Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Disavowal of its racist history “inverts the problem…. Becomes the solution”

Chandler and Chipato 21 – David Chandler is Professor of International Relations at the University of Westminster. He currently edits the open access journal Anthropocenes: Human, Inhuman, Posthuman and the book series Routledge Studies in Resilience. David Chandler has contributed more than one hundred articles to international peer-reviewed journals (in the spheres of international relations, social theory, security, development, democracy, history, geography, political theory, philosophy, ethics and law) including: New Left Review; Radical Philosophy; Current History; Review of International Studies; International Political Sociology; European Journal of Social Theory; European Political Science; Security Dialogue; Political Studies; Millennium: Journal of International Studies; Human Rights Quarterly; Cambridge Review of International Affairs; International Politics; International Relations; British Journal of Politics & International Relations; Journal of International Relations and Development; Politics; Policy and Politics; Democratization; Finnish Yearbook of International Law; Ethics & Global Politics; Globalizations; Global Society; Global Dialogue; Area: Journal of the Royal Geographical Society; The Monist: An International Journal of General Philosophical Inquiry; Development Dialogue; International Journal of Human Rights; Ethnopolitics; International Peacekeeping; Journal of Conflict, Security and Development; Cooperation and Conflict; Critical Studies on Security; Global Change, Peace & Security; Peacebuilding; International Journal of Peace Studies; WeltTrends: Zeitschrift für internationale Politik; Wissenschaft & Frieden; Cahiers Marxistes; Politique Africain; Alternatives Sud; Studia Diplomatica: The Brussels Journal of International Relations; Papeles de Cuestiones Internacionales; Stratejik Öngörü Dergisi and Filozofski Godišnjak. Dr. Farai Chipato is a CIPS postdoctoral fellow (2020-2022) for the Changing Orders project. Farai has a PhD in Political Science from Queen Mary University of London. His thesis research investigated the relationship between international development donors and local civil society organisations in Zimbabwe, focusing [A call for abolition: The disavowal and displacement of race in critical security studies] neil

We have seen above that disavowal operates on the basis of stipulating that the problem of race and racism is one that can be located in the past, intimating that the problem is a difficult one of ‘spectres’ or legacies that must and can be overcome. This is possible because the assumption is that questions of race are somehow separable from the field of critical security studies itself, rather than constitutive of it. The successful accomplishment of disavowal, then, enables a focus upon how critical security studies might move forward. This leap, we argue, is a displacement that then puts questions of the future of critical security studies at the forefront of concern. The displacement accomplishes the inversing of the problematic: critical security studies is now the solution rather than the problem. The precondition for reparative work is the disavowal that race and racism are inextricably entangled with critical security studies. The shift of displacement is the move to reparation, the imaginary of an anti- or non-racist critical security studies.

The problem with this move of displacement is that the ethico-political stance of reparation is necessarily an affirmative one. As : 150–151) suggests, it is through this displacement that we can learn from the ‘ways selves and communities succeed in extracting sustenance from the objects of a culture – even of a culture whose avowed desire has often been not to sustain them’. As Tiffany Lethabo King powerfully argues, while it is the case that reading ‘for what is generative and provides openings’ (: 230n74) is vital for coalition and collaboration, reparative work advocated in LGBT and queer theory presupposes the positionality of a shared humanist sexual subject position. As : 11–12) notes in his essay on race and the work of Levinas, the reparative stance of being ‘open to the world’ or ‘available to the world’ can only work as a critical project for those for whom the world is accessible in these ways. For those structurally excluded from this political ontology of the subject, this openness would be critical only insofar as relationality is understood to be an expression of power, structured by the givenness of a transcendental subjectivity that the black cannot have but by which the black can be had; a structural position that he or she cannot take but by which he or she can be taken. (: 204)

Any project of reparative work for generative ethico-political openings would have to be undertaken after the abolition or dismantling of critical security studies, not as a substitute for this, displacing the problem to that of the repair of the disciplinary field.

Reparative work proffered from within a system where race is not merely the ‘oil’ in the engine but the engine itself offers little hope of real change. How can critical security studies offer a space for a new antiracist political ethics, from within the wider ‘prison of colonial modernity’ ()? Surely, if reparative work is to be undertaken, it should be carried out on the terms of those who are wronged, rather than on the grounds of the perpetrator of the offence. If critical security studies exists on the ground of the ‘human’, as a science of the humanity from which Blackness has always been excluded, then it cannot ameliorate the oppression that was required to clear that ground (). Instead, we might follow : 137) in arguing that humanity, the idea of the ‘human’, can only be overhauled from without, transformed by those who, he argues, ‘live behind the veil of the permanent state of exception’. Thus, we might argue that reparation ultimately leads us back to subjection (see Coulthard, 2007: 453).

‘Questions of race and racism’ are not the spectre haunting critical security studies, they are its life blood, its arteries and the muscles that power it. Critical security studies can have no reparative access to ‘questions of race and racism’ no matter how hard or how genuinely it tries. ‘Questions of race and racism’ are what enable the cuts and binaries, the world, the subjects, the concerns, the practices, the methods, the understandings of critical security studies. Critical. Security. Studies. What is it about these three words, singularly, together, in whatever order, that could make anyone think, in today’s world, there was a way beyond their imbrications in ‘questions of race and racism’? Critical of what? On what grounds? Security of what? On what grounds? Study of what? On what grounds? Answer: the grounds of anti-Blackness or ‘questions of race and racism’.

Being critical necessitates having a standpoint, being a subject in relation. For the white world of modernity, critical standpoints enabled the overturning of the relation, freeing the subject from its oppression, alienation or exploitation. As : 37) notes, these ‘grammars of suffering’ are grounded upon anti-Blackness, grounded upon the construction of the human as an abstract, autonomous, interest-bearing, rational subject. Wilderson argues that the exclusion of Blackness from humanity was required as a counterpart, an outside that allowed for the construction of the modern human subject. Thus, critique, in the sense of striving for emancipation under the conditions of modernity, is ontologically grounded in anti-Blackness. For ‘critique’, then, ‘questions of race and racism’ are problems of management and damage limitation, problems of experience not problems of ontology. Addressing ‘questions of race and racism’ is the form that governance takes, the practice of grounding this governance itself. Critique is what puts anti-Blackness to work in its ceaseless desire to reproduce itself, to improve, to better, to be more adaptive, to be more inclusive – ever changing, ever learning, ever transforming. Therefore, the mere inclusion of questions of race and racism, which maintain the ontological structure of anti-Blackness, must perpetuate an anti-Black world. Critique is the endless search for the emancipation of the human, the quest for the realization of the full potential of an anti-Black world. The flight of critique today can be rewritten as the perpetual denial of and war on Blackness, that which enables and ‘makes invisible’ its grounds of violence.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.