Turn—Relations Solve Entrapment
Stronger relations cause NATO to restrain US aggression- solves entrapment
Anika Binnendijk 19 — (Anika Binnendijk; senior fellow with the Scowcroft Center’s Transatlantic Security Initiative, a political scientist at the RAND Corporation, Published: 2019; "An Attack Against Them All? Drivers of Decisions to Contribute to NATO Collective Defense"; RAND Corporation; Accessed: 7-9-2022; https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/pdfs/AD1080712.pdf)//Pen-SY
Concerns about a mismatch of goals could be overcome if coalition participants are more confident in their ability to influence the coalition’s actions. Potential participants could have concerns about restraining any ally, but in a Baltic scenario, these concerns are likely to be most acute with respect to the most powerful and leading members of the coalition and the Baltic states. Typically, weaker states are thought to have less leverage in the alliance and, therefore, greater concerns about entrapment by a stronger ally like the United States.78 However, weaker allies do have some ways to restrain more-powerful allies. First, longstanding diplomatic and military relationships among NATO members mean that states might have insight into their allies’ decision making processes and the contacts needed to influence those processes.79 Second, allies also have some sources of leverage over a coalition leader, including the ability to withdraw participation or place limits on access to military bases or airspace.80 Such actions could restrain a coalition leader’s behavior by affecting its ability to carry out operations, raising the costs of a military action, or undermining the domestic or international legitimacy of the operation. To the extent that a coalition leader values the support of its allies in the longer term, threats of exit from the coalition or NATO itself could affect a coalition leader’s decisionmaking.81 There is evidence that NATO allies used NATO decisionmaking structures to restrain U.S. actions during the air war over Kosovo. Wesley Clark, who was NATO’s Supreme Allied Commander, complained about the influence of NATO members on military decisions, including campaign phasing and individual targeting.82 In a now-famous incident at the Pristina airport, the British commander of NATO’s Allied Rapid Reaction Corps was able to leverage his chain of command in London to thwart Clark’s plan to block the airport runway with helicopters—a move that the British commander believed could have triggered a security incident between NATO and Russia.83 Ultimately, concerns about constraints posed by NATO structures in Kosovo contributed to the U.S. decision to form a coalition of the willing for initial operations in Afghanistan in 2001.84 NATO members that do not participate could still face direct Russian retaliation or other consequences. Given that possibility, members who do not entirely support the aims of the operation might still participate in order to seek greater influence over operational decisions than they would have if they were on the outside.85 This logic appears to have influenced France’s decision to join NATO’s air war over Kosovo. French Secretary General for Defense and National Security Louis Gautier argued that French participation in the operation meant that France was “able in Kosovo to impose itself in the decisionmaking process and affect strategy.”86