Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Even if democratic institutions could generate pro-climate policy making – rampant corruption precludes compliance

Povitkina 18’(Marina Povitkina, Postdoctoral researcher at the Department of Political Science at the University of Oslo and Center for Collective Action Research at the University of Gothenburg, The Limits of Democracy in tackling climate change, March 2018, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/323530041_The_limits_of_democracy_in_tackling_climate_change, ME)

National-level carbon dioxide emissions depend on a multitude of factors, including countries’ economies, geography, demographics, and, not least, politics. The aim of this study has been to focus specifically on the political 424 M. POVITKINA determinants of CO2 emissions and revisit the findings reported in previous literature indicating that the amount of countries’ CO2 emissions is associated with their level of democracy. Here, I instead argue that while democratic institutions shape preference aggregation within a polity and favor environmental commitments, the benefits of democracy for climate change mitigation are limited in the presence of corrupt institutions, which obstruct coercive capacity, extractive capacity of the state, actors’ compliance, and pro-climate policy-making. To test this claim, I investigate whether the association between democracy and CO2 emissions is conditional on the levels of corruption. In pursuing this aim, I analyze the emitting behavior of countries across the globe over time and estimate a within-between regression, which takes into account the variation between countries and simultaneously accounts for the developments in countries over time. Such investigation brings a number of insights into the political factors behind the differences in CO2 emissions between countries and the political drivers of emission reduction within states. The results of this study show that after taking into account the common economic, geographical, and demographic explanations of CO2 emissions, political factors still make a difference. In accordance with most previous results, my findings show that more democratic countries do tend to emit less. However, this is only true for those democracies where corruption is low. When corruption is high, democracy does not seem to make a difference for the level of emissions, all else equal. It does not matter for the level of emissions whether a country has free elections, freedom of the press, and freedom of association if the executive, judicial and legislative branches of the state do not function well and are drenched in corruption and clientelism. In such a case, democracies do not seem to do any better than authoritarian regimes, where decision-making power is in the hands of a narrow elite. To exemplify, the results imply that it makes no difference for the national levels of CO2 emissions if a country is a democratic and corrupt Jamaica or an authoritarian and corrupt Azerbaijan. The results also show that a political system with a low level of corruption is not a universal cure. Lower corruption seems to matter only for the levels of CO2 emissions in democratic regimes and the level of corruption does not seem to play a role if a country is authoritarian. For example, being democratic and relatively non-corrupt Austria is more beneficial for lower CO2 emissions than being democratic but moderately corrupt Slovakia. However, at the same time, being an authoritarian regime with relatively low-corrupt institutions, such as Saudi Arabia, does not seem to be associated with lower emissions than being an authoritarian and corrupt regime, such as Yemen. While we can only gain insights about the associational relationship between democracy, corruption, and CO2 emissions from the between country estimates, the analysis of changes over time brings us closer to causal claims. The results from the within-part of the analysis show a similar picture to the between-part: positive changes in democracy are associated with the reduction in emission levels only when countries experience relatively low levels of corruption. When corruption levels in countries are low relative to what these countries experienced on average over the time period under investigation, steps toward democracy go together with steps toward climate change mitigation. When corruption is relatively high, more democracy does not seem to make a difference for emission control.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.