Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Democratic strength drives aggressive drone development AND deployment.

Sauer and Schörnig, 12 - *Dr. Frank Sauer, Senior Researcher, Bundeswehr University Munich **Dr. Niklas Schörnig, Deputy Chairman of the Research Council Project Director Senior Researcher @ the Peace Research Institute Frankfurt; “Killer drones: The ‘silver bullet’ of democratic warfare?” Security Dialogue; 43(4); p. 363–380;

Today, it is commonly believed that 40 or more countries are developing military unmanned systems (Singer, 2009: 241). Much of the data behind such a claim is hearsay and quite tough to verify. However, the most recent edition of Military Balance, published annually by the International Institute for Strategic Studies, can serve as a guidepost and a first handle on numbers. Here, 34 countries are listed as holding either medium- or heavy-sized UAVs (IISS, 2011: 24–6). The list of UAV holders reveals a peculiarity: two-thirds of these countries are democratic states. While the ‘drone hype’ is commonly said to be driven mainly by the United States and Israel, it seems that democracies in general have been the first to jump on the unmanned bandwagon. Democracy indices – such as Polity IV, on which we draw here – need to be taken with an appropriate grain of salt, yet they can be helpful in systemizing and corroborating this first impression. With Polity IV ranging from 10 (strongly democratic) to –10 (strongly autocratic), 24 of those 34 countries listed in Military Balance turn out to have a polity score of 6 or higher – in other words, they can safely be called democratic. So, why are democracies in the driving seat of this development? Some might point to a fairly obvious answer: because they can be. The financial and technological resources required for pursuing drone warfare are most readily available to wealthy states, the majority of which are democracies. Adhering to the ‘technological imperative’ (for a concise summary, see Reppy, 1990: 102–3), so this theoretical argument goes, they employ these superior resources to build the best technology and arm their militaries with it, simply because it is possible for them to do so. Yet, no country’s defense budget, not even that of the USA, is limitless. Consequently, political decisions about how to allocate resources have to be made, all while maintaining the technological edge. So, for instance, why did the US Army abandon its ‘Comanche’ advanced helicopter project in 2004, thereby swapping a fast and stealthy hi-tech helicopter for what were then technologically inferior, slow, and non-stealthy drones (Fulghum and Wall, 2004)? The simplistic argument according to which technology is the sole driver, while commonplace and not entirely implausible, obviously carries only so far. We are not the first scholars to raise the question of why democracies are so intrigued by unmanned weapon systems and particularly drones at the moment, but a review of the burgeoning literature on military use of unmanned systems shows that the issue has hitherto only been dealt with cursorily and in passing. There is currently no general, systematic, and theory-driven study seeking to probe the peculiar nexus of democracy and the use of unmanned systems.3

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.