Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Interoperability key to NATO---successful integration of AI is key

Martin Dufour 18, Colonel in the Canadian Army, working with NATO. This Policy Brief is a revised version of a paper that was awarded the Eisenhower Prize for the best Individual Paper of NDC Senior Course 132. NATO Defense College, Research Division. NDC Policy Brief, No. 6. December. "Will artificial intelligence challenge NATO interoperability?" //pipk

NATO has arguably been the most successful alliance of its kind, and much of this success can be attributed to its cohesion in the face of various threats. At the heart of this cohesion lie two important notions: burden sharing between members; and interoperability. The Alliance’s cohesion however has increasingly come under pressure over the last two decades, and there are growing challenges with the level of interoperability between member countries. While numerous technical and political factors influence interoperability, the emergence of disruptive technologies such as genetic engineering, nanotechnology, additive manufacturing and robotics, are likely to make this challenge more acute in the next two decades.

Of the many technologies rapidly emerging, none is likely to have as significant an impact as that of artificial intelligence, which combines with other technologies and multiply their effect by allowing the development of advanced autonomous systems. And while the latter holds the promise of developing new classes of weapons with great military potential, its asymmetrical adoption among the various NATO allies could also lead to significant interoperability problems.

What interoperability means Cohesion, often mentioned as the Alliance’s center of gravity, lies at the heart of NATO’s success. Underwriting this cohesion is the ability of member states to share the burden of producing military capabilities to service the whole, and the burden of conducting operational missions. To do this successfully, members have to be able to undertake military actions in concert with each other in a fully coordinated, and as much as possible integrated manner. This is referred to as interoperability, defined as “the ability of systems, units or forces to provide services to, and accept services from other systems, units or forces and to the use the services so exchanged to enable them to operate effectively together”.1

This definition implies that there are several layers to interoperability which need to be addressed to ensure forces are able to operate together effectively in a military context. These include technical features permitting systems to physically connect to one another and exchange information; and the alignment of procedures and processes to allow military personnel to function within the same space and achieve common goals without fratricide. It also implies that this takes place at various levels of operation, from tactical to strategic. A high level of interoperability allows allies to effectively exchange intelligence and information, cooperatively plan complex military operations, and conduct integrated missions with fully exchangeable force packages.

NATO interoperability challenges Historically NATO has had the tendency to focus on procedural and technical interoperability between systems. To do so, it has employed a standards-based approach and developed hundreds of Standardization Agreements (STANAGs) which provide member states agreed-upon processes, procedures and platform compliance specifications rather than stipulating what to build and how. While this approach has allowed member states to equip themselves but still successfully train and operate together for decades, the last 25 years has witnessed a growing rift in the military capabilities of different nations.

Rapid technological evolution and the increasing cost and complexity of contemporary military systems have made it progressively more difficult for several countries to keep pace with the systems of the bigger allies. For instance, some countries have invested heavily in advanced systems allowing them to collect and process intelligence, designate targets and strike them at will with standoff, precision-guided weapons, day and night in any weather conditions. The level of investment necessary to acquire such capabilities, as well as various politico-strategic concerns such as the protection of a country’s military-industrial base and resultant unwillingness to sell or transfer advanced technologies, have prevented other allies from remaining current with some of these innovations. These allies therefore lack the ability to gainfully partake in certain military operations and equally share the burden with other members of the Alliance.

The growing capability gap between NATO member nations was explored in a 2000 RAND Corporation study titled Interoperability: a continuing challenge in coalition air operations, which considered 40 contemporary coalition operations and concluded that there was a “growing divergence between US and NATO allies’ air forces in all-weather precision-strike capabilities to minimize collateral damage and employment of standoff weapons”.2 Using a specific example to highlight this point, the authors stated that “Allied contributions to recent strike operations in the Balkans have been limited because the allies lack sufficient precision-guided weapons that can be delivered day or night in any weather conditions”.3 While numerous countries have since taken steps to acquire precision-guided weapons, the US has continued to improve its capabilities, moving even further away from most allies during that same period. The 14 April 2018 strikes on Syrian chemical weapons sites is a recent example of this situation where, setting political considerations aside, only three countries (US, UK and France) were realistically in possession of the required standoff attack missiles capable of reaching targets deep inside Syria with precision, without putting the pilots and aircraft at undue risk from Syrian air defence systems. The same study also found that this growing interoperability gap also exists with other capabilities such as command and control systems, battle management systems, as well as information exchange and security. Most importantly, this problem has not gone away.4 The ability to gather, process and disseminate accurate intelligence to support effective decisions-making faster than the enemy’s ability to do so (the so called decision-action cycle) has always been the hallmark of effective military operations. In an age when most systems are interconnected, with proliferation of sensors and data repositories, information superiority is rapidly becoming a decisive factor for mission success. Therefore the ability of allies to rapidly share intelligence in a secure manner at the operational and strategic levels, and leverage this intelligence to make sound, common decisions is bound to become a determinant factor in who can participate in a mission in the future.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.