Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

In this sense, NATO has become America’s new colonial toy through which we can assert an unparalleled level of power over primitive civilizations. Uncontested in its power, the US is able to lead NATO through a new era of imperial dominance that is constituted by “global raciality”.

Howell and Richter-Montpetit 19 – Dr. Alison Howell is an associate professor of Political Science at Rutgers University where she also studies Women’s and Gender Studies. Their involvements and research interests include Critical Studies on Security, International Political Sociology, Security Dialogue, and the Review of International Studies where she serves as a board member. Dr. Melanie Richter-Montpetit is a senior lecturer in International Relations and is the director for the Center for Advanced International Theory at the University of Sussex. (Alison Howell, Melanie Richter-Montpetit, “Is securitization theory racist? Civilizationism, methodological whiteness, and antiblack thought in the Copenhagen School”, Sage Journals, Security Dialogue, 7 August 2019, Vol. 51, Issue 1, pgs. 3-22, https://doi.org/10.1177/0967010619862921) || PZ

Antiblack racism in securitization theory writings on Africa ‘Antiblackness’ is a term used to describe the specificity of racism against people of African descent in the post-Columbus world. Chattel slavery turned people from the African continent into commodities to be traded and accumulated, and thereby placed them as ‘the bottom marker’ of ‘a projected universally human scale of being’ (: 308; see also ; ; ). In this imaginary, blackness and black people figured as enslaveable things: the foil against which notions of what it means to be human (and thus a political subject) were invented. Antiblack racism is also complexly entangled with Western gender and sexual formations (; ; ): black women’s bodies and their alleged sexual difference were cast as proof of African primitivism. Significant here are questions of temporality. For Victorians, Africa was ‘a fetish-land, inhabited by cannibals, dervishes and witch doctors, abandoned in prehistory’ (: 41). Tropes of ‘the Dark Continent’ as ‘inhabiting not simply a different geographical space but a different temporal zone’ (: 40) stubbornly persist, including in much international relations theory, which casts Africa ‘as a metaphor for a number of evils: failed states, AIDS, poverty, corruption’ (Grovogui, 2001: 426). Such representations of Africa are not incidental in traditional international relations theory. They are intrinsic to it. This is because ‘Africa’ serves as a foil (: 13) to ‘Europe’ and ‘the West’, the ultimate counterpart to not just Western but human development (Mudimbe, 1988; ). In much international relations scholarship, blackness continues to signify ultimate (moral, sexual, and political) primitivism, an inherent propensity to (sexual and political) violence, and sexual excess and danger. Does securitization theory overcome, replicate, or deepen antiblack thought on ‘Africa’? Certainly, securitization theory sees a tendency towards primal anarchy and the ‘state of nature’ in many non-Western parts of the world (the Balkans; Eastern Europe; Central, South, and East Asia; the Middle East; and South America), but ‘Africa’ is particularly maligned. Often, classic securitization theory treats the entire continent as a single entity, a space where normal politics is weak and oversecuritized, the state or social contract fails (or was never established), and ‘man’ reverts to (or never left) the state of nature. ‘Africa is a pessimist’s paradise, a place where the Hobbesian hypothesis that in the absence of a political Leviathan life for individuals will be nasty, brutish, and short seems to be widely manifest in everyday life’ (: 219). Elsewhere, however, it adds some complexity by seeing Africa in terms of multiple temporalities, being both ‘premodern’, having elements of the ‘modern’, and threatening a ‘back to the future’ scenario. On the one hand, a book like Regions and Powers () offers a sweeping history of Europe over millennia (containing little mention of colonialism), but a history of Africa that covers only official decolonization and the post–Cold War era: a matter of mere decades. Completely missing is any historical account of how colonialism and enslavement shaped not only African but also European security relations (Agathangelou and Ling, 2004b; ; ; ), and the idea of Europe itself (Mudimbe, 1988; ). Conversely, another canonical securitization theory text asserts that ‘in the contemporary international system, some prestate referent objects are still active. The remnants of tribal barbarians still exist in parts of Central Asia and Africa. Some hint of how these tribes worked as referent objects for military security can be gleaned from contemporary civil wars in Afghanistan and Somalia’ (: 53, emphasis added). The past-tense ‘worked’ here implies that we can learn about premodern times (in Europe) by looking at present-day Afghanistan or Somalia, whose backwards ‘tribal barbarian’ populations constitute a prestate referent. These two temporalities come together in the statement that ‘in Africa, the main societal referent objects are a mix of premodern – the extended family, village, clan, and tribe – and modern, the “state-nation”’ (: 126). Securitization theory, then, sees Africa as temporally anomalous – that is, both premodern and modern – because it manifests both a postcolonial present and a potential degeneration to a precolonial/premodern past, as when : 221), drawing from other authors, including Kaplan, speculate that: the period of colonization and decolonization might, in the long view, appear as something of an interlude, a period with its own distinctive characteristics, rather than a point of permanent transformation from premodern to modern. If back-to-the-future pessimism is right, then what we are looking at now is some phase in the terminal collapse of the Westphalian experiment in Africa. This passage outlines a ‘back to the future’ scenario in which Africa returns to its default state of precolonial, tribal, anarchic statelessness. Here, as elsewhere, securitization theory does not entirely ignore histories of colonization: it admits that colonialism had an impact on Africa, but it understands this impact not as an extraction of resources and labor and a violent transformation of people into chattel, but as an ‘experiment’ aimed at bringing the European Westphalian state to ‘premodern’ barbarians (see : 221; : 53, 126). Colonial and ongoing postcolonial and settler-colonial exploitation does not feature in this analysis, and decolonization appears not as a project of liberation but as a potential backslide into primal anarchy (: 345). For securitization theory, histories of colonialism look less like violent ongoing exploitation than a missed opportunity for Africa to become more modern, desecuritized, and European. Why is ‘Africa’ missing this opportunity? Securitization theory’s methodological whiteness leads it to assert, without substantiation, that the cause of this backsliding must not be the ongoing extractive violence of liberal powers but the failure of African people and states to ‘desecuritize’: Because political violence has been such an endemic feature of the African landscape, and because the crisis of the African state is so central to the pervasive insecurity on the continent, we will take the existence of systematic political violence to indicate the presence of a dominant securitization. (: 223) This is strikingly circular reasoning, where premises and conclusions guarantee each other. Securitization theory starts, as we have seen, from the axioms that ‘normal politics’ tames violence and irrational securitizations threaten ‘normal politics’. Seeing Africa as a violent, anarchic space, lacking in ‘normal’ civilized politics, securitization theory assumes this must be because securitization has run amok. As a result, African ‘dominant securitization’ can be taken for granted, as a foil to the supposed peacefulness of Europe, and therefore as evidence that ‘normal politics’ tames violence, and so on. Securitization theory here turns an antiblack narrative of African (a)history (Africa is primitive, violent, anachronistic) into an equally antiblack normative proposition: that Africa is culpable for failing to produce ‘normal politics’. European colonial violence is occluded or, worse, exonerated: many African elites publicly embraced a negative view of globalization, and took the view that their weak position in the global periphery was a major explanation for their difficulties. This led to a convenient rhetoric of ‘neo-colonial’ securitization that sought, often successfully, to divert attention from the indigenous causes of Africa’s difficulties. (: 251) This not only sanitizes the violence of colonialism and enslavement, it goes so far as to cast anti-colonial politics as the problem. With Europe exonerated, Africa is then able to appear as a threat to Europe. We have already seen that securitization theory seeks to protect Western ‘progress’ and normal politics from excessive securitization and a potential fall into primal anarchy. It is similarly concerned to defend normal politics outside the West but sees this as more hopeless: ‘In regions dominated by weak or failed states, real prospects exist that the local level will become dominant, with securitization forming microregions. To the list of microregions we should perhaps add the Hobbesian anarchies in some inner cities of megalopolises’ (: 70). Later, this idea is expanded: As argued by , units other than states have created new lines of division…. The booming megacities in the Third World, with their enormous slum suburbs, produce large populations that identify neither with their clans or tribes nor with states or nations…. Large groups of people who focus on immediate material survival needs become nonidentity factors and might enter the sociopolitical realm as the joker at some later point when they suddenly do acquire or generate an identity. (: 127) Here, those who dwell in slums are figured as people without identities, or political subjectivities, not fully political, and perhaps not fully human. (Even cursory empirical investigation would prove this false: there are robust traditions of political activism in slums across the globe, including across the African continent.) Because they exist in this state of nature (i.e. ‘focus on immediate material survival needs’), these racialized ‘jokers’ are potential threats to Europe, though in a way that is particularly tied to securitization theory’s constructivist methodology: ‘Another effect of Kaplanesque anarchy, especially the disease–crime–population–migration circles in Africa, is the unofficial erection of Atlantic and Mediterranean walls by which North Americans and Europeans define a category of Africa and Africans as the major zone of anarchy, danger, and disease to be shut off from “our world”’ (: 127). This asserts that ‘Africa’ is a space of ‘Kaplanesque anarchy’ and, at the same time, warns against the securitization of ‘Africa and Africans’ in the West. What securitization theory’s analysis of Africa produces, in this formulation, is nothing other than an updated ‘white man’s burden’: it is incumbent on the civilized not to turn away from the plight of the primitive, but the civilized must also take care to avoid being corrupted by their primitive anarchy. We can see here, finally, how little separates this contemporary school of security analysis from the openly antiblack racism of its Victorian predecessors.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.