Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

3. Only our paradigmatic analysis forces self-reflexivity – allows for critical interrogations of ideological hegemony

HOWARD 11 - Natasha Howard - appointed in Geography and Environmental Studies and Africana Studies. She holds a Ph.D. in Educational Thought and Sociocultural Studies and her Masters in Latin American Studies. Dr. Howard’s research centers on unveiling the structures of anti-black racism and the production of anti-black racial discourses in the Americas. 7-2-2011 “Black in the Non-Black Imagination: How Anti-Black Ideology Shapes Non-Black Racial Discourse”, University of New Mexico UNM Digital Repository, https://digitalrepository.unm.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=&httpsredir=1&article=1013&context=educ_llss_etds//vi

Methodology This study takes a critical hermeneutical approach. According to Gallagher (1992) critical or depth hermeneutics is concerned with engaging ideology critique. He notes that, “critique calls for a special and suspicious interpretation of those ideologies and institutions which support and maintain ruling power structures” (Gallagher, 1992, p. 240). He cites four guiding principles related to critical hermeneutics: 1) reproduction, 2) hegemony, 3) critical reflection and 4) application. Drawing from Habermas, Gallagher states that the purpose of critical interpretation is not simply to attempt to reproduce original meaning but rather to interrogate ideological positions presented in texts. A critical or depth hermeneutic methodological approach proposes that reproduction of texts without any critical reflection on ideological representation only serves to maintain unequal power relations. This stands in sharp contrast to traditional methodologies that follow strict non-critical, non-reflective approaches concerned with reproducing the supposedly pure words of the texts (or in the case of empirical research, the voice/s of the subject/s of study). Related to the second principle, hegemony, a depth hermeneutical approach would take the perspective that ideology is embedded within linguistic symbols. Once again, drawing from Habermas, Gallagher notes that problematic ideology distorts and serves the purpose of maintaining oppressive social relations. Critical hermeneutics is concerned with undistorting distorted communication, which takes place through engaging in ideological critique. In other words, depth hermeneutics questions the meaning behind linguistic symbols and to what extent does the meaning collude in the reproduction of oppression. The third principle, critical reflection places the interpreter in relationship to that being interpreted. Gallagher states that “the purpose of critical reflection is to assist in the achievement of emancipation the objectivity of interpretation is seen either as a tool to be used in the pursuit of emancipation or as a result of emancipation, but not as an end in itself (p.244). The fourth principle of critical hermeneutics is application or the idea that there exists ideal undistorted communication, which we strive to achieve. A critical hermeneutic approach is guided by the pursuit of freedom and transformation. In reflecting on Habermas‟ and the principle of application, Gallagher (1992) writes, For Habermas, application, which is the result of critical interpretation in the sense that it always comes along with the practice of depth hermeneutics, involves an escape from prejudice, a radical modification of the anterior relation with the tradition process. The “deep” meaning discovered by the critically suspicious interpretation is not only enlightening but also emancipation for the interpreter. (p. 246) My methodological framework, depth hermeneutics, is grounded by Derrick Bell‟s theory of racial realism (1992). This theory makes us aware of the real dynamic and effects of a racialized social system for Blacks. Although race may be a social construct, the social outcomes produce concrete forms of inequality. Bell also concludes that racism has such a dynamic in our society that it is unlikely that Blacks will achieve full equality since American society is premised upon a system of white supremacist domination. This ideology penetrates American consciousness to the point that no institution, individual or group has not been touched or affected by it. Racism will always re-invent itself in such a way as to maintain the hierarchy and the subordinate status of Blacks. Thus, with each racial gain achieved by Blacks, there are subsequent setbacks. We can see the evidence of this in the aftermath of the Civil Rights Movement. Of course, the movement led to significant gains for Blacks. However, antidiscriminatory laws have not successfully leveled the playing field. Furthermore, in recent decades we have witnessed some backlash against any goals or principles that might presumably lead to any potential advantage for Blacks. We see how the language of the Civil Rights Movement and subsequent laws are currently being used to deter from the goal of racial equality and now a racial hierarchy. Racial realism tells us that we must acknowledge the historical endurance of anti-Black racism and understand that it has often been disguised. This is particularly true in our contemporary age of colorblind race politics. Therefore, we must be mindful of how anti-Blackness manifests in the postCivil Rights era. A study influenced by racial realism would critique the idea of abstract neutrality or pure deductive reasoning, and instead acknowledge that research is also interpreted through social knowledge. A study grounded in a racial realist approach would work toward exposing and confronting anti-Black ideology in fields of thought that collude in the perpetuation of a racial hierarchy. For example, from a racial realist perspective even those discourses that are presented as “critical” or still yet “anti-racist” discourses may also be complicit in the preservation of anti-Black ideology. This means that even presumably critical discourses on race must be studied from the perspective that they take a particular social position, also understand Blacks from a particular social position and maneuver theoretically based upon that understanding. Racial realism is premised upon ideological critique. My study is rooted in this method of inquiry. In Ideology and Modern Culture, Jon Thompson (1990) highlights the debate in defining the notion of ideology. Ideology has its origins in Marxist theory and the idea of false consciousness. Ideology is seen as negative in that it supports the status quo and delimits the development of counter-hegemonic consciousness among the working class. Ideology illusively hides unequal relations of power between dominant and subordinate groups. Other theoretical perspectives propose that ideology is neutral, moving away from the purely pejorative connotation. Ideologies can be regarded then as „systems of thought‟, „systems of belief‟, or „symbolic systems‟ which pertain to social action or political stance” (Thompson, 1990, p.5). In this light, all political action and thought is ideological. I concur with Thompson‟s (1990) critical conception of ideology in which he finds that, the analysis of ideology is primarily concerned with the ways in which forms intersect with relations of power. It is concerned with the ways in which meaning is mobilized in the social world and serves thereby to bolster up individuals and groups who occupy positions of power. To study ideology is to study the ways in which meaning serves to establish and sustain relations of domination. Ideological phenomena are meaningful symbolic phenomena in so far as they serve, in particular social historical circumstances, to establish and sustain relations of domination. (p.56) Nicolas Burbules (1995) proposes five forms of ideology critique including (1) scientific, (2) immanent, (3) deconstructionist, (4) argument from effects, and (5) counter-ideology. Scientific critiques see ideologies as distorted and irrational. They examine ideologies for the ways in which they distort the truth. Immanent critiques reveal how ideologies often do not “measure up to their own standards” (p.57). The critic reveals the contradictions that belie a particular standpoint or position. Burbules states that the third form, the deconstructivist approach, takes the position that there are no universal truths or metanarratives. The fourth form of ideological critique, argument from effects, takes the stand that we must examine the outcome or consequences of ideological positions and then critique those that uphold domination or perpetuate unequal systems of power. The final form of critique is counter-ideology, which proposes that ideological critic challenge ideologies with other counter-hegemonic ideologies. Burbules (1995) notes that there are both possibilities in and limitations to each form of ideological critique he describes. He proposes that we approach the process from the perspective of critiquing ideology as a way of working on developing critical thought. Additionally, he proposes that the work of the ideological critic is to understand people on their own terms, in their journey towards changing perspectives as they are introduced to new ways of thinking about the world. And while, as an educator, I do tend to concur to some degree with the position, I strongly disagree with his presupposition that we must not refute ideologies but rather attempt to induce people towards transformative thinking. For instance, I see my role as ideological critic as one that is guided by racial realism and the commitment to refute and challenge forms of antiBlackness or what I see as ideologies that uphold the oppression and subjugation of Black people. By intersecting racial realism with ideological critique I propose a study that will critique the presence of anti-Black ideology in post-Civil Rights racial discourses on multiracialism, culture, and those defined as moving beyond the Black/white paradigms (e.g., LatCrit and AsianCrit). I have selected these fields of thought because they represent contemporary discourses on race that purported reject binary racial thinking in an attempt to offer new theoretical insight into U.S. race relations. Each field of thought dedicates substantial scholarship to problematizing the presence of Blackness in U.S. racial thought. Though individual texts were selected and interpreted in relationship to anti-Black ideology, taken as a whole, these texts represent a larger pervasive anti-Black discourse that works to sustain the racial hierarchy. As an ideological critic I am concerned with challenging ideology that sustains unequal power relations. Anti-Black discourse sustains a racial hierarchy that places Blacks at the bottom. My responsibility as an ideological critic is to unpack that ideology colluding in the oppression of Blacks. As Thompson (1990) states, ideological critique proposes a contestation or challenge to systems of domination by unveiling precisely how they manifest, are defended and also become unquestionably part of social reality. I first will begin with a review of literature comprising the following areas: racial hierarchy in the post-Civil Rights era; globalized anti-Blackness; ethnicity and the structure of racism; and the construction of the Black body.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.