2AC---Oversight Fails---Cybersecurity
Congress can’t keep up in cybersecurity due to political divisions
Marks 21 [Joe Marks writes The Cybersecurity 202 newsletter focused on the policy and politics of cybersecurity. Before joining The Washington Post, Marks covered cybersecurity for Politico and Nextgov, a news site focused on government technology and security. He also covered patent and copyright trends for Bloomberg BNA and federal litigation for Law360 https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/12/08/congress-cant-even-pass-easy-cyber-stuff/]//LP
Expansive new cyber reporting requirements now appear dead in Congress. Congress has cut requirements for companies to share cyber threat information with the government from its must-pass defense bill, which passed the House last night and is expected to pass the Senate shortly. The failure of such a popular and bipartisan effort – which would have marked the largest expansion of government involvement in private-sector cybersecurity in years – raises questions about whether Congress is up to the task of responding to a wave of ransomware and other attacks that have battered industry in recent years. It would have required companies in critical industry sectors such as energy and transportation to alert the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency whenever they’re hacked or hit with other significant cyber incidents. It would have required disclosures from a far broader group of companies if they paid ransoms to hackers. But the measure also looked meager given the hacking threats facing industry. More than 90 percent of cyber experts and current and former officials supported the changes in a recent Cybersecurity 202 poll. The government has already imposed far more stringent cyber requirements on several key industry sectors in just the past few months. “This result is beyond disappointing and undermines national security,” said House Homeland Security Chairman Bennie G. Thompson (D-Miss.) and Rep. Yvette Clarke (D-N.Y.), chair of the committee’s cyber panel and a sponsor of the House version of the bill. Sen. Rick Scott (R-Fla.) wanted to curtail a cyber reporting provision in a major defense policy bill. It ended up getting cut entirely. (Jabin Botsford/The Washington Post) The dispute centered on the ransomware provision, which Sen. Rick Scott (R-Fla.) considered too broad, Senate aides told me. Scott wanted to substitute a provision that would have limited ransomware reports to just critical infrastructure — that’s a group of 16 industry sectors that includes financial services, health care and chemical facilities among others. The fight over the provision lasted so long that by the time they’d reached a compromise, House and Senate negotiators who were putting together the final bill ended up leaving it out entirely, as Tim Starks reports for CyberScoop. The fine print Because of some peculiarities about how the bill came together this year, lawmakers could still try to add amendments in the Senate, including the cyber reporting provisions. But leaders of the House and Senate Armed Services Committees are begging them not to out of fear one or more of those amendments will prevent the bill from passing entirely. If that happens, it would mark the first time in more than five decades Congress has failed to pass the bill, known as the National Defense Authorization Act. Sen. Gary Peters (D-Mich.) championed a cyber reporting provision that got cut from the National Defense Authorization Act. (Jabin Botsford/The Washington Post) The blame game: Thompson and Clarke laid the blame for provision being cut at the feet of Senate Republican leaders as did Senate Homeland Security Chairman Gary Peters (D-Mich.). “I am disappointed Senate Republican leaders blocked these common sense provisions that have broad bipartisan support — including from the bipartisan leaders of the Senate Homeland Security and Intelligence Committees,” Peters said. “Cyberattacks, including ransomware attacks, are one of the greatest threats to our national and economic security.” An aide for Scott told The Hill’s Maggie Miller that Scott was disappointed the full provision got left out of the NDAA and that he’d only wanted to limit its scope. He denied Republicans were to blame.
Congressional oversight over cyber fails
Cordero and Thaw 20 [Carrie Cordero and David Thaw; Member of the Homeland Security Advisory Council, CNN legal and national security analyst and professor of law at Georgetown / Professor at the University of Pittsburg in the School of Law with a focus in cybersecurity; “Rebooting Congressional Cybersecurity Oversight”; January 30, 2020; DOA: 6/24/22; ; Lowell-ES]
Currently, existing laws, executive structure, and congressional oversight mechanisms are a mismatch for the nature of the cybersecurity challenges presented by a complex, technologically integrated society. Existing mechanisms for congressional cybersecurity oversight are likewise disjointed and uncoordinated. Unlike in many other policy areas, there is no one clear committee or clear set of committees responsible for cybersecurity issues. These are divided among many committees in both the House of Representatives and the Senate, often along historical lines that may not match current expertise. The Judiciary committees often encounter cybersecurity issues in the context of surveillance, cybercrime enforcement, and privacy issues. The Armed Services committees are called upon to consider cybersecurity issues when evaluating legislation concerning offensive and defensive cyber capabilities, which are part of the government’s response to counter hostile cyber activities by foreign nation-states. The Intelligence committees engage on cybersecurity activities most recently from the perspective of protecting electoral system infrastructure from foreign influence and malign cyber activities related to foreign interference in democratic processes. And the Homeland Security committees are heavily involved in cybersecurity oversight due to the critical cybersecurity functions that DHS provides in securing the federal government’s civilian networks and in coordinating information sharing between government entities and the private sector. The lack of a coordinating function among these committees limits Congress’ ability to obtain a comprehensive picture of the cybersecurity problem, particularly when these committees advance legislation solely from their own jurisdictions.39
To develop a successful cybersecurity approach, Congress must first be able to obtain a comprehensive picture of the problem. This is challenging, and not just because of the lack of committee coordination. The complex nature of the problem itself, previously illustrated, requires gathering information about the interaction of a large set of actors, economic sectors, and government departments. How would increased organized criminal investigative activities impact the incentives of potential nation-state actors? How would the responses by those foreign actors alter the availability of malicious tools and code to third parties targeting private organizations and individuals? How might proposals to legalize “hacking back” affect adversaries’ incentives to engage in false-flag operations? These are complicated questions spanning many different areas yet attempts to address any one area impact nearly all others. This is no easy challenge for Congress, made worse by the fact that it is happening in real time, and pressure to act is growing on executive agencies Congress must oversee.
Since January 2019, in the 116th Congress, there have been at least 13 hearings involving cybersecurity topics. These 13 hearings have been conducted by seven different congressional committees, including three committees in the House of Representatives and four committees in the Senate. From January 2017 to December 2018, in the 115th Congress, there were at least 56 hearings involving cybersecurity topics. These 56 hearings were conducted by 17 different congressional committees, including eight committees in the House of Representatives and seven committees in the Senate. (See Appendix A for a list of these hearings.) Meanwhile, specific members of Congress have launched the Cyberspace Solarium Commission, mandated by the 2019 National Defense Authorization Act and comprised of members from both chambers of Congress, as well as outside experts. The commission is charged with “evaluating divergent approaches to defending the United States in cyberspace and driving consensus toward a comprehensive strategy.”40 The commission’s recommendations for developing this strategy are scheduled to be delivered in a 2020 report.
The lack of committee coordination is only one aspect of the problem, however. There are many different aspects to the cybersecurity problem, most of which are interrelated and equally vulnerable to adversaries who seek to compromise U.S. systems. In other words, attackers don’t care how they get in—only that they do. Their mechanisms do not neatly (or even weakly) follow committee jurisdiction. While the disjointed committee patchwork could be interpreted as an argument for intelligence oversight–style reform of congressional committee structure, this is as deceptively incomplete an answer as is the myth of information sharing or effective increased deterrence through criminal penalty. Because it is precisely the patchwork nature of the problem—which spans questions in national defense, law enforcement, agriculture, energy, transportation, finance, healthcare, manufacturing, consumer protection, and a host of other areas—that makes uncoordinated oversight and legislation challenging at best. At worst, it runs the risk of benefiting adversaries by promoting a false sense of security when problems are addressed in one area at the expense of ignoring another.
Cybersecurity Oversight fails
Cordero and Thaw 20 [Carrie Cordero is the Robert M. Gates Senior Fellow and General Counsel at CNAS. Her research and writing interests focus on homeland security and intelligence community oversight, transparency, surveillance, cybersecurity, and related national and homeland security law and policy issues. David Thaw is a professor at the University of Pittsburgh and holds appointments in the School of Law and the School of Computing and Information. He is also an Affiliated Fellow of the Information Society Project at Yale Law School. https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/resrep27475.pdf?acceptTC=true&coverpage=false&addFooter=false]//LP
Cybersecurity oversight is due for a reboot. This paper explores the need for refreshed congressional oversight of cybersecurity. After laying out why cybersecurity oversight presents special challenges, this paper suggests that the disparate nature of the cybersecurity policymaking legal framework is mismatched to the nature of the cybersecurity problem, resulting in difficulty legislating in this space. It then provides two key recommendations to guide a congressional cybersecurity oversight reboot. Cybersecurity is a broad challenge spanning many disciplines and industries. This paper argues that the current “patchwork” legal framework is ill suited to address cybersecurity questions either for legislative oversight or effective policymaking. The paper provides an overview of the nature and scope of the cybersecurity problem, with a focus on how the complexity of the field affects congressional oversight activities. Congress has been conducting a substantial amount of oversight in this area in recent years. Those efforts, however, have not yet resulted in legislative actions that have demonstrably improved national cybersecurity. This paper seeks to aid the effort to craft legal authorities that deal with an increasingly complex set of cyberthreats. This short exposition provides a path to rebooting Congress’ approach to cybersecurity oversight in a way that would allow these issues to be addressed more comprehensively. Cybersecurity is a complex, integrated challenge spanning topics as diverse as (but not limited to) international affairs, national security and defense, criminal law, civil liability, data protection, privacy and personal responsibility. Cybersecurity also involves many different actors, ranging from governments to companies to organizations to individuals. And it involves virtually every type of computing and information technology in use today, representing a plethora of technologies far more diverse than the personal computers and servers of yesteryear. Thus, perhaps the greatest challenge of developing a comprehensive cybersecurity governance framework is the fact that it is a highly complex problem, pervasive and interrelated across many aspects of government, the private sector, and society. From a federal government perspective, cybersecurity presents a set of interrelated challenges. Cybersecurity responses to malign cyber activities of hostile nation-states cannot be resolved the same way traditional kinetic defense threats would be handled. For example, cybersecurity cannot just be handed off to one agency, such as the Department of Defense (DoD) or the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). Although those departments play important roles, neither can—as a result of limits on legal authorities and their appropriate roles and responsibilities— address the problem comprehensively. The current “patchwork” legal framework is ill suited to address cybersecurity questions either for legislative oversight or effective policymaking. Most commonly, the term cybersecurity refers to some type of defensive technical security problem. Its meaning varies both descriptively and normatively across industrial sectors, types of actors, and disciplinary backgrounds. In reality, however, cybersecurity problems generally describe only one piece of a complex puzzle. The lack of a framework for defining these issues diminishes the ability of policymakers to create policy that adequately addresses the full spectrum of cybersecurity problems. This spectrum is broad and is not limited to traditional defensive boundaries. It includes strategic and adversarial planning and operations, spanning parties from private sector targets to law enforcement to military operations. In a fully internetworked world of connected appliances, vehicles, Internet of Things devices, and mobile devices, holistic consideration of cybersecurity questions is necessary. This discussion takes an expansive view of the elements that impact “cybersecurity”— ranging from technical aspects of system security to principles of international law in the context of armed conflict. This wide view is unified by the theme of efforts to improve the health of the U.S. information and computing infrastructure as an empirical matter, agnostic of any particular normative policy prescription of consumer protection, economic policy, or related issues. The technological aspects of cybersecurity further complicate this problem in two ways. First, they create a degree of opacity for nontechnologists in understanding key elements of the problem. Second, the highly technical nature of cybersecurity lends itself to the false belief that technical measures can provide complete solutions. Nothing could be further from the truth. Indeed, solutions focusing on technological “silver bullets” often are beneficial to adversaries because of the false sense of security they provide. Many of the most effective methods of “hacking” often rely on human vectors. Just as a technological perimeter is an infeasible system in an interconnected world, a cyber border defended by the Armed Forces is impractical.