Tests prove nuclear proliferation outweighs and turns climate change
Toon et al. 21 (Owen B. Toon PhD - Professor in the Department of Atmospheric and Oceanic Sciences at the University of Colorado, Alan Robock PhD - American climatologist and currently a Distinguished Professor in the Department of Environmental Sciences at Rutgers University , Richard P. Turco - American atmospheric scientist, and Professor at the Institute of the Environment, Department of Atmospheric and Oceanic Sciences, University of California, “Modelling Armageddon: The effects of nuclear weapons on climate”, Open Access Government, 11 May 2021, https://www.openaccessgovernment.org/modelling-armageddon-the-effects-of-nuclear-weapons-on-climate/109988/, MG)
Obviously, all of these factors could never be determined precisely beforehand. Even so, enough work has been done – exhaustively in many areas – to define the boundaries of the problem. For example, the damages inflicted by a nuclear blast and prompt radiation are relatively well understood from more than 500 above-ground weapons tests conducted from the 1940s through the 1960s. Also known are the incendiary effects of nuclear bursts, but these are less well known partly because testing was not as focused on this aspect of nuclear weapons. Understanding the climate changes that might result from smoke produced by nuclear fires requires knowledge of the types and amounts of fuel consumed, the quantities and forms of black carbon (the highly absorbing component of smoke) generated, and the fraction of that black carbon deposited in the upper atmosphere, where it could reside for years.
As each of these questions is slowly being resolved, the overall uncertainty in the outcome of nuclear war is steadily being reduced. New evidence, for example, from large forest fires in Canada (2017) and Australia (2020) reveals that smoke from intense fires is readily lofted into the stratosphere. There, without rain to remove it, smoke can be tracked by satellites over many months, and its distribution analysed using the same models employed to predict global changes following a nuclear war, including nuclear winter. The behaviour of the wildfire smoke mimics that predicted for massive smoke injections expected from nuclear-ignited firestorms, including alterations in wind patterns and air temperatures3. Moreover, newer simulations of historical volcanic eruptions also indicate similar effects – such as the “year without a summer” that followed the Tambora eruption of 1815 – and which was noted by Ronald Reagan as a reason to fear a nuclear winter.
Recently, we employed these same models to simulate the possible outcome of a regional-scale nuclear conflict between India and Pakistan, perhaps triggered by their continuing disputes over Kashmir. Remarkably, even such a limited use of nuclear weapons could lead to the coldest global temperatures recorded in the last 1,000 years4, resulting in a reduction in worldwide crop yields by tens of percent5.
It is generally agreed that the only legitimate reason for maintaining substantial arsenals of nuclear weapons is to avoid war. Nevertheless, the existence of such weapons and the robust means to use them, implies that global nuclear conflict cannot be dismissed as impossible or even improbable. And unlike global warming, which has been decades and centuries in the making, nuclear warfare could play out in mere hours or days. But the consequences would last years, shatter civilization, and create climatic anomalies comparable to a sudden ice age, leading to deprivation on a global scale6, possibly affecting billions of individuals. Leadership must do everything in its power to ensure that nuclear weapons can never be used, including actionable treaties on arms reductions, national policies to increase weapon security, and international diplomacy to stop and reverse nuclear proliferation.