Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Even if the FG is tangentially involved, the SPP completely avoids politics

Hightower 17, PhD in Public Policy and Management (Rudolph, “National Security Policy Complexity: An Analysis of U.S. Defense Security Cooperation Program Effects on Political Terror,” Proquest Dissertations)

Currently, the senior-most foreign military and civilian decision makers who have previously and are currently participating in the program view the State Partnership Program in glowing terms. The following illustrates the level of endorsement of the security cooperation program: "…Multiply that by 22 all around Europe and you can see the bang for the buck here is really quite significant.[SPP] is a very powerful tool. It is unmatched. They are, bang for the buck, one of the best things going. Anything that enhances state partnership is money in the bank for the regional combatant commanders.” - Admiral James Stavridis, Former USEUCOM Commander Retired US Navy Admiral Stavridis’ glowing praise of SPP is not unique. There is evidence of a significant quantitative knowledge gap between security cooperation stakeholders and government policy evaluators. National Guard leadership and foreign partners continually state these qualitative outcomes of SPP. Conversely, the Government Accounting Office (GAO) and Congressional Research Service (CRS) have concluded that SPP needs far more quantitative data collection and analysis to properly assess program efficiency and effectiveness. The measurable outcomes, not merely public budgeting line item outputs, on democratic consolidation principles such as reducing political terror in partner nations, are needed to assess SPP program effectiveness. Though the program is wildly popular, there remains a disconnection between leadership’s pronouncements and a testable, measurable program evaluation. Until most recently, SPP effectiveness as has been qualitatively evaluated and the results consistently associated with the value of trust-building and strengthening relationships with foreign partners (NGAUS, 2016). Evaluation metrics included outputs related to the number of foreign engagement missions, the numbers of individual troops participating in SPP events, and the dollars spent in implementing the SPP annually. The evaluation of program effectiveness has not broached the broader concept of the whether the program affects long-term outcomes on democratic consolidation and political terror. Countering the possibly biased qualitative assessment of stakeholders, the official US Government’s assessments of security cooperation programs in general, and of SPP, in particular, offer much more tempered endorsements of such programs: According to the private National Guard of the United States Association (NGUSA): The National Guard State Partnership Program (SPP) is one of the most innovative low-cost security cooperation tools available to the United States…In addition to military-to-military engagements; SPP leverages the whole-of-society relations and capabilities to facilitate broader interagency and whole-of-government engagements. Though policymaker support for DSC programs is strong and pronouncements of great success are common, there is a counter-argument to its success. There are obvious real-world events that challenge the efficaciousness of DSC programs in building stabilization and/or stemming the use of state security forces to violently suppress political dissent or for soldiers to attack the government. These counter arguments are usually in real world news headlines from around the world. 31

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.