Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Solves runaway securitization by the state

Rita Floyd 11, Department of Politics and International Studies, University of Warwick. “Can securitization theory be used in normative analysis? Towards a just securitization theory” Security Dialogue 42(4-5) 427–439 //pipk

Just war theory has attracted both endorsement and criticism. One of the most pertinent criticisms is that it moralizes war, making it easier to fight. In the light of the ‘war on terror’, Anthony Burke (2004: 330), for example, has argued that ‘moral discourses [including just war theory] are part of the warrior’s political armoury; they are part of war’s machinery, not a rod in its wheels’. A similar objection could conceivably be advanced against a just securitization theory. It might be argued that such a theory moralizes securitization, making it easier to exclude and marginalize minorities and control populations. Some scholars already hold that securitization is a process of deliberate ‘insecuritization’. Didier Bigo (2001: 111), for example, has argued that security is in no sense a reflection of an increase of threats in the contemporary epoch – it is a lowering of the level of acceptability of the other; it is an attempt at insecuritization of daily life by the security professionals and an increase in the strengths of police potential for action.

I hold against this first objection that my criteria are robust enough to protect against the abuse of securitization. Note that the insecuritization argument has largely been advanced with a view to migrants in the European Union (Bigo and Guild, 2005; Huysmans, 2006); yet, crucially, under my framework even high levels of migration do not qualify as objective existential threats because the element of intentionality is missing. In the case of migration, we are not even dealing with a collective actor, but with lots of different people and their individual decisions. Intentionality would come into consideration only in the highly unlikely event that one state, perhaps after failing to provide for its own people, would urge or perhaps even pay its own people to emigrate en masse to another state. Under such circumstances, immigration might then become an objective existential threat to the receiving state.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.