US EU cooperation on AI key to global US leadership and democratic AI
Julia Voo and Lauren Zabierek 20, Cyber Fellow, leads the team behind Belfer’s National Cyber Power Index, and is the former Research Director for the Belfer Center’s new China Cyber Policy Initiative. Her areas of research include the Digital Silk Road, industrial policy, and technical standards for strategic technologies. Voo also has research affiliations with the Future of Humanity Institute (Oxford), the Hague Program for Cyber Norms (Leiden), and the China-Africa Research Initiative (Johns Hopkins). A 2019 graduate of Harvard Kennedy School’s mid-career Master in Public Administration program, Julia served earlier at the British Embassy in Beijing where she covered China’s cyber and artificial intelligence policy from a commercial perspective, technical standards, and other trade policy issues. Executive Director of the Cyber Project at Harvard Kennedy School’s Belfer Center where she leads research and programming on domestic and international cyber and emerging technology policy issues; her driving vision for the Project is “Cybersecurity is National Security.” She comes to this role as a 2019 graduate of the Kennedy School’s mid-career MPA program. Lauren served as an intelligence officer in the United States Air Force at the beginning of her career. Later, as a civilian intelligence analyst with the National Geospatial Intelligence Agency (NGA) assigned to the Office of Counterterrorism, she completed three war zone deployments where she worked to identify and dismantle terror networks. The Cyber Project Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs Harvard Kennedy School. "The Case for Increased Transatlantic Cooperation on Artificial Intelligence" August. https://www.belfercenter.org/sites/default/files/2020-08/TransatlanticAI.pdf //pipk
The next decade will be a decisive time for the US to shape its future role in the world. Democracies are being tested and toyed with by malign powers, as seen in the form of Russian interference in the 2016 US Presidential elections and subsequent disinformation campaigns by other nations. Great power politics and the national security implications of emerging technologies, such as AI, are breaking up supply chains and further fragmenting the internet. We’re witnessing shocks to the liberal economic order and global governance as a result of several economic crises and the aftermath of the biggest public health crisis in a century. Societies across the world will be looking to develop and implement new technology to deal with crises and recover from economic losses faster. The rise of revisionist powers and the transformative potential of emerging technologies means that the US and its European allies need to prioritize investing in capabilities and its relationships to ensure that emerging technologies align with liberal, democratic values. While the US currently maintains a slight edge in research and development of AI capabilities, that advantage is eroding as a result of a shortage of AI talent, lack of engagement between the federal government, academia, and the private sector, and overall gaps in federal government funding. US innovation has its roots in an open and multicultural society. American leadership in innovation is the result of decades of attracting, training, and recruiting the brightest minds in the world. While recognizing that there are some national security risks, efforts to cut off the flow of students will be detrimental to long-term US innovative capabilities. The European Union while maintaining its role as a leader in AI ethical guidelines, also faces challenges stemming from a lack of talent as well as insufficient funding and uncoordinated AI expertise and application across the Member States. Moreover, the EU suffers from other institutional challenges that are most glaringly demonstrated by the UK’s vote to leave the EU in 2016—which unbeknownst at the time dealt a major blow to the EU’s AI ecosystem. The US and EU need to enhance cooperation in the development and application of AI in healthcare, environmental science, and defense. When the US and EU work together on global challenges such as healthcare and environment science, the rest of the world benefits. And there are other key geopolitical challenges that the US and EU face that can only be balanced together. We are delighted to share with you this analysis of the AI landscape between the US and EU, written and researched by our students working with the Cyber Project and China Cyber Policy Initiative, Christie Lawrence and Sean Cordey. We feel this report provides a strong evidence base for further collaboration, and puts forth thoughtful recommendations. The importance of the transatlantic relationship cannot be understated. The world needs strong leadership in these uncertain times and the US and EU bring unique strengths to the table that collaboratively can strengthen the other’s advantage in the face of unprecedented technological and geopolitical challenges. The US and the EU need to work together.