Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Hegemonic masculinity was a precondition to the universalization of liberal economic subjectivity

Burke 2002. (Anthony, School of Political Science and International Studies, University of Queensland, Alternatives: Global, Local, Political 27.1, InfoTrac OneFile)

These insights have direct relevance to the international conduct of states. Christine Sylvester has argued that there is a pernicious "normativity of sex" structuring international relations, while Tickner argues that statecraft is dominated by an image of "hegemonic masculinity" that is "sustained through its opposition to various subordinated and devalued masculinities such as homosexuality . . . and through its relation to various devalued feminities." In international policy, the characteristics of hegemonic masculinity "are projected onto the behaviour of states whose success as international actors is measured in terms of their power capabilities and capacity for self-help and autonomy." (53) What this achieves is a whole series of exclusions (and norms of action) based on the dichotomy between masculine and feminine. This generates a chain of analogous oppositions that align maleness with reason, activity, objective truth, and the mind, and woman with passion, passivity, subjective truth, and the body--realms and values constructed as perpetually threatening, backward, and disruptive. By then aligning these with two other crucial dichotomies--between savage and civilized, and the commonwealth and the state of nature--this chain of oppositions gives life to the progressive movement of being central to a post-Enlightenment politics of security. In the liberal chain that links subjectivity, economy, and geopolitics, gender is simultaneously a work on the self, a principle for the participation of individuals in society, and one for the conduct of the state in managing subject populations and constructing geopolitical space. Hegemonic masculinity has also been crucial to universalizing the liberal mode of economic subjectivity based around the subjugation, control, and exploitation of nature--with the implicit exclusion of other possible modes of economic life. (54) A pivotal figure here is Descartes, whose philosophical account of method and the division between mind and body has underpinned many characteristics of the modern liberal order: its obsession with political and epistemological certitude (stability and equilibrium), the vision of nature implicit in modern economics, and the control and production of international space. Genevieve Lloyd emphasizes how the separation of mind and body was essential to his vision of a "unitary pure thought" t hat secured the foundations of modern science, yet simultaneously separated it from the rest of life. Lloyd also draws out the links between Cartesian method and Hegel's association of male attainments with universality. Maleness becomes a technical attribute achieved by breaking away from the nature associated with woman, and thus analogous to modern theories of technological, political, and economic progress based on the manipulation and control of nature. (55)

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.