Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

AI effectiveness key to NATO---pilot projects solve enterprise-level adoption necessary for integration and leadership

Andrea Gilli et al 20, Senior Researcher at the NATO Defense College where he works on issues related to technological change and military innovation. He has been visiting and postdoctoral fellow at Johns Hopkins University and Columbia University as well as Stanford University (where he remains an Affiliate) and Harvard University. Mauro Gilli is a Senior Researcher in Military Technology and International Security at the Center for Security Studies (CSS) at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, ETHZurich. Before joining CSS, he was a post-doctoral fellow at the Dickey Center, Dartmouth College. Ann-Sophie Leonard is a former Mercator Fellow on International Affairs, focusing on the intersection of international security and technology. She was a Visiting Fellow at the Research Division of the NATO Defense College in Rome from September to December 2019. Zoe Stanley-Lockman is an Associate Research Fellow in the Military Transformations Programme at the Institute of Defence and Strategic Studies at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies in Singapore. “NATO-Mation”: Strategies for Leading in the Age of Artificial Intelligence. NDC Research Paper No.15 – December 2020 //pipk

According to many observers, artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning (ML) and big data (BD) are going to promote a dramatic technological transformation affecting every aspect of our lives, every industry and profession, every layer of our societies, with major implications also for international politics.5 The consequences for military affairs and international security are still not fully appreciated or understood.6 Nonetheless, building on previous cases, as well as historical experience with other major technological revolutions, we can reasonably conjecture that the fallout will likely be massive. Countries – and alliances – unable to adapt quickly and thoroughly will be left by the wayside.7 Understanding, preparing for and exploiting this technological transition is thus of utmost importance for NATO and for its Allies.8

The Atlantic Alliance as a whole has an obligation to preserve and extend its military power, maintain its level of prosperity and internal cohesion, lay the conditions for future wealth creation, and make its action more efficient and effective, starting from its core tasks: collective defence, crisis management and cooperative security.9 The technological transformation triggered by AI, ML and BD will, however, challenge many of the assumptions, procedures, capabilities, skills as well as doctrines and strategies underpinning NATO’s current activities.10 There can be no substitute for understanding, preparing and exploiting this AI-centred technological transition, but it will require significant effort.11 The first Industrial Revolution – driven by the combined employment of new mechanical devices – was ultimately about increasing the power of natural energy, and it brought about a dramatically different international system.12 Similarly, the second Industrial Revolution, which allowed for large production runs and thus brought economies of scale centre stage, made “mass” a central tenet of military power, with tragic consequences for international politics due to the emergence of industrial and total war.13 The third Industrial Revolution, with its focus on computation, allowed for much higher levels of precision; and precision came to dominate the battlefield – through long-range guided munitions, real-time intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance assets and stealth, among others.14 Some define our new era as the fourth Industrial Revolution.15 Others speak of the Second Machine Age.16 Regardless of the name, in the age of intelligent machines, machine speed will likely prove one of the defining features of future warfare.17

NATO should act so that it can be at the forefront of this transition, rather than observe it as an onlooker or – even worse – be subjected to it by others. In order to avoid the risk of lagging behind, AI will have to be integrated across the board – i.e., in every single aspect and domain, layer and functional area: from data gathering and processing to communications and cyber-defence, from logistics and medical diagnosis to tactical, operational and strategic decision-making.18 Such enterprise-level adoption would allow Allied forces to run every single procedure and process at machine speed, and thus not find themselves outcompeted. Admittedly, enterprise adoption is challenging – even more so for AI, given that it requires different organizational solutions and culture, talent and skills, and infrastructure support.19

The defence and military capabilities of NATO countries are tightly integrated and coordinated, resulting in combined military power where the sum is greater than its parts. NATO and its Allies will have to integrate AI at enterprise level – in order to preserve their military and technological leadership in the near future – both at the national and coalition level.20 The challenge will thus be massive.

Building on existing academic research and policy discussions, including those related to a NATO Artificial Intelligence Strategy, 21 this Research Paper has a twofold purpose: to contribute to existing debate within the Alliance on AI, ML and BD, and key related issues; and to advance a number of proposals centred on the concept of “NATO-mation” – i.e., equipping the Alliance with the capabilities, organizational structures and strategies to compete in the world of AI.22

Given the major changes now under way, the Atlantic Alliance has a unique opportunity to shape this transformation, rather than sit by as an onlooker. With the concept of “NATO-mation”, this Research Paper aims to promote this goal. The research is based on two guiding principles. On the one hand, individual measures will be crucial to sustain and expand the Alliance’s economic, technological and hence military power, and adapt it to new circumstances and needs. On the other hand, coordination and cooperation among the Allies will be necessary to address the resulting challenges and ensure continued integration in the NATO context.23 Uncoordinated individual actions risk creating a major offset in capabilities among Allies, with a number of negative implications for interoperability, cohesion and consensus. Moreover, because of the very nature of the technologies at hand, the consequences of failure to work in concert could prove even more dramatic.24 The challenge is therefore not limited to technology per se, but includes other equally relevant domains. This is why discussion of the “NATO-mation” concept is divided into the following 11 building blocks: • Ethical purpose: making sure that NATO acts in the ethical domain, following and promoting its founding principles and moral commitments; • Championing innovation: identifying an innovation champion to lead, support, connect and engage with all Allies and relevant stakeholders; • Pilot projects: favouring adoption by promoting small, secure projects with greater likelihood of success; • An innovative workforce: understanding and addressing the human capital requirements this new transition entails; • An innovative workplace: changing organizations to attract and retain talent and thus enable innovation; • Concepts: running simulations, exercises and wargames to test and devise new concepts and technologies; • Technological superiority: maintaining and extending technological leadership and developing new relevant technologies; • Arms control and technology regimes: supporting mechanisms to strengthen international stability and prevent diffusion of critical technologies; • The data pipeline and the AI Network Trinity: promoting the development of the ecosystem necessary to exploit AI, including cloud and quantum computing and 5G networks; • Standards and standardization: enabling interoperability and translating strategic imperatives and ethical commitments into technological solutions; • Primacy of democracy: protecting democracy and democratic values against digital authoritarianism. For each of these building blocks, the paper will discuss the importance of the issue, the key challenges, potential solutions and possible recommendations.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.