Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

Increasing defense spending on NATO is unpopular across the board—causes the dem’s to lose swing votes

Steven Kull 19, April 2019, Dr. Steven Kull is a political psychologist who studies the impact of public opinion on public policy. He has conducted polls and focus groups in over 30 countries around the, Program for Public Consultation, No Publication, https://publicconsultation.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/NATO_Report_0419.pdf

Defense Spending Levels by NATO Allies Respondents were told about the dispute between the US and other NATO members regarding their lower levels of defense spending towards NATO. Presented three options for dealing with this situation, the least popular option was to press European countries to spend more by threatening to disengage from Europe and possibly withdraw from NATO. The most popular option for both parties, supported by half, was to remain part of NATO, but reduce U.S. military investments to bring them more in line with the level that the Europeans spend. The second most popular option was to press European countries to spend more, but not to threaten to disengage or withdraw from NATO. Respondents were introduced to the dispute between the US and European NATO members over defense spending levels as follows: For some years now there has been a dispute between the U.S. and other members of NATO about their level of defense spending. The U.S. has complained that it spends about 4-5% of the U.S. economy on its military, while European nations generally spend about 2% or less, some as low as 1%. Europeans point out that the amount that the U.S. spends is not only in Europe but also in Asia and in the U.S. homeland, and that Europe already spends twice as much as Russia, which is NATO’s primary focus. Nonetheless, in 2014, the European NATO partners agreed to set a goal to increase their defense spending to at least 2% of their budget. There have been some increases, but only 4 of the 26 European countries have met this goal, though several more are expected to reach this level within the year. One of the largest countries, Germany, is unlikely to reach it at any point in the near future. They were then told that there is some debate about what the U.S. should do about this situation and were asked to evaluate three options with an argument in favor of each one. Three possible approaches were presented. The first argument stressed that the Europeans should stop taking advantage of the US after it freed them from Hitler and defended them during the Cold War, that the Europeans can afford to do their share, and that the Russians pose a smaller threat, so if Europeans do not do more, the US should be ready to disengage from Europe. This argument did only moderately well with an overall majority of 56% finding it convincing. However, there was a sharp partisan divide: 76% of Republicans, but only 39% of Democrats found it convincing. Likewise in very red districts 61% found this argument convincing, but only 43% in very blue districts. The second proposal considered was to press European countries to spend more, but to refrain from threatening to disengage from Europe or withdraw from NATO. The argument for this stressed that it is not really feasible to withdraw from Europe or NATO, that the US should not make such a threat, that doing so could backfire by emboldening Russia and causing Eastern European countries to draw closer to Russia, and that overall, it is better for the US to stand close to Europe and that doing so is affordable. This argument did far better than the first argument. Overall 80% found it convincing as did 87% of Democrats. Among Republicans , 72% found it convincing — roughly the same as the 76% who found the argument for the first proposal convincing — suggesting substantial ambivalence. In very red districts , 72% found the argument convincing — more than the 61% that found the argument for the first proposal convincing. The third proposal was that the US should remain in NATO but adjust its military investment there to be more in line with the European investment. This argument stressed that the European members of NATO spend a substantial amount on the military and many troops under arms, that their reluctance to spend more is understandable given the low level of threat from Russia, that adjusting US commitments might cause Europeans to do more, but even if they do not, NATO will still be far stronger than Russia. This argument also did quite well with 74% finding it convincing. Among Republicans (77%) and in very red districts (75%) it did the best of all arguments, with 72% of Democrats concurring. Asked for their final recommendation, the clear favorite, endorsed by about half overall and by both parties, was the third option. The least attractive option was to threaten withdrawal from Europe and NATO , which was endorsed by just 12% overall —one in five Republicans and a miniscule 4% of Democrats. The option of pressing the Europeans but not threatening withdrawal was endorse d by 35% overall — Republicans 29%, Democrats 41%. Those who voted for Donald Trump in 2016 did not differ much from Republicans. One in five said the US should threaten to withdraw, while 48% favored adjusting the US military commitment.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.