DPT is wrong – longitudinal analysis disproves peaceful dyad thesis
Owsiak and Vasquez 22 — Andrew P Owsiak, John A Vasquez, The Limited Scope of the Democratic Peace: What We Are Missing, International Studies Perspectives, Volume 23, Issue 2, May 2022, Pages 169–190, https://doi.org/10.1093/isp/ekab015 WMK
Cumulatively, our analysis offers three main, interrelated findings. First, the democratic peace potentially accounts for only a minority of peaceful dyads in the interstate system. The exact amount of its explanatory power varies, depending on myriad research design choices; yet that amount most often falls below 10 percent of peaceful dyads. The democratic peace does not, then, account for the majority of peaceful dyads in the interstate system over the past 200 years. It has a limited scope. Second, the democratic peace performs better in more recent, shorter periods, as opposed to longer historical ones. Finally, most peaceful dyads, regardless of time period, require a theory other than the democratic peace to explain why they have never had a war or a MID. We now turn our attention to where scholars might most fruitfully search for the factors capable of accounting for these overlooked, peaceful dyads.