Temporal narrative of progress bad
Chandler and Chipato 21 – David Chandler is Professor of International Relations at the University of Westminster. He currently edits the open access journal Anthropocenes: Human, Inhuman, Posthuman and the book series Routledge Studies in Resilience. David Chandler has contributed more than one hundred articles to international peer-reviewed journals (in the spheres of international relations, social theory, security, development, democracy, history, geography, political theory, philosophy, ethics and law) including: New Left Review; Radical Philosophy; Current History; Review of International Studies; International Political Sociology; European Journal of Social Theory; European Political Science; Security Dialogue; Political Studies; Millennium: Journal of International Studies; Human Rights Quarterly; Cambridge Review of International Affairs; International Politics; International Relations; British Journal of Politics & International Relations; Journal of International Relations and Development; Politics; Policy and Politics; Democratization; Finnish Yearbook of International Law; Ethics & Global Politics; Globalizations; Global Society; Global Dialogue; Area: Journal of the Royal Geographical Society; The Monist: An International Journal of General Philosophical Inquiry; Development Dialogue; International Journal of Human Rights; Ethnopolitics; International Peacekeeping; Journal of Conflict, Security and Development; Cooperation and Conflict; Critical Studies on Security; Global Change, Peace & Security; Peacebuilding; International Journal of Peace Studies; WeltTrends: Zeitschrift für internationale Politik; Wissenschaft & Frieden; Cahiers Marxistes; Politique Africain; Alternatives Sud; Studia Diplomatica: The Brussels Journal of International Relations; Papeles de Cuestiones Internacionales; Stratejik Öngörü Dergisi and Filozofski Godišnjak. Dr. Farai Chipato is a CIPS postdoctoral fellow (2020-2022) for the Changing Orders project. Farai has a PhD in Political Science from Queen Mary University of London. His thesis research investigated the relationship between international development donors and local civil society organisations in Zimbabwe, focusing [A call for abolition: The disavowal and displacement of race in critical security studies] neil
Security Dialogue’s call comes out of a wider move to include race in discussions of international relations, amid calls to ‘decolonize’ a discipline that has always been at the heart of colonial power structures (). Yet, in order to understand what is at stake in this move to include race in a discipline that formerly seemed to ignore it, we must consider the relationship between Blackness and the world, the ontological condition that makes anti-Blackness inextricable from security. In short, we must realize that questions of race and racism have always been the ground that critical security studies stands on. The idea that racism can be isolated and extracted from an academic discipline while its effects are therapeutically addressed is challenged by the weight of Afropessimist scholarship, critical Black feminist and anti-colonial thinking. The urge to ‘decolonize’ academia suggests that coloniality is a condition that can be uprooted within the university without addressing the broader anti-Black world that universities are in. Some prominent decolonial scholars have challengingly argued that ‘decolonization is not a metaphor’ (), and others have suggested the need for pluriversal approaches to security that allow for inclusion of a multitude of non-Western ontologies (). However, even pluriversal approaches risk retaining parts of the edifice of modernity without addressing its anti-Black foundations, leaving open the possibility of ‘re-enchanting and pluralising [international relations]’ (Rothe, 2019: 9), assuming that redemption and reparation is possible. The temporality at stake is that which seeks to salvage ‘critique’ through an imaginary telos of progress – learning the lessons and moving onwards, ever opening and exploring new avenues and new approaches – hence the appeal to an ethico-political ‘openness’ that the making of reparative politics is held to enable. This attempt to move ‘beyond’ the problem of ‘the spectres of race and racism’ is laudable but, we argue, misguided. It is precisely critical narratives of ‘progress’ that critical Black studies and Afropessimism seek to problematize (). Rather than considering anti-Blackness as an epiphenomenon of modernity, a glitch in our system that needs to be fixed, it may be understood as constitutive of a modern ontology (). As : 130) states, ‘there is no contemporary discourse that is free or independent of the itinerary of the concept of race’. The existence of Blackness is ontologically crucial in providing the boundaries of humanity, in creating the Outside, the Other, that is necessary to define the inside of modernity, civil society and human subjectivity (). As Saidiya Hartman (2017: 33) argues, ‘the texture of freedom is laden with the vestiges of slavery, and abstract equality is utterly enmeshed in the narrative of black subjection’. Thus, for Afropessimists, it is not merely the contemporary order of humanity that is enmeshed with anti-Blackness, but also the struggles for emancipation by those within that order. This does not mean that there is no oppression among those who are recognized as human, but that their struggles for freedom within this space are of a different order from that of Black people, as the space of these internal conflicts is constituted by anti-Blackness. In order for there to be security for humanity, in order for the liberal subject, civil society and a world of progress to function, Blackness must remain outside, as the counterpoint to the telos of modernity. This throws into question calls for inclusion, for justice and for reparation, as well as the ability for the global system to be accountable for the suffering and death of Black people. If anti-Blackness is a structural necessity for the system to exist, then there can be no justice, no end to violence against Black people if the current system persists. The drive to include Black people in civil society, to promote multiculturalism, diversity and inclusion, leaves untouched the ontological condition of Blackness, which is required to maintain the borders of humanity. The radical force of Black liberation movements was blunted by the drive to assimilate them, to include Black people in the political sphere, to recognize and celebrate their ‘ethnic identity’, without addressing the fundamental condition of Blackness. In the USA, anti-Black violence remains a necessity to maintain security, despite the inclusion of Black people at all levels of government. Inclusivity does not ameliorate the problem; it merely obfuscates it. As : 103) argues, ‘few characters aestheticize White supremacy more effectively and persuasively than a Black male cop’. American governance is not ‘haunted’ by race, it is constituted through race. Thus the line between humanity and Blackness is not shattered through the inclusion of some Black people in the space of civil society; rather, it is reinforced. In South Africa, the Black inhabitants of townships continue to endure state violence and poverty despite the formal end of apartheid. Black activists now protest against their government by ‘black boers’ (settlers), those who have crossed the line into humanity only to fortify it against their former compatriots (Madlingozi, 2017). This is because, as Tsepho Madlingozi (2017: 14) argues, ‘the main edifice of the ontological structure of colonial-apartheid . . . remains in place’. In order to ensure the security of settler society, those few who have been inducted into it must maintain the violence of the anti-Black order that is said to be overturned. Security, then, is sustained through anti-Blackness, for if the abject non-subject of the Black experience does not exist as a point of contrast, then humanity cannot be safe. The subjectivity of the (non-Black) human is imperilled, without the safety of anti-Black violence that ensures its ontological integrity. If this is the case, then we must re-read the call to bring considerations of race and racism into critical security studies and question the feasibility of achieving an ethico-political reparation in a discipline that relies on the structure of an anti-Black system. Disavowal: ‘Spectres’ and ‘foundations’ Having grasped the nature of the relationship between anti-Blackness and security, let us reflect on the assumptions underpinning the desire to rejuvenate the criticality of the field through reparative approaches to race. We see a potential problem with the argument that the recent important work by the scholars like and Rutazibwa (2020) on security’s racial underpinnings has cleared the ground for a project of accounting and reparation while maintaining existing academic fields recognizably intact. Indeed, recent work on race in security and global politics has highlighted many potential issues, demonstrating the substantial challenge facing reparative projects. As demonstrate, considered ontologically, coloniality is much more than a set of space- and time-specific policy practices, but rather a world-making (and worlds-destroying) practice through which our understanding of global space and time is constructed (see also Grovogui, 2014; ; ). Moreover, critical sociological accounts of security and international relations argue that the imposition of racial difference is intimately tied to colonial and settler-colonial power as a technique of control and regulation that naturalizes and reproduces differential powers and capacities (e.g. ; Nisancioglu, 2020). Race and white supremacy are thus inextricable from hegemonic regimes of power and imposition, at the heart of the discipline, despite the abstract categories of liberal political theory that structurally operate to occlude the centrality of race to contemporary political divisions and understandings. As , the location of race is often displaced – to claims to identity and difference, seen to be racial – while white-coded framings of ‘sovereignty’ and ‘class’ obscure their racialized grounding. This important work on the nature of race and racism in security studies shows that the problem is not so much one of a lack of incorporation of questions of race and racism, but rather that of a thoroughgoing saturation in issues of race. This ontological saturation implies that there can be no definitive temporal break between the colonial past and a postcolonial present. Coloniality remains in the present not only in residue, but rather as an ‘ongoing and quotidian atrocity’, inevitably problematizing attempts at reparation (see discussion in : 20). We are thereby fully sympathetic to understanding that ‘questions of race and racism’ cannot be disentangled from critical security studies or, for that matter, the broader field of international relations. As : 22) powerfully notes, any attempt to separate ‘questions of race and racism’ from systems, structures and institutions of power already risks disavowing the centrality of race and its reduction to a secondary or contingent aspect.