The communist tenant of a moneyless society is impossible – no incentive for production and can’t quantify how to spend time and capital
Hersey and Walker-Werth, 22 --- Jon Hersey is managing editor of The Objective Standard and holds fellowships at Foundation for Economic Education. Thomas Walker-Werth is associate editor of The Objective Standard. He is an Ayn Rand Fellow with Foundation for Economic Education's Hazlitt Project. He holds a master’s degree in music from Oxford Brookes University (Hersey, Jon, and Thomas Walker-Werth, "Star Trek, Marx, Maezawa, and the Moneyless Dream: Utopian or Dystopian?", spring 2022, The Objective Standard, https://go-gale com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/ps/i.do?p=AONE&u=umuser&id=GALE%7CA706181904&v=2.1&it=)//EG
Although Marx considered himself a social scientist and economist--and although his ideas are still some of the most widely taught--they aren't much taught in social science or economics departments, except as foils. That's because virtually all of Marx's hypotheses have been debunked. For one, who's going to build the free Ferraris that Maezawa has dreamed up, never mind tackle more mundane tasks, with no incentive? But for those who don't find such commonsense thought experiments convincing--or who think, as Marx did, that human nature will somehow mysteriously change--the impracticality of Marx's moneyless state was demonstrated by what Austrian economists have come to call the calculation problem. Ludwig von Mises once explained the problem as follows: If a hydroelectric power station is to be built, one must know whether or not this is the most economical way to produce the energy needed. How can he know this if he cannot calculate costs and output? We may admit that in its initial period a socialist regime could to some extent rely upon the experience of the preceding age of capitalism. But what is to be done later, as conditions change more and more? Of what use could the prices of 1900 be for the director in 1949? And what use can the director in 1980 derive from the knowledge of the prices of 1949? The paradox of "planning" is that it cannot plan, because of the absence of economic calculation. What is called a planned economy is no economy at all. It is just a system of groping about in the dark. (6) In short, without prices, people have no relatable, quantifiable means of comparing and contrasting options about how to spend time and capital, which is vital for determining how best to use these naturally scarce resources. "New Scientist magazine reported that in the future, cars could be powered by hazelnuts," said comedian Jimmy Fallon, in a skit that captures Mises's point hilariously. "That's encouraging, considering an eight-ounce jar of hazelnuts costs about nine dollars. Yeah, I've got an idea for a car that runs on bald eagle heads and Faberge eggs." But there's more. As has been shown with so many of Marx's ideas, a moneyless society is not only impractical, it's also deeply immoral. Marx often grumbled about greedy capitalists alienating workers from their labor. The focus on efficiency, he said, reduced the worker to a mere extension of a factory's machines, rendering him a brute tool of capitalist exploitation. Of course, workers chose industrial jobs because they paid better than those in agriculture and the like. And even if boring, such jobs rarely were so backbreaking as life on the farm. Far from alienating workers from their labor, the capitalist arranged new modes of production that vastly increased the value of that labor, not only for himself, but for workers, too. Whereas a slave truly is alienated from his labor--he works but is deprived of the fruits of his effort--the industrial worker could count on greater returns from his labor than ever before. Over the course of the Industrial Revolution and the following centuries, those returns have grown immensely and reduced the percentage of people living in extreme poverty from more than 80 percent to less than 20. Money stores the value of one's effort. It's made possible by the legal protection of property rights. In the words of Francisco d'Anconia from Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged: Money rests on the axiom that every man is the owner of his mind and his effort. Money allows no power to prescribe the value of your effort except the voluntary choice of the man who is willing to trade you his effort in return. Money permits you to obtain for your goods and your labor that which they are worth to the men who buy them, but no more. Money permits no deals except those to mutual benefit by the unforced judgment of the traders. (7) Just as the worker owns himself, he owns the values he produces, on which his life depends, either directly or indirectly via the sale of those values. Without money and the property rights that underlie it, we all would be truly and fully alienated from our labor, left without enforceable claim to the values we spend our time--and thus our lives--creating. That's an idea hardly fit even for science fiction, one best relegated to the dystopian genre.