Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Turkey says no, they won’t risk their friendship with Russia OR they’ll demand something too risky in return

Simon A. Waldman, 6-30-2022, "Two-faced Turkey demands a terrible price for NATO expansion," Haaretz, https://www.haaretz.com/middle-east-news/turkey/2022-06-30/ty-article-opinion/.premium/two-faced-turkey-demands-a-terrible-price-for-nato-expansion/00000181-b40c-d445-afbd-bc1cf9960000, accessed 7-20-2022//cpd

Ankara figures that the Turkish she-wolf has no chance against the Russian bear in a head-to-head wrestling match. Instead, Ankara seeks both active engagement with Moscow on a bilateral level, but belligerency through proxies in their overlapping near abroad.

This is how that delicate, if not fragile, balancing act works. Turkey buys Russian S400 surface-to-air missiles and sends ministers to Moscow for strategic discussions, while seeking to advance trade relations. In 2019, before the COVID crisis hit, the volume of that trade stood at $23 billion and the two sides reiterated their goal of making this number reach $100 billion. Energy cooperation is strong with Gazprom having just signed a four-year gas deal with Turkey’s state energy company Botas in January this year, the latest advancement of the Turkstream project, the Russia to Turkey natural gas pipeline. Turkey is predicted to receive 1.5 million Russian tourists this year, including Putin’s oligarchs who can enjoy Turkey’s luxurious resorts without fear of sanction.

However, Turkey supported the Government of National Accord during the Second Libyan Civil war, despite Moscow having thrown its lot with its sworn enemy, General Haftar. Just before the 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, Turkey armed Azerbaijan to the teeth while Russia backed Armenia. In Syria, Russia continues to back the country’s president Bashar Assad while Turkey supports an umbrella collective of opposition groups.

Ankara’s jaundiced policy towards Russia continues during the Ukraine crisis. Turkey supplies the famed Bayraktar drones to Ukraine and limited Russia’s military use of the Bosphorus straits which connect the Black Sea with the Sea of Marmara and then onto the Mediterranean, in accordance with the 1936 Montreux Convention. However, Turkey also placates Moscow by refusing to close its airspace to Russia (unless flights are headed to Syria) or to impose sanctions, and instead has sought (with little success) to facilitate talks between the two sides.

So, now that Turkey has opened the path for NATO’s Nordic expansion, expect Ankara to make some sort of conciliatory gesture to Moscow in return. That is, unless the West performs a complete U-turn in its relations with Turkey – or, rather, a complete appeasement.

In getting Turkey to agree to drop its opposition to Sweden and Finland joining NATO, the three countries signed a trilateral memorandum, whereby Stockholm and Oslo pledged to drop arms embargoes on Turkey, curtails the activities of the PKK in their soil, examine Turkish extradition requests against suspected members of the PKK and the Gulen movement, and promise not to provide support to YPG/PYD in Syria.

In agreeing to these terms, it was not Turkey which made a U-turn but rather Sweden and Finland. This new trilateral memorandum is uncannily similar to the conditions Ankara set out for NATO expansion back in May. No wonder the slavish Turkish press has hailed this week’s deal as a sweeping victory.

Mr Erdogan will now expect Sweden and Finland to adhere to the spirit, and not just the (notably vague) letter, of the agreement. This means he will demand they back a future Turkish operation in Syria to combat the YPG, who happen to be the West’s main allies against Islamic State, support Ankara’s plans to expel and forcibly resettle over one million Syrian refugees in northern Syria, take concrete steps to extradite alleged members of the PKK and Gulen movement to face trial, unlikely to be fair, in Turkey, and keep schtum about Turkey’s poor human rights records and abuses of fundamental democratic freedoms.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.