Democracy promotion causes terrorism---prefer a holistic analysic of US counter terror policy
Morris et al. 20 — Morris, N. A., LaFree, G., & Karlidag, E. (2020). Counter‐terrorism policies in the Middle East: Why democracy has failed to reduce terrorism in the Middle East and why protecting human rights might be more successful. Criminology & Public Policy, 20(1), 153–175. https://doi.org/10.1111/1745-9133.12532 WMK
Much of US foreign policy aimed at reducing terrorism in the Middle East following the 9/11 attacks emphasized increasing the strength of democratic institutions in the region. In particular, this was a cornerstone of President George W. Bush's policy in the Middle East. By contrast, while state-based human rights violations sometimes provoke a negative response from US officials, they are rarely seen as an important avenue for achieving regional stability and decreasing terrorism. In several speeches President Barack Obama pointed out the importance of state-based human rights violations, but did not provide a systematic policy advancing the reduction of human rights violations as a counter terrorism measure in the Middle East. President Donald Trump has shown little interest in the records of Middle Eastern countries in terms of either democracy or state-based human rights violations (Washington Post, 2020). Indeed, the Trump administration has generally seen enforcing sanctions against Middle Eastern countries for human rights violations as a barrier to trade and therefor inadvisable (New York Times, 2017).
Although a growing number of worldwide studies examine the relationship between democracy, human rights violations and terrorist attacks, few studies focus exclusively on the countries of the Middle East. Based on prior research we hypothesized that because the Middle East is characterized by exceptionally weak democracies, within-country increases in the strength of democracy in the Middle East will lead to increases in terrorist attacks (Hypothesis 1). We also hypothesized that because Middle Eastern countries are concentrated in the lower half of strength of democracy measures, we will not find a curvilinear effect of democracy on country-level terrorist attacks for this region (Hypothesis 2). Furthermore, we hypothesized that state-based human rights violations in the Middle East may well be more important than strength of democracy and hypothesized that human rights violations will be associated with increases in terrorist attacks in that region (Hypothesis 3). Our results show consistent support for all three hypotheses.
We found that from 1980 to 2016, increases in the strength of democracy are associated with significant increases in terrorist attacks among Middle Eastern countries. Also, as hypothesized, but in contrast to some recent worldwide studies of terrorism (e.g., Gaibulloev et al., 2017; Sandler, 2014), we find no significant support for a curvilinear relationship between democracy strength and terrorist attacks among Middle Eastern countries. We argue that this outcome is a likely consequence of the fact that most previous studies of terrorist attacks have examined worldwide samples with large numbers of mature democracies. By contrast, our descriptive data on 18 Middle Eastern countries shows that most are autocratic or anocratic.