Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Starting with an AI logistics pilot through NATO is key---it’s key to military effectiveness, is technologically and politically feasible, and establishes benchmarks necessary for effective AI testing and standards necessary for innovation and interoperability---allies only say yes to the plan

Margarita Konaev & Husanjot Chahal 21, Research Fellow & Research Analyst, Center for Security and Emerging Technology, Georgetown University. "The Path of Least Resistance Multinational Collaboration on AI for Military Logistics and Sustainment" April. https://cset.georgetown.edu/wp-content/uploads/CSET-Path-of-Least-Resistance.pdf //pipk

Focusing on AI-enabled Military Logistics and Sustainment In military affairs, logistics is tasked with managing the global supply chain for the armed services, including “the transfer of personnel and materiel from one location to another, as well as the maintenance of that materiel.”27 Sustainment is a broader term, encompassing logistics as well as financial management, personnel services, and health services which together provide the support necessary to maintain operations until the mission is accomplished.28 The two functions are closely intertwined. NATO’s Allied Joint Doctrine for Logistics, for instance, offers a comprehensive definition of logistics that also entails elements of sustainment, encompassing the aspects of military operations that deal with “design and development, acquisition, storage, movement, distribution, maintenance, evacuation and disposition of materiel; transport of personnel; acquisition, construction, maintenance, operation and disposition of facilities; acquisition or furnishing of services; and medical and health service support.”29

Logistics and sustainment are essential to military effectiveness, readiness, survivability, and endurance, and in many ways, constitute the lifeblood of military power.30 The Department of Defense, in turn, sees great promise in leveraging AI/machine learning (ML) technologies for military logistics and sustainment to better maintain equipment, reduce operational costs, and improve readiness. The Department of Defense’s AI strategy, for example, includes efforts related to AI-enabled logistics and sustainment, such as “implementing predictive maintenance and supply, and streamlining business processes,” as part of its strategic approach to “delivering AI-enabled capabilities that address key missions.”31 Joint Logistics, in turn, is one of the JAIC’s key mission initiatives, dedicated to “improving fleet readiness through AI-driven diagnostics, training, process improvements, demand forecasting, and supply chain optimization.”32

The discussion below outlines the technological, political, and strategic imperatives and opportunities for multinational collaboration on AI-enabled military logistics and sustainment. Naturally, the principal mission of militaries is national defense and the force (including logistics and sustainment functions) must be prepared for combat at any time. Modern militaries, however, are massive organizations that employ hundreds of thousands of people, if not more. The Department of Defense, for example, employs 2.91 million people, and less than half of them, or 1.3 million, are active duty personnel.33 And unlike military functions such as fires or movement and maneuver of forces and equipment, many of the tasks related to military logistics and other financial, personnel, and health services are administered in noncombat settings.

While we discuss how the United States and its allies can work together on AI for military logistics and sustainment in both combat and noncombat settings, there is no doubt that the environment in question matters a great deal. From data to computational power to available talent, as well as considerations like privacy, safety, and security, implementing AI for military logistics and sustainment functions performed in controlled environments similar to commercial settings is a different endeavor from deploying AIenabled logistics and sustainment functions in contested and hostile environments. We take these differences into account where relevant, and acknowledge that even under the best of circumstances, there are still significant challenges for both the adoption of AI applications and multinational collaboration in this area.

Technologically attainable While not without its challenges, military logistics and sustainment tasks, especially those performed in noncombat settings, present a technologically attainable area for multinational collaboration in AI. Although much of the innovation in AI is occurring in the commercial sector, adopting and adapting commercial AI applications for military purposes is often impossible. Current AI technologies, and especially ML-based systems, tend to perform well in stable environments but struggle with uncertain and novel situations, and remain particularly vulnerable to adversarial attacks.

These vulnerabilities present an unacceptable level of risk in highstakes military settings, where the environment is uncertain and adversarial by definition. The consequences of mistakes and even system failure, however, are less severe when it comes to some military logistics and sustainment tasks which are administered and managed in noncombat settings, and constitute what some have called enterprise AI applications.

Advances in AI for logistics in commercial aviation, maritime shipping, and transportation sectors are therefore more applicable to certain military logistics and sustainment tasks performed in noncombat settings than for specialized military equipment like autonomous ground combat vehicles or armed drones. In particular, there may be opportunities to adopt and adapt commercial applications for the intelligent automation of tasks such as scheduling equipment maintenance and repairs, updating and issuing licenses, supply tracking and forecasting, and other processes that control the flow of logistics throughout the military organization.34 To reiterate, these are much more than cost cutting and efficiency increasing measures; improvements in these areas enable military readiness and effectiveness in combat.35

In addition to these opportunities to leverage AI-enabled technologies and tools available in the commercial sector in support of military logistics, there are also fewer barriers to inhouse innovation within defense organizations. Many of the AI applications relevant to logistics and sustainment can be developed and used in relatively well-controlled and benign environments in settings akin to commercial civilian enterprises. Under such conditions, resources like data and infrastructure, including storage, ETL pipelines, communication bandwidth, and compute can be made available to train ML models for various AI applications.36 Notably, the 2016 Defense Science Board Summer Study on Autonomy raised a similar point regarding logistics planning and execution as “a particularly good candidate for testing and experimentation (T&E) … because the behavior of logistic software can be evaluated against crisply known metrics.”37

Considering both the potential for leveraging developments from the private sector and lower barriers to in-house innovation, collaboration on AI for logistics and sustainment could also involve allies with more limited military-industrial capacities. Based on its fact-finding mission to Singapore, NATO’s Science and Technology Committee observed that “small and medium-sized Allies with smart scientists and engineers can play an outsized role in AI development and adoption.”38 This is a significant advantage, arguably unique to AI technologies, and especially timely considering that even the relatively wealthy U.S. allies are facing cuts to their defense budgets due to the economic fallout from the COVID-19 pandemic. Moreover, collaboration that includes input from small and medium-sized allies can strengthen interoperability, contribute to allied burden sharing, and buttress the long-term viability of U.S.-led defense partnerships.

This is not to say that adopting and developing, let alone collaborating on AI-enabled logistics will be an easy task for the U.S. military and allied defense organizations. The ML and deep learning algorithms behind commercial AI-enabled logistics are generally not optimized for military needs.39 And if the experience of the Department of Defense is any indication, there are multiple challenges with regards to the data needed to power AI applications—from lack of data to problems with traceability, access, and interoperability of data collected by different systems.40 Moreover, data security and privacy concerns as well as different legal frameworks for how personal data is collected, handled, processed, and stored remain a critical barrier to international collaboration. Lack of clarity surrounding how to implement the exemptions for research incorporated into the General Data Protection Regulation, for example, has stalled collaboration between the U.S. National Institutes of Health and some European counterparts.41

These and other technical barriers and privacy-related concerns are indeed significant. But developments in privacy-preserving ML techniques, including homomorphic encryption, secure multi-party computation, and federated learning offer opportunities for allies to share and pool data without compromising the privacy of individual users and organizations whose data is being used.42 The United States can also work with allies to develop technical standards and protocols for harmonizing data collection, formatting, storage, and archiving to ensure data security and integrity.43

Overall, the U.S. military and allied defense organizations will face nonnegligible technical barriers whether adapting commercial AI technologies or building AI-enabled systems and tools in-house. From a comparative standpoint, however, military logistics and sustainment applications that fall under the broader category of enterprise AI applications present “low hanging fruit” for the U.S. military (and presumably for other technologically advanced militaries).44 Moreover, international collaboration on AI-enabled military logistics and sustainment is likely more within reach than collaboration on AI integrated into weapons systems or applications that feed on sensitive data collected by proprietary weapons and sensor systems.45

Politically feasible With key U.S. allies like the United Kingdom, Germany, France, South Korea and Japan already pursuing efforts to leverage AI for military logistics and sustainment, collaboration in this area seems politically feasible. The integration of AI into weapons systems has raised ethical concerns and opposition in some communities across the United States and in allied countries. Yet by focusing collaboration on AI applications for military logistics and sustainment functions, the United States and its allies could potentially sidestep the contentious “killer robots” debate. Collaborative efforts to develop and apply AI tools to areas such as defense supply chain management, personnel management, and equipment maintenance can improve existing processes and functions, save costs and increase efficiencies in defense organizations. Multinational collaboration around this set of goals and applications is less likely to galvanize widespread grassroots opposition than programs on AI-enabled drones or autonomous ground combat vehicles.

Moreover, some of the United States’ closest allies are already investing in AI and ML technologies for logistics and sustainment. The United Kingdom’s Ministry of Defense’s (MOD) Autonomy Programme, for example, identifies defense resupply and logistics challenges through the Defense and Security Accelerator as one of its key activities.46 In 2019, MOD also allocated £66 million (about $83 million) to accelerate robotic projects for the British Army, including autonomous logistics vehicles supporting resupply missions in conflict zones.47 Notably, the UK’s Defense Science and Technology Laboratory and the U.S. Army Combat Capabilities Development Command’s Ground Vehicle Systems Center have been working together since 2016 on the Coalition Assured Autonomous Resupply project, prototyping semiautonomous logistics convoys, along with ground and aerial autonomous resupply systems, and demonstrating the interoperability of the two nations’ armies with autonomous driving technology.48

France’s military AI strategy also views “logistics and operational readiness” as one of the priority areas for the defense ministry, including a focus on predictive maintenance. 49 Notably, the strategy states that “mission performance and assisted maintenance applications, especially for cooperation with countries that have the same systems” as France pose no significant problems in terms of sharing classified data. And in addition to its key European partners, France is also open to collaboration with the United States given the similar approach to AI development. 50 Along similar lines, the German Army identifies AI for personnel and material management, including predictive maintenance, as one of the main areas for action on AI development.51

Japan and South Korea are also increasingly investing in military applications of AI, including for logistics and sustainment. South Korea’s National Strategy for Artificial Intelligence lists national defense as a key area for AI applications, including using AI to “quickly analyze and process large-scale defense data and develop and support common services such as medical care, logistics, and administration.”52 Meanwhile, Japan’s Acquisition, Technology and Logistics Agency (ATLA) has identified “logistical support technologies” in its medium- to long-term defense technology outlook back in 2016. More recently, ATLA has been working with private sector partners on research and development projects applying AI for defense logistics and “streamlining system maintenance work.”53

Efforts to advance collaboration on AI-enabled military logistics and sustainment will likely face some resistance. The aforementioned challenges related to data privacy are not merely technical in nature, but deeply political as well. Some European policymakers are pushing toward data sovereignty and less dependency on U.S. technology. Others are doubting whether the United States is willing to advance meaningful regulations over digital technologies and safeguards for data privacy.54 The question of a forum for collaboration remains a politically sensitive topic as well, even more so now in the aftermath of Brexit. 55

These challenges notwithstanding, the United States and its allies have shared interests and common policy objectives in ensuring the safe and responsible use of AI in alignment with democratic norms and principles. And with allies like the United Kingdom, France, Germany, South Korea, and Japan already promoting initiatives to leverage AI for military logistics and sustainment, this seems like a politically pragmatic area for collaboration.

Strategically critical The strategic environment in Europe and the Asia-Pacific region heightens the importance of coordinating national and multinational logistics, while collaboration on AI-enabled logistics can provide an operational advantage in multinational operations.

The U.S. military is a global force that must remain ahead of competitors and adversaries and be prepared for a broad range of contingencies and missions. Yet in multinational operations, the gap in military and technological capabilities between the United States and its allies and partners, and more specifically, significant discrepancies in allies’ logistic capabilities, can negatively impact survivability, interoperability, cohesion, and ultimately, mission success. Thus, for the United States and its allies, collaboration on logistics and sustainment in general, and on AI-enabled logistics and sustainment in particular, is important for several operational and strategic reasons.

Operationally speaking, logistic support during multinational military operations differs from unilateral operations. Nations have different national and military objectives, cultures, capabilities, and approaches to logistic support and functions. These differences impact how the United States military organizes, prepares, and eventually executes logistic support during multinational operations.56 Moreover, in multinational operations, nations share a collective responsibility for logistics in support of the mission. Thus, the logistic capabilities of each allied nation affect not only their ability to support their own forces but the operational-level support capabilities of the coalition as a whole.57

On a strategic level, the global threat landscape and U.S. security posture in Europe and the Asia-Pacific region elevate the significance of joint, streamlined logistics and comparable military endurance capabilities between the United States and its allies. In Europe, on NATO’s eastern flank, the Baltic states of Estonia and Latvia, (as well as potentially Lithuania) could be overrun by Russia’s superior military forces in a matter of days.58 Thus, in the event of a major conflict in the Baltic states, NATO would have to move thousands of troops and heavy military equipment from across Europe as well as from the United States very rapidly and efficiently to counter Russian aggression. Sound logistics—from the coordination and transfer of military cargo ships and private merchant vessels to the surge and movement of military equipment and supplies along Europe’s roads, rivers, and incompatible rail infrastructure—would prove essential to success. 59

Preventing China from becoming a regional hegemon in East Asia and strengthening the U.S.-led security architecture in the western Pacific is high on the list of U.S. strategic interests. Yet the U.S. military has no local shore bases from which to project power in the region, and its dependence on more distant bases in Guam, Japan, and South Korea, presents significant operational limitations. Moreover, U.S. air bases, aircraft carriers, surface vessels, ports, airfields, and logistics systems—those already in the region and those surge forces moving into the theater in the event of a crisis or a conflict—are currently vulnerable to Chinese air and missile attacks and cyberattacks.60 U.S. national security experts are well aware of these challenges and recognize the need to work with allies to protect shared security interests in these strategically important regions. For instance, the NSCAI’s interim report recommends assisting NATO in its adoption of AI and negotiating formal AI cooperation agreements with allies and partners like Australia, India, Japan, New Zealand, South Korea, and Vietnam.61 Moreover, the report explicitly recommends that U.S. alliances, primarily NATO, “explore pilot projects in low-risk areas such as for enterprise AI applications (logistics and sustainment) to derive lessons that would support broader application of AI systems for alliance efforts.”62

Along similar lines, in their assessment of U.S. competitiveness in the Indo-Pacific region, the Center for a New American Security recommends integrating logistics and sustainment considerations into the U.S. military strategy and operational concept development for China in order to ensure that the United States is able to project and sustain combat power in the Indo-Pacific region. 63 These efforts, however, could be strengthened by paying closer attention to the role AI/ML technologies could have in enabling more responsive logistics systems as well as in building the capacity of key partners in the region.

Certainly, when it comes to international collaboration in general, or collaborative AI projects related to military logistics and sustainment more specifically, disagreements and complications are inevitable. The past four years have seen more friction between NATO member states as well as between the United States and NATO. Rebuilding U.S. alliances is high on the Biden administration’s agenda. But restoring trust and good collaborative relationships takes time, effort, and resources. Moreover, NATO member states have very different military and technological capabilities which makes it difficult to implement alliance-wide initiatives. And while confronting China’s assertiveness is a top priority for the United States, many of the United States’ European and Asia-Pacific allies have economic and technological relationships with China. Their objectives vis-à-vis China on questions of geopolitics and technology are not necessarily aligned with those of the United States.

Nevertheless, the strategic and operational arguments in favor of working together on AI-enabled logistics and sustainment are quite powerful. Coordination on AI embedded in logistic systems can make for more efficient and streamlined movement of personnel and equipment, enable interoperability between systems and forces, and expedite the provision of medical services. Such improvements directly contribute to the readiness and endurance of allied military forces and their ability to deter and defeat adversaries if conflict erupts.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.