Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

No European prolif now. But Ukraine is the brink.

Keating 6/1 (Joshua Keating – Global Security Reporter for GRID, “Will more countries want nuclear weapons after the war in Ukraine?”, GRID, 1 June 2022, https://www.grid.news/story/global/2022/06/01/will-more-countries-want-nuclear-weapons-after-the-war-in-ukraine/, MG)

On the one hand, if anything demonstrates the dangers of a world with nuclear weapons, it’s the war in Ukraine. And yet, it’s also a demonstration of why countries want to have them. Russia’s nuclear arsenal is one big reason why it has been able to invade a neighboring country (a ) without facing an international military response. It also seems far less likely that Russia would have invaded had Ukraine possessed a nuclear arsenal of its own. Compounding the frustration for Ukrainians is the fact that the country did have nuclear weapons on its territory — around 1,900 Soviet warheads at the end of the Cold War in 1991, making it, on paper, the world’s third-largest nuclear power. In 1994, the newly independent nation of Ukraine agreed to give those weapons to Russia in exchange for internationally negotiated security guarantees that turned out to not be so ironclad. While Ukraine never actually had control of the weapons, which were connected to command-and-control systems in Moscow, it’s a powerful narrative nonetheless. As the country’s former defense minister in February, shortly before the invasion, “We gave away the capability for nothing.” Nicholas Miller, a political scientist at Dartmouth College who studies nuclear proliferation, said the current war and recent history underline the advantages of the nuclear capability. “It’s already well understood that nuclear weapons seem to do a pretty good job at deterring outright invasions,” he told Grid, pointing out that North Korean officials , which abandoned their weapons of mass destruction programs and then found themselves targets of U.S.-led regime change operations. “This just kind of reinforces that.” None of which suggests a looming global rush to obtain the bomb. Davenport said the more likely possibility is more states engaging in nuclear “hedging”: developing the capabilities to quickly build a bomb without crossing the red line of actually doing so. Countries have done this as an insurance policy in case security guarantees provided by their partners turn out not to be flawed, or weak. Japan and Germany are often cited as examples of this “hedging” strategy.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.