Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

Nuclear deterrence post-ukraine avoids WMD terrorism and nuclear war

Beres 22 (Louis René Beres PhD - professor emeritus of international law at Purdue, “Nuclear War Avoidance: Why It Is Time to Start Worrying, Again”, AirUniversity, 18 March 2022, https://www.airuniversity.af.edu/Portals/10/ASOR/Journals/Volume-1_Issue-1/Beres_Nuclear_War_Avoidance.pdf, MG)

Any planetary system of law and power management that seeks to avoid nuclear war must recognize a significantly underlying axiom: as egregious crimes under international law, war and genocide need not be mutually exclusive.25 On the contrary, as one may learn from history, war could sometimes be undertaken as an efficient manner of national, ethnic, racial, or religious annihilation.26 This was almost certainly the case with respect to Germany’s World War II aggressions, crimes oriented deliberately to Adolph Hitler’s always primary war against the Jews. When the war in question becomes nuclear, the argument must become unassailable.

In light of Russia’s 2022 war against Ukraine, it is time to start worrying again about nuclear war avoidance, but this time, just worrying will not be enough. The only reasonable use for nuclear weapons on this imperiled planet will still be as controlled elements of dissuasion and never as actual weapons of war. The underlying principles of such a rational diplomatic posture go back long before the advent of nuclear weapons. In his oft-studied classic On War, ancient Chinese strategist Sun-Tzu reminds succinctly, “subjugating the enemy’s army without fighting is the true pinnacle of excellence.”27

There can be no more compelling strategic dictum. This distilled wisdom represents the “one big thing” for US strategists, commanders, and policy makers to know. It would be best not to have any enemies in the first place, of course, but such residually high hopes would be without any intellectual foundation. They would always remain unsupportable.

The unwelcome outcomes in Afghanistan and recent Russian invasion of Ukraine do not portend heightened nuclear warfare prospects per se, but they do suggest a generally widening diminution of American power. Among other things, this diminution could spawn various regional or even global crises that bring the United States into a much larger ambit of WMD scenarios, ones involving both war and terror. Even if the United States does not become involved in any such crises directly, other states or even the wider world could quickly become entangled in extremis atomicum.

Immediately, to whatever extent possible, national leaders should make all appropriate intellectual and analytic preparations for nuclear war avoidance. In carrying out this responsibility, especially careful attention should be directed to the scenarios of inadvertent nuclear war, as well as narratives pertaining both to accidental nuclear conflict and to a nuclear war resulting from miscalculation. All the while, prospects for a deliberate nuclear war should never be downplayed; preparations for credible nuclear deterrence must be continuously maintained at the highest possible levels. To meet this urgent requirement, leaders of nuclear and near-nuclear states must first acknowledge the recurrent seriousness of a global atomic threat. This is not a time for any leadership complacence. Instead, it is an optimal time to “start worrying again.”

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.