Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

NATO allies have limited anxiety now---fear of a revived pivot is lingering

Morgan and Péczeli 21 (Amelia Morgan - research associate at the Center for Science and Security Studies and a doctoral candidate in the Defence Studies Department at King’s College, Anna Péczeli - postdoctoral research fellow at the Center for Global Security Research at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory , “Europe’s Evolving Deterrence Discourse”, Center for Global Security Research, February 2021, https://cgsr.llnl.gov/content/assets/docs/CGSR_euro_det_final.pdf, MG)

Any transatlantic debate on deterrence takes its cues from the U.S. debate. Due to its large international role, its correspondingly large military, and its sizable and vibrant strategic community, the United States has been at the forefront of deterrence thinking since the advent of the nuclear age. Its unique role as the military protector of many countries in and beyond NATO has given U.S. thinking on deterrence and other security matters enormous weight. If in the past mainstream U.S. deterrence thinking often had a streak of alarmism, it largely stemmed from concerns about the credibility of extended deterrence. As this concept seeks to deter an adversary from attacking an ally of the United States, rather than the U.S. homeland itself, it was burdened with a credibility dilemma that it sought to ameliorate by the forwarddeployment of conventional and nuclear forces, as well as through unique nuclear sharing arrangements. In retrospect, it is fair to say that Europeans were generally less concerned with the specifics of the Western deterrence posture, as long as certain basics—above all, a strong and credible U.S. commitment to European security—remained assured.

The fact that a growing number of European observers now fear that this U.S. commitment is waning is among the greatest game changers in the deterrence debate. Washington’s harsh criticism of European military underperformance as well as the emergence of China as the new U.S. strategic rival have sparked European nervousness about Washington’s continued commitment to the security of the continent.26 Although the United States reacted promptly to reassure NATO’s eastern allies after Russia’s annexation of Crimea, thereby demonstrating its continued interest in European security, fears of abandonment have led to a lively discussion about European alternatives to U.S.-centric security arrangements. However, this discussion is likely to yield few tangible results. Europe remains a conglomerate of nation states of different sizes, cultures, historical experiences, and geographic outlooks. Hence, there is no European strategic culture that could form a basis for a European-only deterrence policy and posture. A U.S. exit from Europe may force some countries to explore new forms of closer defense cooperation, yet others are more likely to pursue separate bilateral deals with Washington.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.