Interoperability collapsing---AI integration is key
Martin Dufour 18, Colonel in the Canadian Army, working with NATO. This Policy Brief is a revised version of a paper that was awarded the Eisenhower Prize for the best Individual Paper of NDC Senior Course 132. NATO Defense College, Research Division. NDC Policy Brief, No. 6. December. "Will artificial intelligence challenge NATO interoperability?" //pipk
At the operational and strategic levels, the adoption of artificial intelligence-enabled autonomous systems connecting sensors, battle management, command and control systems, as well as defensive and offensive assets in a network of learning, adaptive systems will enable “a form of algorithmic warfare and machine learning approach to targeting”10 which will compress the decision-action cycle to such an extent that countries not connected to the system will be unable to keep up.
The 2017 report Future War NATO argues that the “technologically-driven US military strategy is advancing so fast compared to European allies that, sooner rather than later, all-important NATO military interoperability might well become a thing of the past”.11 This echoed a 2016 report from the Armament Industry European Research Group, which concluded that “a further boost in US defence technology could promote a wider US-Europe gap and the emergence of a two-tier alliance”.12 It was furthermore observed that the USD3.6 billion invested in Third Offset Strategy technologies in 2017, while representing only 5 percent of the overall US military research and development budget corresponded “to more than 40 percent of the overall EU-European R&D budgets”.13
Beyond interoperability, a profound technological mismatch between allies could also erode the political and military cohesion of the Alliance by creating resentment between countries that bear a greater share of the burden as a result, and those that do not.
While challenges exist, artificial intelligence need not erode NATO cohesion. It is however imperative that countries begin to think seriously about the future impact of artificial intelligence, and how to effectively start adopting the technology. An exploratory look at the development landscape for artifi cial intelligence and autonomous technologies reveals that most of the innovations in the fi eld occur outside the military-industrial complex. The GAFAs (Google, Amazon, Facebook, Apple) have steadily invested over the years to develop commercial applications for artifi cial intelligence, and one can fi nd many other startup companies throughout the world. The data company CB Insights’ second annual AI 100 list identifi ed the 100 most promising artifi cial intelligence startups, noting that they came from nine different countries, including many from smaller nations which “in aggregate... have raised USD11.7 billion in equity funding across 367 deals”.14 NATO states should therefore strive to develop partnerships with such companies, identify promising applications, and start implementing them at once in their defence framework to act as agent of change.
It is also interesting to note that when it comes to successfully leveraging emerging technologies, the business model is often more important than the capability. One only needs consider the success of companies such as Uber and AirBnB, giants in their respective fi elds, but which do not actually own any physical assets. Smaller NATO nations should therefore reconsider their business model and identify niche domains such as cyberwarfare, early threat detection or predictive analysis. They could then leverage partnerships with promising companies to develop those capabilities to obtain a competitive advantage allowing them to remain relevant in times of confl ict. These capabilities could offset complex hardware solutions and allow smaller nations to continue sharing the burden of military opera tions. This is the point made in a 2017 study titled Artifi cial Intelligence and the Future of Defence, according to which given its “algorithmic and non-defence specifi c essence…[artifi cial intelligence] is easier to jump in than is the case for many industrial-kinetic technologies [such as] building a sixth-generation jet fi ghter”.15 As such smaller, nimble nations have an opportunity to redefi ne how they do military development, and harness this key disruptive technology to start fi lling the growing capability gap between NATO countries.
Overcoming the interoperability gap It is evident that of the emerging disruptive technologies, none is likely to have as signifi cant an impact on warfare as that of artifi cial intelligence. The effect of artifi cial intelligence is already being felt in numerous fi elds, and its further development and combination with other technologies will compound this, allowing the development of advanced autonomous systems. While the latter holds the promise of creating new classes of weapons with great military potential, disproportional growth among the various NATO allies could lead to complex interoperability problems, further widening the existing interoperability gap between member nations.
Over the next two decades Alliance members will be increasingly challenged by the rapid evolution of artifi cial intelligence and risk becoming unable to operate together should the asymmetric adoption of emerging technologies not be carefully managed. It is therefore paramount that countries begin preparing for the future impact of artifi cial intelligence in the military realm, and start adopting the technology in niche areas to ensure they do not fall too far behind.