estimation to affirm the results, and the Dumitrescu –Hurlin Granger causality test is employed to find the direction of causality between the variables.

The empirical results of all the methods suggest that military spending and economic growth have a strong inverse relationship, suggesting that encouraging military expenditure is not a good option because it discourages economic growth. Moreover, the Dumitrescu–Hurlin Granger causality test exposes bidirectional causal nexus between military expenses and economic growth in the sample countries. The bidirectional causal linkage between military spending and growth though exhibits a degree of interdependence between military spending and economic growth policy objectives. Thus, the execution of economic growth policies should not be given more primacy over the military burden while other than military expenditure factors shall be considered.

Overall, the empirical results validated that military spending is undesirable for national economic development. The results of the significantly negative effect of military spending on national income go against the results obtained by , and others who claim that military expenditure positively contributes to the aggregate output, while, consistent with the findings by  for 106 countries over 1988–10, Dunne and Tian concluded that “These results do seem to provide valuable robustness checks and support strongly the view that military spending hurts growth” (p.29). The findings of the present study are technically and statistically acceptable and plausible for frontwards policy recommendation purposes.

From these findings, the unequivocal negative effect of military spending on economic growth indicates that non-OECD countries are developing countries with scarce resources, and these economies can't afford military spending, while when these economies grow, governments can contemplate rising its military spending to strengthen its military power. Enlarged military spending can't be used to boost economic growth in the non-OECD countries, since any positive impacts it would have on the economic growth through augmented demand, modernization, and resource outset, would have overwhelmed by the damaging effects on economic growth through reduced investment. Policymakers should thus leave military spending for security objectives only and restructuring public resources from the military sector toward civilian objectives. Likewise, policymakers should focus on rationalizing their budget spending more on improving social welfare. Furthermore, incremental efforts are required to adopt an effective and prudent policy to further encourage growth, while shrinkage in military spending can largely benefit the economies. Therefore, military expenditures need to be reduced while expenditures on other developmental sectors including health and education sectors to be increased.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.