TCBMs fail---circumvention and abuse
Ram S. Jakhu 12. LLM in International Law, LLM in Air & Space Law, DCL in Law of Outer Space & Telecommunications, Law Professor at McGill University, former Chair of the UN Working Group for Satellite Communications, member of the Global Agenda Council on Space of the World Economic Forum. “Transparency and Confidence-Building Measures for Space Security,” Decoding the International Code of Conduct for Outer Space Activities, Pentagon Security International, 2012, pp. 35- 46, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2801702
Moreover, TCBMs are merely a means for achieving space security but their effectiveness highly depends upon their precise contents, pertinent scope, uniform and effective implementation, objective compliance monitoring and verification, and the presence of efficient dispute settlement mechanisms. Compliance with non-binding undertakings under TCBMs cannot be fully expected or guaranteed. It is well-known that neither the information sharing regime under the non-binding 2002 Hague Code of Conduct for Ballistic Missiles nor the registration of space objects under the binding 1969 Registration Convention are fully respected by the subscribing States. We should also be aware that there is always a possibility of an abuse of TCBMs, as for example there have been instances when ‘violations’ of the Missile Technology Control Regime—a form of TCBM—had been alleged against some States that were not subscribers to the Regime. Irrespective of the good intentions and the abundance of possible means for preventing an arms race in outer space, the lack of political will, primarily on the part of major space-faring nations, has so far constrained any serious progress in achieving space security. Only time will tell if the recent initiatives being undertaken by the international community on TCBMs in outer space will bear any fruit.