Doing both ruins the process and decks effectiveness.
James N. Williams, 12 (Lieutenant Colonel James N. Williams, Army National Guard, March 2012, accessed on 6-30-2022, United States Army War Project Strategy Research Project, “The National Guard State Partnership Program: Element of Smart Power”, https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/pdfs/ADA562110.pdf, HBisevac)
Any new directives, regulations or statutory authorities would be most effective with a “bottom-up” approach, using input from the National Guard to the greatest extent possible. Given the vastness and diversity of the programs requirements, the coordinators at the National Guard Bureau level should be the “trusted advisors” to ensure that language incorporated into evolving guidance ensure the flexibility required to administer the program effectively “where the rubber meets the road.”
The Bureau can most effectively synthesize the discrete nuances across the program into a cohesive representation for the further development of directives and authorities. Without initial input from the program level, any top-driven attempts to develop guidance will ultimately fail to achieve the balance and flexibility required to effectively administer the program. The National Guard Bureau has had over twenty years experience with this program and is the only single agency that truly has the “big picture.” The Bureau is more than capable of fairly and honestly representing the needs of the partner nations consistent with the requirements of the Department of State, the Geographic Combatant Commanders and the American taxpayers.