Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

Nuclear extended deterrence does nothing to prevent nuke prolif – Turkey and Germany prove

Sauer and van der Zwaan 12 (Tom Sauer - Assistant Professor in International Politics at the University of Antwerp , Bob van der Zwaan - Senior Scientist at the Energy Research Centre of the Netherlands in Amsterdam, “US Tactical Nuclear Weapons in Europe after NATO’s Lisbon Summit: Why their Withdrawal is Desirable and Feasible”, International Relations, 2012, https://www.isodarco.it/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/tacnukes_Sauer_VDZ_in_IR-2012.pdf, MG)

Extended deterrence as a brake against further nuclear proliferation Some experts claim that thanks to US nuclear weapons stationed in Europe some host nations have agreed not to develop their own nuclear weapons.53 The states most cited are Turkey and, to a lesser extent, Germany. This argument, however, is flawed. In NATO there is no proof that it was extended deterrence that prevented nuclear proliferation. Germany is legally bound not to develop nuclear weapons because of its constitution, and German public opinion has always been very much anti-nuclear. According to Harald Müller, observers regularly underestimate how deeply rooted Germany’s non-nuclear status is in its political culture:

Any German government that sought to effect a change in the country’s nuclear status would risk public protest ranging all the way up to civil-war-style conditions compared to which the events surrounding the shifting of Castor [civilian nuclear spent fuel] containers would probably appear trivial.54

The 2011 German decision to close all German nuclear reactors is another indication of the German anti-nuclear political culture.

Likewise, it is also doubtful whether Turkey would have developed its own nuclear weapons if the United States had not stationed them in the country. There is increasing pressure today to create a Nuclear Weapon Free Zone in the Middle East, as formally declared during the NPT Review Conference in May 2010. This is pushing Turkey to rethink its current policy vis-à-vis US nuclear weapons based on its territory. More and more Turkish experts are in favor of withdrawal.55 In the unlikely case that the Turkish government believed that possessing nuclear weapons was of vital interest for the nation, it is doubtful whether the presence of the remaining number of US nuclear weapons would really makes any difference in its calculation.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.