Autocracies are necessary to combat pandemics – decisions are made faster and more effectively
Cepaluni et. al. 20 – (Gabriel Cepaluni, assistant professor at São Paulo State University (UNESP), PhD from the Department of Political Science at the University of São Paulo and was a visiting researcher in the Department of Government at Georgetown University (2008-2009), Michael Dorsch, applied economist whose research and teaching interests are mainly in political economics and public economics, Ph.D., Economics, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign, M.A., Economics, Miami University, B.A., Economics, International Studies, French, Miami University, Réka Branyiczki, BA in International Business, Corvinus University of Budapest, BA in Psychology, Eotvos Lorand University, MA in Economic Policy in Global Markets, CEU, “Political Regimes and Deaths in the Early Stages of the COVID-19 Pandemic,” Comparative Politics, 4-27-2020, https://preprints.apsanet.org/engage/apsa/article-details/5ea7229e5d762d001217da9a)
6 Discussion and conclusions Our analysis demonstrates that in the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic, more democratic countries experienced deaths sooner and on a larger scale. For advocates of democratic governance, these results are unsettling. We have several lines of rationalizing the findings, which we believe open up some crucial debates in political science. There may be systematic under-reporting of COVID-19 deaths in less democratic countries. In some cases, under-reporting could be a political decision. In other cases, it may reflect a lack of state capacity to perform the testing necessary to determine the real cause of death (Economist, 2020).24 We have tried to deal with this through our instrumental variable strategy and by including controls for governmental transparency, testing rates and sub-sample analyses, but it remains a concern. Centralized decision-making may be advantageous when it comes to responding to pandemics (Schwartz, 2012). Table 5 shows that more democratic countries had imposed less stringent restrictions during the first 100 days of the crisis. With fewer checks built into the policy-making process, public health policy responses can be made more quickly and perhaps more incisively in autocratic governments. Especially for policies that impinge on civil liberties and privacy, autocratic governments have a far freer hand in imposing restrictions on their citizens. The trade-off between the capacity to protect the public health and personal liberties is a central debate during, and probably well after, the COVID-19 crisis (Harari, 2020). Autocratic governments may have had an extra advantage to the extent that their citizens are more obedient to governmental decrees, especially those that may disrupt the social and business lives of citizens. Figure 3 demonstrates that more stringent policies decreased deaths in less democratic countries, but not necessarily in fully democratic ones. Whether it comes from higher public support for government initiatives (possibly, through the threat of force) or from the government’s ability to stifle debate around their decrees in the media, the greater obedience of citizens in autocracies may have had a role in the lower scale of deaths. Protests against social distancing restrictions in democracies with different institutional performances, such as Brazil and the United States, seem to reinforce this point. Finally, this paper contributes to a substantive topic that will have broad and lasting implications. It may well be many years until we have a clear understanding how the COVID-19 crisis will impact our societies. As the pandemic started in East Asia, the location of some of the best-managed autocracies, it may be that our sample disproportionately includes the autocratic governments with high state capacity. Therefore, it is an area for future research to see if our results hold when autocracies with lower state capacity are eventually included in the sample.