It’s likely - encourages nuclear preemptive strikes and breaks down alliances
Sokolski 18 (Henry D. Sokolski - executive director of the Nonproliferation Policy Education Center and served as a member of the Central Intelligence Agency’s Senior Advisory Grou on two Congressional nuclear proliferation commissions, “Underestimated: Our Not So Peaceful Nuclear Future”, Strategic Studies Institute, August 2018, https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/pdfs/AD1070596.pdf, MG)
Moreover, what the two skeptical academic camps agree on—that the dangers associated with nuclear weapons proliferation are exaggerated—is rebuttable. First, they gloss over the serious military risks faced by nations acquiring nuclear weapons. One can see this most clearly by their inattention to the numerous historical cases of preventive military actions taken against states attempting to build their first bomb and to serious plans countries have made to knock out the nuclear capabilities of new nuclear weapons states.
In the first category are: the British campaign against the Nazi-operated heavy water plant in Norway; Iran’s air strike against Iraq’s Osirak reactor in 1980; Israel’s attack of the same reactor in 1981; Iraq’s repeated strikes against Bushehr between 1984 and 1988; America’s air strike against Iraq’s nuclear facilities and Saddam’s failed Scud missile strike against Israel’s Dimona reactor in 1991; an American Tomahawk missile strike against Iraq’s uranium enrichment plant at Zaafaraniyah; British and American strikes against a variety of suspect Iraqi nuclear sites in 1998; Israel’s air strike against Syria’s covert nuclear reactor in 2007; and U.S. and Israeli covert and cyber attacks against Iran’s nuclear program from 2006 to 2010.
Just as numerous are the occasions that states planned or prepared to knock out the nuclear weapons capabilities of their adversaries. The U.S. military gave serious thought to using nuclear weapons to destroy the Soviet Union’s nuclear complex in 1949 and China’s in 1964. It also made preliminary military preparations for attacking North Korea’s nuclear complex in 1994. The Russians, meanwhile, considered attacking South African nuclear facilities in 1976 after detecting South African preparations to test. They even asked the United States for assistance in making the strike. In 1969, a major border dispute between China and Russia went hot and Moscow seriously considered attacking China’s nuclear complex. Two years before, Egypt threatened Israel’s production reactor at Dimona. Israel and India, meanwhile, cooperated in several schemes in the 1980s (one of which nearly was implemented) to knock out Pakistan’s nuclear weapons facilities at Kahuta.50
Second, while most academic skeptics believe nuclear weapons automatically deter aggression near perfectly even in small numbers, others believe nuclear weapons are militarily useless even if these weapons are numerous and advanced. Because of this, academic skeptics pay little attention to the security risks that may come with deep nuclear weapons reductions—i.e., the transitions from nuclear plenty to zero—risks, which are potentially serious.
Finally, academic skeptics tend to ignore or gloss over the risks “upward” nuclear transitions present. These dangers are three-fold. First, as the number of nuclear weapons players increases, the gravity, complexity, and likelihood of ruinous nuclear incidents may increase within states (e.g., unauthorized or accidental use, terrorist theft, irredentist seizure, etc.) and between them (e.g., catalytic wars, misread nuclear signaling, etc.). Second, and closely related, are the numerous technical and managerial challenges each nuclear state faces to make their nuclear forces robust and survivable enough to have any hope of effectively deterring attacks. These challenges are most severe for new nuclear weapons forces but are hardly inconsequential for large, mature forces.51 Last, as the number of states possessing nuclear forces increases to include nations covered by nuclear security alliance guarantees, the continued viability and coherence of these alliance systems are likely to be tested in the extreme, increasing the prospects for war.52