Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

Nuclear prolif is thinkable, and it’s entirely contingent on an absolute assurance that the US will provide extended nuclear deterrence

Hagel et al. 21 (Chuck Hagel - former US Secretary of Defense, Malcolm Rifkind - former UK Foreign Secretary and Secretary of Defense, Kevin Rudd - former Australian Prime Minister and Foreign Minister, “Preventing Nuclear Proliferation and Reassuring America’s Allies”, The Chicago Council on Global Affairs, 8 February 2021, https://www.thechicagocouncil.org/sites/default/files/2021-02/report_preventing-nuclear-proliferation-reassuring-americas-allies.pdf, MG)

All security partnerships between unequal partners are characterized by a dual dynamic of deterrence and reassurance. The dominant ally needs to take actions that deter the adversary and reassure its weaker ally. Of the two, reassurance is often more difficult than deterrence, especially when the dynamic plays out in the nuclear realm. For while the adversary may be deterred by even a small chance that conflict escalates to nuclear confrontation, the ally will be reassured only if it believes there is a high likelihood that the stronger partner will come to its defense. In other words, because its security is dependent on the actions of another power, an ally will always worry about its possible abandonment in time of need.

The changing security environment characterized by Russia’s return, China’s rise, North Korea’s advance, and America’s retreat accentuates the deterrence-reassurance dilemma in a new form for America’s European and Asian allies. For the first time in decades, it raises new challenges for the long-ignored nuclear dimension of their security relationships. Although renewed discussions about nuclear deterrence and reassurance have so far played out largely beyond public view inmost allied countries, the issue is becoming increasingly salient as the perceived threats to security have increased. The United States and its allies cannot ignore that reality. For if we are to prevent new nuclear proliferation among these allies, it is essential to acknowledge that what has long been unthinkable is becoming thinkable once more.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.