No EU tradeoff
EU Institute for Security Studies 19, The European Union Institute for Security Studies (EUISS) is the Union’s agency dealing with the analysis of foreign, security and defence policy issues. Its core mission is to assist the EU and its member states in the implementation of the Common Foreign and Security Policy (CFSP), including the Common Security and Defence Policy (CSDP) as well as other external action of the Union. "The EU Nato and Artificial Intelligence" November 14. https://www.iss.europa.eu/sites/default/files/EUISSFiles/EU%20NATO%20AI%20-%20Report.pdf //pipk
However, the conference also addressed specific challenges to cooperation. It was pointed out that the two organisations occasionally held diverging perspectives on particular issues, such as Lethal Autonomous Weapon Systems (LAWS) or the appropriate balance between laissez-faire and dirigiste approaches to defence industrial and technological matters. The fact that not every EU member state had published their positions on AI yet, while the US AI military strategy does not even mention NATO, did little to bridge these divergent viewpoints. It was also highlighted that despite any possible need for cooperation on AI, the respective mandates and autonomy of each organisation should be respected.
NEXT STEPS FOR EU-NATO COOPERATION A shared view at the event was that moving EU-NATO cooperation forward was essential. As in the cyber domain, the two organisations could play complementary roles, drawing on their respective strengths and instruments, with the EU leading in dual-use and NATO in military standards. The importance of shared values and outlooks was also highlighted on several occasions. The two organisations held similar perspectives on fundamental issues, including the unknown qualities of AI in defence, the need for technological partnership between democracies, an AI arms control regime and strong links between government and industry. In addition, cooperation required a shared understanding of AI. Creating a common vocabulary was key in this respect, an area that the European Defence Agency (EDA) was already working. It was also noted that inter-institutional cooperation would not be fully effective until each organisation developed an internally coherent outlook, with clearly defined goals, threat perceptions and a goal-driven approach to AI.