Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

2AC --- War Turns alt

War turns—distinctly bad for people with disabilities

Maria Berghs and Nawaf Kabbara 16 (November 8, 2016, “Chapter 17 Disabled People in Conflicts and Wars” , Disability in the Global South by Disability in the Global South The Critical Handbook, Editors: Shaun Grech, Karen Soldatic , https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-319-42488-0 )// RB

The long-term consequences of protracted confl ict on disabled people and the creation of impairment need more research. This calls for a longitudinal or life-course approach (Priestley 2007 ) to see how identities, single and multiple impairment(s), health and social care needs differ as the age of populations and their environments change. A life-course approach can also explore how the concept of disability is changing intergenerationally, whether passed on biologically (e.g. HIV/AIDS) and socially (e.g. stigma), or through ascription of a new kinship identity (e.g. amputee) (Berghs 2012 ). Yet, research, funding and planning to understand the long-term effects of confl ict on disability is rarely available (Wehbi 2011a ). Inhorn and Kobeissi ( 2006 ) usefully note how there are six long-term effects of confl ict on civilians: physical, mental, reproductive/demographic, social structural, infrastructural, and environmental. We briefl y discuss each of these in turn in an effort to illustrate what is missing from current debates in relation to disability.

Physical We know very little about civilian deaths and creation of impairment despite the fact that poorly resourced health systems contribute to death, illness and impairment (Banatvala and Zwi 2000 ; WHO 2011 ). With the focus on public health, the effects of malnutrition, communicable and non-communicable diseases, unsanitary conditions and lack of access to water are given substantial attention post-confl ict. For example, Miles and Medi ( 1994 ) found that while confl ict in Mozambique had resulted in impairment among children, most actually gained indirect impairments due to a mix of effects created by the long-term consequences of the confl ict, such as malnutrition. Insurance provision, necessary implementation of user fees for services and a lack of (paid) professionals, medication, assistive devices, prosthetics and rehabilitation programmes affect impairment, too. Growing privatisation under neo-liberalism is also a threat to access to health and social care services (Berghs 2013 ). Likewise, the impact of landmines, chemicals and circulation of (small) arms can last for generations and will need long-term planning of services. Long-term effects of confl ict and links to impairment need to be identifi ed so that services can be planned and implemented adequately .

Mental In post-confl ict situations, there are increases in mental health needs such as for counselling, social care and specialised psychiatric services. Inhorn and Kobeissi ( 2006 ) cite lack of infrastructural development and trained professionals, as well as not prioritising mental health as detrimental to well-being. The evidence base for many interventions affecting disabled people does not exist, especially in the fi eld of gender-based violence and mental health (Blanchet et al. 2013 ). Likewise, while there is a lot of data on western veterans, there is very little information on culturally sensitive, indigenous or communal interventions for disabled people. Institutionalisation, stigma, western diagnoses (following the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders 5) and links to pharmaceutical companies also infl uence how mental health care is accessed and why. Thus, coping strategies involving cheap and freely available pharmaceuticals, alcohol and/or drugs develop in society (Inhorn and Kobeissi 2006 ). More research is needed to explore the longterm mental health impact of conflict.

Reproductive/Demographic Lives are disrupted during a confl ict, as families, gender relations and patterns of reproduction undergo profound changes. Marriage is a means of societal integration for disabled people but when most men are fi ghting or community ties are disrupted, there may be earlier, delayed or no marriages taking place. Periods of confl ict also have reproductive consequences for disabled women and men with lack of access to reproductive services, antenatal, postnatal and emergency care. There may also be an increase in perceived need for certain services or technologies to prevent impairment, such as antenatal screening in Vietnam (Gammeltoft 2013 ). Correlations exist between lack of access to reproductive services (e.g. screening and contraception) and war-time sexual violence, increases in Sexually transmitted infections (STIs) , infertility, infant deaths and children born with impairments. Disabled people often face discrimination in services and institutions ensuring neglect, segregation, sterilisation or institutionalisation. For example, Human Rights Watch ( 2010 ) documented high rates of physical and sexual abuse of disabled women post-confl ict, but a lack of access to reproductive services, health education and STI testing continues. Lack of access to reproductive services pre- and post-confl ict is important to understand demographically.

Social Structural The social structure of society changes during a confl ict and the informal CBR systems that families and communities are supplied with may collapse. Programmes implemented by NGOs that superfi cially mainstream disability may also increase poverty and marginalisation of disabled people (see Wehbi 2011a ). There could be rising violence on account of (small) arms and the circulation of drugs, often with links to criminal networks and gangs, which leads to rises in specifi c types of impairment (e.g. spinal cord injuries caused by bullet wounds) (Buchanan 2011 ; Handicap International [HI] 2012 ). Confl ict and post-confl ict societal upheaval may last for decades with the threat of bombs, drones and violence profoundly affecting communities. Hill and Hansen ( 2011 ) describe how in Northern Ireland, a state of terror with bombs going off meant that those with mobility problems were forced to stay at home, leading to greater social isolation. Social isolation has also been identifi ed as a risk factor when it comes to exploitation of disabled people (Grove et al. 2010 ). The consequences of societal breakdown, lack of evaluation of disability programming during a confl ict and post-confl ict, and the programmes that empower disabled people to survive must be urgently addressed.

Infrastructural Confl ict destroys most of the limited infrastructure that exists for disabled people. Vocational workshops, institutions such as day centres, and schools need to be rebuilt. Post-confl ict rebuilding can offer an opportunity for inclusive design and mainstreaming of disability in all infrastructural development. For instance, while education is disrupted, new opportunities present themselves to rebuild educational and vocational systems through inclusive practices (Miles 2013 ). Such interventions will have little impact, however, if issues in the current educational system, notably that teachers lack training and know-how and are often unpaid, are neglected. Likewise, ensuring suitable skills training, micro-credit programmes, and employment in the formal and informal economy are particular concerns post-confl ict, but there will be gross diffi - culties in improving disabled people’s situation if societal attitudes remain negative, barriers persist in transportation systems, or there is no economy to contribute to. Therefore, we need to understand more about what enables the entire social and physical infrastructure to become inclusive and robust post-confl ict.

Environmental The exploitation of resources and environmental impact of confl icts will be felt for generations. Yet, the impact of new forms of impairment on indigenous communities and women is rarely investigated (Ngo et al. 2012 ). Likewise, disability rights and intergenerational rights in terms of creation of differing forms of impairment are rarely advocated (Soldatic 2013 ). North–South hierarchies in bodies and body parts are thus still correlated with inequalities, especially in countries with histories of violence or confl ict that are undergoing political transitions (see Scheper-Hughes 1996 ). This is exemplifi ed in biopolitical claims for genetic reproductive harm, such as the use of Agent Orange in Vietnam, nuclear testing in the southern hemisphere and the use of depleted uranium in Iraq, which are rarely upheld. Refl ections on newer forms of biosociality, or social identities based on biological, genetic or medical conditions (such as HIV/AIDs), chemical and environmental harm, and the links between confl ict, violence and activism remain unexplored.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.