Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

State SPP security cooperation solves better than federal action.

James N. Williams, 12 (Lieutenant Colonel James N. Williams, Army National Guard, March 2012, accessed on 6-30-2022, United States Army War Project Strategy Research Project, “The National Guard State Partnership Program: Element of Smart Power”, https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/pdfs/ADA562110.pdf, HBisevac) **edited for gendered language**

Using the National Guard as a primary tool to develop relationships with potential allies is a diplomatic multiplier, and its utility across the various domains of diplomacy was recognized after only a few years of effort. In a 2002 article in the Washington Quarterly, former Colorado Governor Bill Owens touted the State Partnership Program as a proven approach for “strategic democracy building.” 23 Governor Owens was one of the first to document the SPP’s “quiet achievements” in facilitating the development of emerging democracies beyond the typical military-to-military exchanges. For perhaps the first time, under SPP state governments became involved in helping the federal government in achieving diplomatic goals abroad.

By 1995, the program had expanded its scope to include “multifaceted engagement activities…in the social, economic and military spheres.” 24 In cooperation with state and municipal agencies, the program provided assistance and training in “emergency management, disaster relief operations, civil and criminal justice, judicial processes, and law enforcement.” 25 As a result of these engagements over time, more informal relationships developed. “Through SPP, many countries have established successful governmental, educational, and medical relationships with counterpart agencies from the partner states.” 26

This is the greatest advantage of the State Partnership Program. Because of the dual-status nature of the National Guard as both a federal and a state agency, manned [staffed] by citizen-soldiers, it is only natural for relationships to develop beyond the military aspect of the partnership. The citizen-soldiers of the National Guard are natural ambassadors for the American people, who also happen to have military skills. And while their military skills are the primary tools for engagement, their civilian skills and experiences also add intangible factors that enhance these interactions with their counterparts.

National Guard soldiers are more closely tied to their families and their communities than the typical active component soldiers living on large bases. They also have a certain local perspective that they bring to the table and, all politics being local, citizen-soldiers understand issues that are important to the common man, his family and his community. It is from this perspective that sincere and lasting relationships are developed with their counterparts.

Governor Owens was not the only state executive to understand the value of the State Partnership Program. Former Wisconsin Lieutenant Governor Barbara Lawton not only understood the program’s inherent value, she also saw vast untapped potential for further public and citizen diplomacy. In 2010 she chaired a roundtable discussion calling for more citizen-diplomacy, using SPP as a model for what she described as a “State Partnership Framework” to facilitate increased contact at the state and local level. In the report of the discussion, the SPP was recognized by Lieutenant Governor Lawton as one of two existing, trusted state institutions (the other being state universities), that “are ideally positioned to develop a strategic hybrid of public and citizen diplomacy in fifty states.” 27

The conference’s focus on the potential role of the citizen and the individual states in shaping U.S. foreign relations goes straight to the heart of the potential of SPP. While public diplomacy is government-centric, citizen diplomacy, through face to face personal encounters, carries “greater credibility with foreign audiences.” 28 Some suggested areas for state facilitation of citizen diplomacy include education, economic development, science and technology. While the forum was centered on citizen diplomacy and the role of the state, it was clear the State Partnership Program was recognized as having already transcended the gap between government and citizen diplomacy.

The ability to establish enduring relationships is a unique attribute of the National Guard. “The SPP model has proven successful in building and sustaining enduring and trusting strategic partnerships in environments where conventional U.S. government efforts may not be as effective. Individuals in leadership may change, but the commitment of a state National Guard as a more intimate, accessible, and agile partner than a national entity – has proven to be reliable for partner countries.”29

Conference participants included representatives from the Departments of Defense and State, as well as academia. Among the notable attendees was Reta Jo Lewis, State Department Special Representative for Intergovernmental Affairs, who also touted the program’s role in diplomacy. Although the federal government, not the states, has the responsibility for conducting Foreign Policy, Ms Lewis remarked that networks of state and local leaders can help the Department of State to “establish durable foreign partnerships…at the sub-national level.” “Sometimes the personal relationships that are created through the SPP can have a stronger and more intimate connection than those we establish at the national and diplomatic level.”30

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.