Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

Reversal of Roe v Wade could flip midterms towards the democrats

Scher 7/5 – Bill Scher is a political writer at the Washington Monthly. He is the host of the history podcast When America Worked and the cohost of the bipartisan online show and podcast The DMZ., 7-5-2022, "The End of Roe v. Wade Could Help Democrats in These Midterm Races," Washington Monthly, https://washingtonmonthly.com/2022/07/05/the-end-of-roe-v-wade-could-help-democrats-in-these-midterm-races/

Here are some vulnerable Republicans. GOVERNORS: Brian Kemp (Georgia), Ron DeSantis (Florida), and Greg Abbott (Texas) These Republican governors signed abortion bans that are unpopular in their states. Just this week, a Quinnipiac poll showed the Georgia gubernatorial race between incumbent Republican Brian Kemp and former House Minority Leader Stacey Abrams in a dead heat, with Abrams closing a two-point gap since January. However, a smattering of prior polls from other outfits suggests that Kemp may still hold a slight lead. Kemp signed a 2019 law effectively banning abortion after six weeks of pregnancy, with exceptions for risking the mother’s death, “medically futile” pregnancies, and—if a police report is filed—rape and incest. The law has not been enacted because of a federal court injunction, but now that Roe is gone, the injunction should be soon lifted. Most Georgians won’t celebrate. A January Atlanta Journal-Constitution poll found that 54 percent of Georgia voters opposed the law, and 68 percent did not want Roe overturned. The Democratic gubernatorial nominee in Texas, former Representative Beto O’Rourke, might face a tougher battle as he trails Governor Gregg Abbott by five points in the most recent Quinnipiac poll and eight points in the most recent CBS/YouGov poll. But regarding abortion policy, Quinnipiac found that Texas voters preferred O’Rourke over Abbott by two points. And 59 percent of Texans in the CBS/YouGov poll disapprove of Abbott’s handling of abortion. (The Quinnipiac poll was taken before, and the CBS/YouGov poll was partially taken before, the Dobbs ruling.) Perhaps O’Rourke can widen that margin. Abbott has already enacted a six-week abortion ban and a ban on most distribution of abortion pills. He also signed a trigger law, which will soon detonate, banning all abortions except to save the mother’s life, with a maximum sentence of 99 years for abortion providers. Yet, according to the June Quinnipiac poll, 59 percent of Texas voters support legal abortion in all or most cases. A December Spectrum News/Ipsos poll found that 55 percent opposed the six-week ban. As I wrote last month, Abbott’s unpopular abortion position hadn’t weakened his overall standing, because the impact of his policies hadn’t been widely felt. Most Texans seeking abortions were still getting them, either by illegally obtaining pills or by crossing state lines. But with an even more draconian law about to go into effect and disappearing abortion access in three of its four neighboring states, the loss of reproductive freedom may soon be more painfully noticeable. In Florida, DeSantis signed a law in April banning abortion after 15 weeks of pregnancy, a rare example of the right-wing firebrand not going to the farthest possible extreme. He is being pressured by the right to go further in the wake of Dobbs, even though most Florida voters didn’t want him to go as far as he did. In a February poll from the University of North Florida, 57 percent opposed the 15-week ban, which went up to 62 percent when informed that the legislation had no exceptions for rape and incest. Florida’s support for abortion rights is long-standing, and the state constitution includes a right to privacy that has been interpreted by state courts to cover reproductive freedom. A 2012 attempt to supersede court rulings with an anti-abortion ballot initiative failed, with 55 percent of the electorate voting against it. In fact, on June 30, a county circuit judge placed a temporary injunction on the 15-week ban because it runs afoul of the state constitution. But the Florida Supreme Court is stocked with Republican appointees—who serve six-year terms—and may follow the U.S. Supreme Court’s example, disregard precedent, and overrule the lower court. If it upholds the ban, that will give the Democratic nominee—to be chosen in an August primary—an even stronger argument for replacing DeSantis. Other 2022 governor’s races to keep an eye on: Arizona, Iowa, Ohio, South Carolina, and South Dakota: According to the data from Grumbach and Warshaw, these states have pro-choice majorities. (South Dakota just barely, though its voters in 2006 and 2008 defeated proposed abortion bans in referenda.) Yet Ohio’s Mike DeWine, Iowa’s Kim Reynolds, and South Carolina’s Henry McMaster all signed effective six-week bans (injunctions have been lifted in Ohio and South Carolina). South Dakota’s 2005 trigger law lacks rape and incest exceptions—and defies the voters’ will in subsequent referenda. Nevertheless, it’s kicking in with Governor Kristi Noem’s enthusiastic support. Also, in Arizona, where the incumbent Republican is not running for reelection, a 1901 law banning abortions enacted when Arizona was a territory might be resurrected. The four incumbents are viewed as having easy paths to reelection in November; The Cook Report with Amy Walter rates McMaster, Noem, and Reynolds as “Solid,” with DeWine as “Likely.” But it’s worth watching to see if their unpopular abortion stances give their Democratic challengers a fresh foothold.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.