SPP programs enhance interoperability AND allied integration.
Tracey Poirier, 17 (Lieutenant Colonel Tracey Poirier, Vermont Army National Guard, 1-4-2017, accessed on 7-1-2022, United States Army War College Strategy Research Project, “Increasing Interoperability and Preparedness through the State Partnership Program”, https://publications.armywarcollege.edu/pubs/3481.pdf, HBisevac)
The National Guard State Partnership Program (SPP) has continually received rave reviews from Combatant Commanders. Major General Frederick S. Rudesheim, US Army South Commander, called the program “almost incalculable.”3 Admiral James Winnefeld, Vice Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, called it “one of the best foreign policy bargains our nation has.”4 Perhaps the most ringing endorsement comes from Admiral James Stavridis, Former US European Command Commander, when he stated the SPP is, “a very powerful tool. It is unmatched. They are, bang for the buck, one of the best things going. Anything that enhances state partnership is money in the bank for the regional combatant commanders.” 5 In fact, it is difficult to find a criticism of the program from anyone who has experienced it on the ground. Given such reviews, why would the US government not expand its model to include more interactions that would improve interoperability with partner nations?
The SPP model uses the power of American ideas and perpetuates them through personal relationships. Additionally, it can give the US the opportunity to improve infrastructure in various regions around the globe advancing our logistical readiness. However, the effectiveness of ideas and relationships are difficult to measure and too often, we choose not to. The Partnership Program is no exception. The program’s annual report shows measures of performance only and does not assess its effectiveness.
This paper will explore the power of sustained relationships and idea sharing in relation to the National Guard State Partnership Program. It will make a case for logistical preparation of the battlefield through the program for both infrastructure improvement and economic development. Furthermore, it will address the ineffectiveness of the current means of program assessment and provide recommendations for improvement.
The Power of Ideas, Relationships, and Being Prepared
Only history will tell if the success of the US is one that will last, but there is little doubt that the power it holds in the current international world order is unmatched. Whether we are watched in covetousness, fear, awe, or disdain--we are watched. American power likely lies in a combination of realms that include economic, political and military components, but we should not discount the power of American ideas. The idea that liberty could act as a cornerstone for responsible government was one of America’s first and greatest ideas. While there is much debate on whether democracy is a right fit for all nations, liberty in the form of self-determination is viewed as necessary for the liberal world order. President George Bush stated in his second inaugural address, “the survival of liberty in our land increasingly depends on the success of liberty in other lands. The best hope for peace in our land is the expansion of freedom in all the world.”6 However, liberty is not the only American idea that resonates around the globe. Capitalism, free trade, and civic responsibility are all ideas that have found purchase in even the most unlikely global forums.
Ideas are not necessarily epiphenomenal, however. Ideas, often thought of as dependent variables, can also be independent in that the idea itself will play a role in the way people shape their environment.7 It is this concept that explains why decisions and changes that the United States makes are felt around the globe. Our ideas take on a cultural power of their own and become a useful tool in advancing the international world order. Given the power of our ideas, the US needs to spend conscious effort in sharing the good ones. The culture of ideas often spreads on its own; however, adding the power of a mutually beneficial relationship can increase the results.
The power of relational transactions is readily understood by most; however, Americans tend to apply the concept within their own cultural paradigms. This can be a dangerous practice, especially now that the US unipolar moment is at an end.8 Although the idea of unipolarity was generally accepted after the fall of the Soviet Union, perhaps the US was never truly in a unipolar moment. The US has always relied on allies and partners to attain its goals when acting on foreign soil. Essentially, the US cannot accomplish power projection on land in the current liberal world order without assistance from partners. That assistance may take the form of merely granting access, but in most cases provides local industry and services and, in the best cases, labor and resources. These partnerships take time and effort to be effective and do not come without challenges such as that of alignment of interests and degree of commitment.9 Strong relationships with these potential partners will naturally reduce the friction of coalition creation.
Relationships with some level of permanence, nurtured over time, have a far greater likelihood of producing goal alignment and commitment that can overcome integration and interoperability issues. However, the way in which the US government manages foreign diplomatic relationships on various levels such as US Agency for International Development (USAID) and the Foreign Service is very similar to the active military service in that individuals move from position to position throughout their career within an area of expertise. Both organizations’ personnel systems are not organized in such a way to encourage long-term relationships. While the relationship between a given country and the US may be enduring, the relationships with individuals in the foreign diplomacy realm tend to be fleeting. Short-term assignments can be detrimental to relationship building and keep the US from realizing a full level of logistical preparation in these partner regions. In much the same way as the spread of ideas and building of long-term relationships helps to integrate with partners on a cognitive level, building partner capacity in a physical sense through logistical preparation and infrastructure improvement can ensure interoperability. Having interoperability is important if we should find ourselves in a conflict or humanitarian assistance role in areas without a significant US or North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) presence.
Michael Desch writes that military effectiveness is a “preponderance in the material power assets available to the state.”10 This availability includes both the equipment and supplies that a country brings to the fight and the supplies and access they are able to acquire in the regions where they are involved. The ability to set the theater prior to a conflict is paramount to the success of any long-term engagement. The Marine Expeditionary Unit is often the first unit to arrive in a theater in a crisis. It can sustain itself for only 15 days before it needs resupply.11 Even when entire divisions enter a theater with full sustainment packages, all the supplies must travel along the local lines of communication and often rely on local labor at debarkation sights. Longterm sustainment of forces in theater requires compatible infrastructure and local contracts to be effective and efficient. The State Partnership Program is ideally suited to creating the relationships needed in countries throughout the world that increase our preparedness for conflict wherever it may arise.