Authoritarian measures are essential to combat the spread of disease
Trofimov 20 – (Yaroslav Trofimov, Chief Foreign-Affairs Consultant at the Wall Street Journal, “Democracy, Dictatorship, Disease: The West Takes Its Turn With Coronavirus,” 3-8-2020, Wall Street Journal, https://www.wsj.com/articles/democracy-dictatorship-disease-the-west-takes-its-turn-with-coronavirus-11583701472)
Western democracies confronting the spread of the novel coronavirus are facing a test with profound implications for their future: Will they fail where authoritarian China, which is touting itself as an alternative model for the world, is succeeding? Covid-19, the respiratory illness caused by the virus, has already become the most consequential public-health crisis in generations, forcing lockdowns of entire regions, disrupting international travel and damaging the global economy —all of this just weeks since the disease has begun to spread outside China. In December and early January, when the epidemic first erupted in China's metropolis of Wuhan and the surrounding Hubei province, official secrecy and the punishment of whistleblowers contributed to the virus's proliferation. Since then, however, China has adopted draconian measures to control social interactions—a lockdown that seems to have halted the epidemic there, at least for now. China's National Health Commission Sunday reported only 44 new Covid-19 cases, far fewer than the daily toll in the new hot spots of Italy, South Korea, France —and now the United States. The Communist Party of China, or CPC, is already advertising this achievement as proof of the superiority of its model that prioritizes government control over individual freedoms. "The advantages of the Chinese system have once again been demonstrated," went one of many such commentaries in recent days, by academic Dong Yuzhen in People's Daily, the CPC's official mouthpiece. "China's battle against the epidemic showed that the CPC, as China's ruling party, is by far the political party with the strongest governance capability in human history." Europe's experience in tackling Covid-19 offers little encouragement so far, with politicians acting too little and too late, and largely failing to stem the tide. In the U.S., too, nearly 500 cases have already been diagnosed, according to data compiled by Johns Hopkins University as of Sunday afternoon, even as testing capacity lags far behind Europe or South Korea. Many epidemiologists and experts warn that drastic measures of the kind deployed by China and imposed in large parts of northern Italy on Sunday morning—measures that are so far opposed by President Trump—are now overdue. "There is a large perception gap between confirmed cases and unknown infections of Covid-19. This requires school closures, large event cancellations, and other aggressive steps," Mr. Trump's former homeland-security adviser Tom Bossert tweeted Saturday, pointing to Italy's crisis as an example of how hesitation caused by fears of hurting the economy ends up exacting an even higher economic loss, without preventing the disease spread. Back when the epidemic was mostly limited to China, many Western politicians focused on the initial failings in Wuhan, asserting that the free flow of information in democracies would give them a natural advantage during a massive public-health crisis. What is becoming evident now, however, is that such knowledge doesn't necessarily translate into meaningful action. "For a month, we thought that Chinese political values were the cause of the problem, and that our values would protect us from the virus," said Bruno Maçães, Portugal's former minister of European affairs and a scholar of China's global rise. "It was an ideological approach. You need to use technology and political power, not just trust that things will be all right because we have the right values." Italy, the first European nation where the coronavirus spread rapidly, reaching 7,375 cases and 366 deaths by Sunday, acted faster than others, barring direct flights from China in early February and rolling out tens of thousands of tests. On Feb. 21, it was the first to quarantine several towns where the virus had taken root. Yet, Italy's leaders, too, have exhibited a spectacular failure to grasp the scope of the crisis. On Feb. 27, Nicola Zingaretti, leader of one of the two main parties in Italy's government coalition and head of the Lazio region, which includes Rome, posted on Instagram a photo of himself clinking glasses with other people in a Milan pub. "Let's not lose our habits, we can't shut down Milan and Italy. Our economy is stronger than fear: Let's go out for an aperitif, a coffee or a pizza," he urged. On Saturday, Mr. Zingaretti said he had become infected with Covid-19. The next day, Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte signed an unprecedented decree that placed Milan, Venice, Parma and several other northern Italian provinces on lockdown, and banned public gatherings, concerts, sports matches and nightclubs in the entire country. Though the new rules are strict, it isn't clear to what extent Italians will comply given lax enforcement: The penalty for disobeying Mr. Conte's decree is a fine of 206 euros ($234) or imprisonment of up to three months, a trifle compared with the punishment exacted by China for breaking the quarantine. The Latest on the Coronavirus * Deaths have been reported in Florida and Washington state, bringing the number of U.S. fatalities to 19; the total number of infections is now 376 * Japan, Singapore and Malaysia all reported their highest single-day increases in cases * South Korea added 483 cases for a total of 6,797 and Italy added 620 new cases and 49 fatalities in the 24 hours preceding its report Friday evening "We have a very strong sense of individual freedom, but all European citizens—and not just Italians—should understand that we are facing a great danger, and that it can be overcome only with responsible behavior by every single citizen," said Roberto Burioni, professor of microbiology and virology at the San Raffaele hospital in Milan. "I have found an extremely grave undervaluation of the risk. Until yesterday, people continued to crowd the ski resorts, the sports events. The individual citizens unfortunately have not realized how important their personal behavior is in order to stop the virus." As Italy shut down, in nearby France—which has reached 1,126 diagnosed Covid-19 cases, the same level as Italy just nine days earlier—several tens of thousands flocked to the streets on Sunday to celebrate the International Women's Day. In Germany, where cases have topped 1,000, authorities Saturday allowed a major soccer match to take place near the center of the country's main outbreak in the state of North Rhine-Westphalia. And in the U.S., public life goes on almost as normal, with few restrictions on schools, sports events, concerts or other public gatherings. Mr. Trump and his two main Democratic challengers—all men over 70, the demographic with the highest mortality from Covid-19—continue to hold mass campaign rallies across the country. "China's top-down approach seems to have done a pretty good job in terms of mobilizing the resources and capabilities needed to reign in the virus. You see the contrast with how Western countries, including the U.S., have failed to take decisive action," said Yanzhong Huang, senior fellow for global health at the Council on Foreign Relations in New York. "Many of the Chinese experience measures probably won't be replicable in this country, or actually any democracy. But our policy makers will face some tough decisions."