Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Turn – the aff’s investment in the ballot as a recognition of their personhood invokes the logic that a loss signifies the denial of black personhood – this lends the liberal notion that black people are responsible to prove themselves subjects, which in turns places the black in a position of blameworthiness and indebtedness. This legitimizes the commodification of the black body and turns the case

Hartman 1997. (Saidiya, Associate prof of English at Cal Berk. Scenes of Subjection p. 125-6)

Emancipation announced the end of chattel slavery; however, it by no means marked the end of bondage. The free(d) individual was nothing if not burdened, responsible, and obligated. Responsibility entailed accounting for one's actions, dutiful suppliance, contractual obligation, and calculated reciprocity. Fundamentally, to be responsible was to be blameworthy. In this respect, the exercise of free will, quite literally, was inextricable from guilty infractions, criminal misdeeds, punishable transgressions, and an elaborate micropenality of everyday life. Responsibility made man an end in himself, and as such, the autonomous and intending agent was above all else culpable. As Friedrich Nietzsche observed: "The proud realization of the extraordinary privilege of responsibility, the awareness of this rare freedom and power over himself and his destiny, has penetrated him to the depths and become an instinct, his dominant instinct: what will he call his dominant instinct, assuming that he needs a word for it? No doubt about the answer: this sovereign man calls it his conscience.'' 1 In this regard, the burden of conscience attendant to the formation of the sovereign individual was decisive not only in the ways that it facilitated self-disciplining but also in its ability to engender resentment toward and justify the punishment of those who fell below "the threshold of responsibility" or failed to achieve the requisite degree of self-control. 2 The onus of accountability that rested upon the shoulders of the self-responsible individual-the task of proving oneself worthy of freedom-combined with the undue hardships of emancipation engendered an anomalous condition betwixt and between slavery and freedom, for in this case the individual was not only tethered by the bonds of conscience and duty and obliged by the ascetic imperatives of restraint and self-reliance but also literally constrained within a mixed-labor system in which contract was the vehicle of servitude and accountability was inseparable from peonage. Moreover, the guilty volition enjoyed by the free agent bore an uncanny resemblance to the only form of agency legally exercised by the enslaved-that is, criminal liability. Responsibility and restraint all too easily yielded to a condition of involuntary servitude, and culpability. inevitably gave way to indebtedness. The emergence of what I term "indebted servitude" is the subject of this chapter. 1 use the term "indebted servitude" to amplify the constraints of conscience (discipline internalized and lauded as a virtue), the coercion and compulsion of the free labor system, and the ''grafting of morality onto economics'' in the making of the dutiful free laborer and similarly lo illuminate the elasticity of debt in effecting peonage and other forms of involuntary servitude.' According to Nietzsche, the feelings of guilt, obligation, and responsibility originated in the relations~ip of creditor and debtor; moreover, debt as the measure of morality sanctions the 'imposition of punishment; debt serves to reinscribe both servitude and the pained constitution of blackness. 4 A telling example of this calculation of conscience or the entanglement of debt and duty can be found in Jared Bell Waterbury's Advice to a Young Christian. Here the duty of self-examination is compared to bookkeeping: "Let the duty [of selfexamination] be duly and thoroughly performed, and we rise to the standard of the skilful fsicJ and prudent merchant, who duly records every ilem of business; who never closes his counting-house until his balance sheet is made up~ and who, by a single reference, can tell the true state of his accounts, and form a correct esti1nate of his co1nmercial standing. "5 In the case of the freed, the cultivation of conscience operated in the whip's stead as an overseer of the soul, although the use of compulsion was routinely employed against those seemingly remiss in their duties. As it turned out, the encumbrance of freedom made one not only blameworthy and vulnerable to hardship and affliction in the name of interest but also, surprisingly, no less susceptible to the correctives of coercion and constraint.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.