The counterplan linearly increases state involvement in foreign affairs.
Peter Howard, 4 (Peter Howard is the economics director at Policy Integrity, and a former economic fellow, May 2004, accessed on 7-2-2022, International Studies Perspectives, Vol. 5, No. 2, “The Growing Role of States in U.S. Foreign Policy: The Case of the State Partnership Program”, https://www.jstor.org/stable/44218880?seq=1, HBisevac)
As the preceding case illustrates, states can play a significant role in implementing U.S. foreign policy. The National Guard’s State Partnership Program has given states a critical role in U.S. engagement programs. The networks of opportunity created by the number of SPP funding sources and potential programs have allowed entrepreneurial state actors to shape a unique course for each partnership. Some innovative state coordinators have, on their own initiative, tapped other funds, such as cooperative threat reduction programs or environmental programs to further the reach of their state partnership. The participating state National Guards are uniquely positioned in this respect—they are connected to both the state and federal governments through their dual mission and contain vast experience including military duties, support to civilians, and regular civilian jobs. This gives an enterprising state a chance to make a significant impact in the content of U.S. foreign policy. The meaning attached to that policy is created, in part, by the actions undertaken in the name of that policy. Through their implementation of the SPP, states have shaped the meaning of U.S. foreign policy of engaging the former communist states of Eastern Europe and NATO enlargement. This is not to say that all National Guards and Partnerships are equally forward-leaning, but some can be, and in a way not directed or anticipated by the federal government.
Early criticisms that military engagement programs lacked direction (Ulrich, 1999) have receded as programs such as the SPP evolve into more sophisticated enterprise. Recent analyses of the SPP have revealed that all of the program’s “stakeholders,” including the governors, the National Guard, the U.S. Defense Department, and the partner countries, are enamored with the program’s success.”° With ten years of experience, the National Guard has developed a “life cycle” approach to each state partnership. Early in the life of the partnership, mil-mil exchanges dominate. After a certain point, however, the marginal utility of additional military familiarization exchanges declines, and mil-civ and civ—civ exchanges rise to take their place. As the partnerships mature and are dominated by the civilian exchanges, state governments take an even greater role in initiating and implementing international relationships.
An implementation perspective on the analysis of foreign policy makes this insight possible. Analyses of foreign policy that rely solely on a decision-making perspective miss the important role that states are playing in U.S. foreign and national security policy. While most of the primary decisions are still made by the president, his administration, and Congress, states are gaining an ever-increasing role in implementing those decisions. The SPP is but one example. Guard units are also taking a greater role in peacekeeping activities in the Balkans, and may do so in a postwar Iraq. The intense focus on homeland security is yet another policy area where states will implement most policy decisions. The guard has already been active in domestic security operations, flying combat air patrols and providing airport security, and several studies and senators have advocated an even larger role for the guard in homeland security (Miller, 2002). Emergency response and law enforcement are still state and local responsibilities, and these areas are the new front lines in homeland security and the war on terrorism. The states, which perform these duties, have a vital say in how they will be done. As independent and entrepreneurial implementers, the states are carving out a larger role in shaping the environment in which federal decision makers act.
Policy decisions are important, but many of those decisions lack meaning unless they create content and action. In the long run, policy implementation—the practice of what states and countries do with each other—produces the substance that give rules and identities their meaning. It is this meaning that ultimately forms the environment to which future decision makers respond. It is here that the federal government’s monopoly in international affairs begins to erode and it is here that states are finding an ever-growing role in U.S. foreign policy.