Baudrillard destroys feminist projects
Ebert 5 (Teresa, Professor of Humanities at the College of Arts and Sciences at the University at Albany who specializes in Critical and Cultural Theory, Feminist Critique, Marxist Theory and Globalization Theory, “Rematerializing Feminism” http://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/40404228.pdf) //Don Markos
Beyond the "End of Ideology " In postmodern social theory, especially in the work of Ernesto Laclau and Chantal Mouffe, ideology is seen as undergoing a "break." In their writings, Laclau and Mouffe, through a heavy reliance on Lacan and Althusser, have erased the materialist theory of ideology articulated in Marx and Engels' The German Ideology and more em- phatically reiterated in Marx's own Capital In order to dramatize the break, they have reduced the classical Marxist theory of ideology to a simple "false consciousness" and with great fanfare have represented Althusserian and post-Althusserian views as groundbreaking concep- tual feats. Ideology after this "break" has become a generalized rep resentation from which no one can escape and in which everyone is condemned to live their social being. One of the consequences of this notion of ideology, of course, has been its erasure of the rigid clarity of class antagonisms and any other binaries (such as true/false, powerful/powerless, exploitative/emancipatory) . This paradox - that in a world in which ideology is one of the fundamental axes of identity and social processes, intellectuals have declared it ended - is caused by the fact that the regime of social relations of production, which the Marxist tradition has explained by the concept of ideology, has not only not ended but instead has intensified its hold on the subject. The most effective way to disentangle the contemporary impasse on ideology is to re-understand the materialist theory of ideology. Ideology has a very specific and materialist meaning in the Marxist tradition, especially in Marx's Capital (in which, curiously, it has be- come common to say that the notion of ideology was abandoned by Marx). In various chapters of Capital (especially chapters 1, 6, 9, 10, 1 1 and 12), Marx explains the process by which the worker exchanges his/her labor-power for wages. In chapter ten he explains the pre- cise mechanism of the working day, during which the worker pro- duces the equivalent of his wages and also surplus labor. In chapter six he theorizes the difference between labor and labor-power and concludes that labor-power is that particular "commodity whose use- value possess the peculiar property of being a source of value, whose actual consumption is therefore itself an objectification of labor, hence a creation of value" (1977, 270). The exchange, he concludes, between the capitalist and the worker is an exchange of labor-power for wages. This exchange is represented in bourgeois theory as a free, unfettered and equal exchange. In fact, at the end of chapter six, Marx makes a point of dwelling on this "free-trader vulgaris" view of the exchange of wages for labor-power; he concludes that it is anything but an equal exchange - it leaves the worker, Marx notes, "like some- one who has brought his own hide to market and now has nothing else to expect but - a tanning" (1977, 280). The historical materialist concept of ideology seeks to account for the representations of this exchange as an equal and fair ex- change. This, I want to emphasize, is the core of the materialist theory of ideology: how the relation between wage-labor and capital is rep- resented as free and equal when it is anything but (it is "a tanning") . False consciousness (the bête noir of postmodern theories of ideology) is a "struggle concept" (to adopt Maria Mies' term) by which a mate- rialist understanding marks the consciousness that regards this ex- change to be an exchange among equals and conducted in freedom. It is a false consciousness, because it is seen as unfettered and un- coerced when, in fact, as Marx himself argues, this exchange takes place under "the silent compulsion of economic relations" - a com- pulsion that "sets the seal on the domination of the capitalist over the worker" (Marx, 1977, 899). False consciousness is the conscious- ness that misrecognizes the compulsion of economic relations as free and therefore accepts the exchange of wages for labor-power as equal. Even a quick look at the post-Althusserian theories of ideology will make clear that, far from being groundbreaking theories, the postmodern notion of ideology is simply an erasure of the material- ist theory of ideology and a marginalization of the role of labor. It ends up essentially legitimizing the relation between wage-labor and capital. To say, as postmodern theories of ideology say over and over again, that there is no space outside ideology is to say that it is impos- sible to mark any relation as a relation of inequality. Because to say that the exchange of wages for labor-power is unequal, according to postmodern theory, is to set up a "true" {i.e., "equal") relation. This is "wrong," according to postmodern theory, because it establishes a binary in which a truthful relation masters a false relation. But this is exactly what happens under capitalism. The relation between wage- labor and capital is an unequal relation, and to simply say that draw- ing attention to its inequality is to fall into binaries is to substitute bourgeois epistemology for social justice. Ideology is not epistemol- ogy: to try to make ideology part of epistemology and then decon- struct it through a maneuver in which right and wrong, correct and incorrect, truthful and untruthful are pitted against each other is to simply relegitimate capitalist relations. The crisis we are witnessing now in the theory of ideology is the crisis of this legitimization of an unjust relation in the discourses of intellectuals who, in their formal theories, declare themselves to be anti-capitalist and friends of the people.