Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Uniqueness question – neoliberalism is collapsing in on its own problems – that means cripped, mad collectives are necessary

Jess Whatcott 21 [Crip Collectivity Beyond Neoliberalism in Octavia Butler’s Parable of the Sower, Cripistemologies of Crisis: Emergent Knowledges for the Present, Issue 10.1 (Spring 2021), https://csalateral.org/section/cripistemologies-of-crisis/crip-collectivity-beyond-neoliberalism-octavia-butler-parable-of-the-sower-whatcott/, -ekh-]

I have argued that as a cripistemological fiction, Octavia Butler’s 1993 novel Parable of the Sower imagines the possibilities for crip flourishing through collective emergence within and against neoliberal precarity. While this parable about crip life beyond the state is generative, I recognize that it is difficult to imagine how to meet the need for modern technologies to keep disabled and mad people alive outside of the market and state models. Currently, the state seems like the best—although not necessarily the only—way to enforce access and to distribute life-saving services and technologies. It may therefore seem counterintuitive to conclude that a future of crip thriving and flourishing is only possible through a critical perspective of neoliberal modes of state governance. Yet without devoting energies to creating lifesaving services and technologies beyond the state apparatus, disabled and mad people will be stuck in an endless precarious neoliberal loop of crisis, cure, neglect, and scapegoating. The disaster that opens Parable predicts that the neoliberal state is always already imploding under the weight of problems it helped to create, including urban divestment, wealth inequality, and climate change. As the real-life versions of similar disasters have demonstrated, the most acute effect of neoliberal precarity is on racialized communities, on women and gender diverse people within those communities, and on disabled and mad people. The need to think outside the state is not just speculation—racialized and gendered crip communities are always necessarily creating their own terms of survival and developing communities of flourishing beyond the neoliberal state.

Such community has emerged among readers of Parable. Readers and scholars of Butler gather digitally, physically, and intellectually, through the creation of such infrastructures as Wildseeds: New Orleans Octavia Butler Emergent Strategy Collective (co-founded by Desiree Evans and Soraya Jean-Louis McElroy), Emergent Strategy Ideation Institute (founded by adrienne maree brown), and the Octavia Butler Legacy Network (founded by Ayana A.H. Jamieson). In these communities, Butler’s work is treated as a pedagogical, at times sacred, text containing much needed wisdom about survival, healing, and creating a future where communities of color, women, and gender diverse people can flourish. These communities are an example of the kinds of collective emergence that can be scaled up from the imaginary of speculative fiction into the level of the material world. 

If, as I join others in insisting, Butler’s fiction is a cripistemological text, then Parable contains knowledge precisely for developing networks of mutual aid through which crip and mad people, specifically, can survive and flourish. Parable offers a critique of neoliberalism, an essential imaginary of “feminist, queer, crip” “flourishing” (in Kafer’s and Berne’s terms), and, finally, operates as a foundation for real-life community building, as Butler’s readers and scholars connect digitally and in person. This last is an example of putting speculative fiction as theory into “practice” in a whole new way. Disabled and mad people in the real world currently face the kinds of rapid climate change catastrophe and abandonment by the neoliberal state presciently imagined by Octavia Butler in Parable of the Sower. Collective crip emergence as praxis, facilitated through the gathering of speculative fiction readers, is an urgent and timely practice for realizing futures for crip and mad people.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.